Restaurants near West Sayville

Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House 469 Main St, West Sayville Ice Cream Shop • $
469 Main St, West Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Italian Ice
Cherry Italian Ice

“This is a quaint little ice cream shoppe. The Ice cream is tasty. The servers were very pleasant and there is a warm atmosphere about the place. We will definitely be back.”

4.7 Superb59 Reviews
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods 229 Montauk Hwy, West Sayville Bakery • $$
229 Montauk Hwy, West Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
Birthday Cake

“My family and I have used Audrey’s for years and have also recommended it to my friend for their wedding and engagement party. They do not disappoint and truly make your cake dreams come true. Not only do the decorations on the cake look amazing but it tastes even better. I will always come back to this bakery (even though I am not local)”

4.4 Superb156 Reviews
The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville NY 21 Main St, West Sayville American • $$
21 Main St, West Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Sandwiches
Cobb Salad
Eggs Benedict
Shed Bowl
Short Rib Sandwich
Short Rib Melt
blt
Breakfast Bowl
Fish Sandwich
Sausage

“The restaurant food and service was very good. However, no one likes to be served a martini in a champagne glass. It’s like drinking out of a bowl of soup. You should serve your martinis in the proper glasses.”

4.4 Superb366 Reviews
Kingston's Clam Bar 130 Atlantic Ave, West Sayville Seafood • $$
130 Atlantic Ave, West Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Crab Roll
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Baked Clams
Clams and Oysters on the Half Shell
Crab Cakes
Fried Shrimp
Garlic Bread
Stuffed Shrimp
Cold Lobster Roll with Fries

“Best lobster roll ever! The bartender confirmed what I already knew! ❤️You have a great staff! They believe in your restaurant and in your products! We will be back! 100/10 experience no seat is ever a bad seat at Kingstons ❤️”

4.2 Good187 Reviews
The State Room 67 W Main St 2nd floor, Patchogue Gastropubs • $$$
67 W Main St 2nd floor, Patchogue - 4.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dessert
Beef Tartare
Salads
Gulf Shrimp
Hanger Steak
Bolognese
Tapas
Cocktail Hour
Beet Hummus
Honey Bear

“Decor is intimate but light enough to see yourself.

Drinks were diverse and fantastic. There will always be something new since they’re seasonal. Cheese platter paired perfectly with more herbal drinks.”

4.9 Superb116 Reviews
Taco Island Mexican Cantina 2320 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville Mexican • $
2320 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville - 7.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Island Shrimp Taco
Crunch Taco
Avocado Taco
Chicken Quesadilla
Mexican Street Taco
Birria Pizza
Sweet Plantains
Salsa Verde
Classic Taco
Chipotle Sauce

“I love your pizza de birria barbacoa. so much flavor. cooked perfectly. big portions. your tostada's with steak perfection. I literally ordered for my first time today for lunch in person with my boyfriend and once we got home ordered again for dinner to try something different. the staff are friendly and efficient. thank you for a great dining experience keep up the great work.”

4.9 Superb265 Reviews
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ 41 NY-111, Smithtown Barbeque • $$
41 NY-111, Smithtown - 9.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soup
Steak
Cake
BBQ and Hot Pot
Spicy Hot Pot
Seafood
Crab Legs
Miso
Brisket
Sauce Station

“I have been going to the Bay Shore, NY location for at least 6 months now and can't recommend it enough. I went with several of my co workers a few nights ago and DEO was awesome to have as a waiter. He was funny and super helpful.”

4.8 Superb368 Reviews
The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant 154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point American • $$
154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point - 4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cucumber Cream Cheese
Pot of Tea
Tea Pot
Chicken Tenders
Afternoon Tea Tier
Cheesecake
Mozzarella Sticks
Blueberry
Egg Salad
Tuna Salad

“Very relaxing cozy tea room, delicious deserts and finger sandwiches, many teas to choose”

4.9 Superb217 Reviews
Osteria Umbra 197 Terry Rd, Smithtown Italian • $$$$
197 Terry Rd, Smithtown - 8.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Calamari
Lamb Chops
Zucchini Flowers
Veal Chop
Pistachio Gelato
Tomahawk Steak
Beef Carpaccio
Panna Cotta
Truffle Fries
Walnut Pesto Ravioli

“Yes!, but I have been there a few times all have been great but this last time. The food was salty. I mean every dish. We spoke to manager who was extremely nice. Apologize and did the right thing. But I will go back for sure”

4.7 Superb724 Reviews
Hummus Mediterranean Holbrook 1066 Main St, Holbrook Mediterranean • $
1066 Main St, Holbrook - 5.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Topping
Rice Bowl
Lamb Gyro
Salad Bowl
Tzatziki Chicken
Side of Pita
Baklava
Salad Bar
Steak Gyro

