1840 Tavern

Name: 1840 Tavern
Address: 1 Strawtown Rd, West Nyack, New York, 10994, US
Telephone: (845) 675-8550
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Bar & Grill, Irish Pub

Hours:
1 Strawtown Rd, West Nyack
(845) 675-8550

Menu Order Online

About 1840 Tavern

1840 Tavern is a neighborhood bar and restaurant that serves excellent food at reasonable prices. Their 1840 ale is one of the customer's favorites. The establishment has a family-friendly atmosphere with patio seating available in good weather, and parking is never an issue. The food at 1840 Tavern is highly praised, with the NY strip steak being cooked perfectly and served with carrots, asparagus, and mashed potatoes. The service is attentive and friendly, and the restaurant seems to be a local favorite, with a "Cheers-like" vibe where everyone knows your name.

Customers describe 1840 Tavern as a wonderful, homie-type tavern with solid food choices and great drink options, including three different IPAs. The bartenders are attentive, accommodating, and professional, creating a good overall vibe. The restaurant offers a better-than-average burger and sweet potato fries, along with a tasty chicken pot pie and a shrimp dish with pasta. The dessert menu is very attractive, featuring special treats like brown butter cake with maple walnut ice cream. Many guests have enjoyed the live music and the cozy ambiance, whether sitting indoors or outside. The staff consistently provides excellent service, and the owner often stops by to ensure everyone’s experience is on point. Visitors often find 1840 Tavern to be a hidden gem with a friendly, welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite spot in the area.