“I eat here everyday I love the muffins the atmosphere the food and the staff. I would recommend this place to anyone that enjoys good food. Cant forget about the muffins the milk cereal muffin hands down the best thing you will ever eat

Kid-friendliness: Staff always welcomes me and everyone is very nice”

4.8 Superb369 Reviews
11

RHUM

RHUM 13 E Main St, Patchogue Caribbean • $$
13 E Main St, Patchogue - 5.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp
Duck Empanadas
Island Burger
Steak
Tuna Burger
Jerk Chicken
Chicken Taco
Fish Tacos
Buffalo Soldier Taco
Caesar Salad

“Went here for brunch today for first time. Friendly staff!! Atmosphere was great! Our waiter was very friendly made us feel good from start to finish. Food was very good! Thank you for being the great place we hoped for. Our waiter was Danyeal, very nice young man!!!”

4.6 Superb273 Reviews
The Barbeque King 371 Lakeland Ave, Sayville Barbeque • $$$
371 Lakeland Ave, Sayville - 1.98 miles

“What a pleasure to be able to enjoy our own party from start to finish! Keith was a pleasure to work with planning the event and his staff were absolutely amazing from set up, preparation serving and clean up! The abundance of delicious food and amazing selection made the party! Everyone was asking “who are these guys I need their number!” We cannot express our happiness enough and look forward to our next event with them! Thank you Keith and crew!”

5 Superb177 Reviews
Halal Munchies 142 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip Halal • $
142 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip - 7.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wings
White Sauce
French Fries
Philly Cheesesteak
Seasoned Fries
Chopped Cheese
Lamb Gyro
Fish Sandwich
Cheese Fries
Mix Combo Platter

“The food was absolutely delicious. The portion sizes were generous, leaving me completely satisfied. On top of that, the service was fast, ensuring that we never waited long for anything. I highly recommend this place.”

4.8 Superb204 Reviews
FLAME HALAL GYRO 499 Sunrise Hwy #76, Patchogue Fast Food • $
499 Sunrise Hwy #76, Patchogue - 4.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Sauce
Baklava
Lamb over Rice
Combo over Rice
Chicken Gyro
BBQ Wings
Lamb on Rice
Tomato Chicken on Rice
Buffalo Wings
BBQ Sauce

“The best chicken and rice spot in the area. Absolutely delicious, chicken and lamb is so juicy and fresh, everything tastes fresh, not heavy or oily. It is very well seasoned, it’s just the best. Also the owner is super friendly and nice. Can’t recommend this place enough!”

4.9 Superb214 Reviews
TIESTOS RESTAURANT 411 W Main St, Patchogue Latin American • $$
411 W Main St, Patchogue - 4.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Quesadillas
Salad
Nachos
Tacos
Bandeja Paisa
Chaulafan
Paella
Fajitas
Shrimp Ceviche
Clams

“I was brought here for my birthday highly recoommended fantastic.Will be back”

4.6 Superb130 Reviews
Yume Ramen and Cake 350-4 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove Ramen • $
350-4 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove - 9.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Vegan Ramen
Pork Buns
Tofu Buns
Miso Soup
Bento Box A
Takoyaki
Egg Fried Rice
Spicy Miso Chicken Ramen
Original Pork Tonkotsu
Spicy Miso Pork Tonkotsu

“The guy that was handing out free samples was very joyous and the fried chicken was so good that I am genuinely burping purposely to taste it again. I will definitely be back.”

4.8 Superb200 Reviews
Mazza Mediterranean Cuisine 58d S Ocean Ave, Patchogue Afghan • $$
58d S Ocean Ave, Patchogue - 5.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Falafel
Hummus
Potatoes
Lamb Kebab
Greek Salad
Aushak
Greek Food
Chicken Kebab
Octopus
Spanakopita

“This place is a hidden gem! The food was deliciously authentic and the kind of fresh you only get when you’re actually in the Mediterranean. This will definitely be my new go to restaurant for family and friends!”

4.8 Superb182 Reviews
Hummus Fit 200 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma Health Food • $
200 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 6.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baked Herbed Tilapia 1 lb Competition-Approved
Buffalo Mac N Chicken
Falafel Plate
Arnold 2022 Bowl
Crispy Vegan Wrap
Taco Poblano Bowl
Cheeseburger Bowl
Baja Chicken Tacos
Pulled BBQ Chicken Bowl
Competition-Approved Lemon Pepper Salmon 1 lb

“Besides the product being excellent the customer service is amazing. Had an issues with delivery and they were quick to respond and correct the problem! This product is worth every penny and the excellent customer service is a huge bonus.”

4.9 Superb129 Reviews
The Tiki Bar At Sunset Harbour 90 Colonial Dr, East Patchogue American • $$
90 Colonial Dr, East Patchogue - 6.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Tacos
Shrimp Ceviche
Tiki Crab Cake
Wedge Salad
Cheeseburger
Burger with Fries
Lobster Ravioli
Onion Ring
Key Lime Pie
Clams on the

“I love the atmosphere and the food and cocktails! I haven’t been for a very long time. I am handicap, I use a walker and sometimes a wheelchair and your place is not accessible The ramp is steep and you cannot get to the rest rooms. I’m sure you don’t have many complaints regarding this issue, but I would love to be able to enjoy your tiki bar/ restaurant once again. Thank you !”

4.8 Superb220 Reviews
Chachama Grill 655 Montauk Hwy, East Patchogue American • $$$
655 Montauk Hwy, East Patchogue - 6.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Rubio
Burrata
Crab Cake
Chocolate Cake
Beef Empanadas
Warm Rice Pudding
Black Sea Bass Ceviche
Coconut Flan
Gnocchi
Chocolate Vanilla Crème Brûlée

“I love Chachamas. The staff is outstanding. The food is amazing. I had the rack of lamb with Risotto. Absolutely delicious 😋 I highly recommend Chachamas 100%. You will not regret it. It may be your favorite restaurant to eat at!”

4.7 Superb314 Reviews
Glenn Wayne Bakery 1800 Arctic Ave, Bohemia Bakery • $
1800 Arctic Ave, Bohemia - 3.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Donuts
Apple Fritters
Croissants
Boston Cream
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Strawberry
Cupcakes
Chocolate Glazed Donut
Key Lime Pie Donut
Assorted Pastries

“Yummy treats and great variety that’s fun!”

4.8 Superb296 Reviews
George Martin's Strip Steak 60 River Rd, Great River Steak House • $$$$
60 River Rd, Great River - 3.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster
Popovers
Creamed Spinach
Banana Pudding
Tomahawk
Seafood
Calamari
Caesar Salad
Petite Filet Mignon
Burrata

“Enjoy every time we go delicious”

4.6 Superb606 Reviews
Salad-icious 83 E Main St, Smithtown Salad • $
83 E Main St, Smithtown - 10.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Salad
Craisin the Sea Crunch Wrap
Create Your Own Bowl
Avo blt Wrap
Kale Ceasar

“we came in today with our entire family and ordered what feels like everything off the menu! What an absolutely wonderful place! The staff really seems to enjoy working there and the food was out of this world. Everything tastes so fresh and healthy, but it doesn’t skimp on taste. I got to meet the owner, Mike, and he seems to be kind of person who really cares about customer satisfaction and providing the best experience. I very very strongly recommend this place!”

4.9 Superb92 Reviews
Maria's Pizza Bistro 2060 Ocean Ave, Ronkonkoma Bistros • $
2060 Ocean Ave, Ronkonkoma - 4.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Zeppole with Nutella
Buffalo Chicken
Garlic Knots
Specialty Slice
Meat Lovers
Garden Salad
Grandma Pizza
Southwestern Sandwich Breakfast
Meat Pizza
Large Pizza

“Great pizza!!! Great people!!!”

4.9 Superb91 Reviews
Hummus Fit 680 Middle Country Rd, Selden Mediterranean • $
680 Middle Country Rd, Selden - 10.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Overnight Oats
Tzatziki Chicken Salad
Spicy Tzatziki Sauce
Steak Gyro Sandwich
Shrimp Salad Bowl
Cheeseburger Bowl
Chicken Gyro
Rice Bowl
Falafel

“Besides the product being excellent the customer service is amazing. Had an issues with delivery and they were quick to respond and correct the problem! This product is worth every penny and the excellent customer service is a huge bonus.”

4.8 Superb207 Reviews
il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante 260 Islip Ave, Islip Italian • $$$
260 Islip Ave, Islip - 5.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baked Clams
Panna Cotta
Ravioli Al Pomodoro
Lamb Chops
Chicken Parm
Zuppa Di Pesce
Calamari Fritti
Insalata Caprese
Pappardelle Alla Bolognese Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes
Orecchiette Alla Barese with Broccoli Rabe Sausage & Garlic Oil

“These guys are the best! They make you feel like a king when you walk in and treat you like family! God bless 🇺🇸”

4.8 Superb207 Reviews
Ruta Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine 30 E Main St, Patchogue Mexican • $$
30 E Main St, Patchogue - 5.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chips and Salsa
Coffee Flan
Quesadillas
Ceviche
Beef Short Ribs
Grilled Octopus
Calamari
Fish Tacos
Chicken Bunuelos
Shrimp Tacos

“Just wanted to share that this is one of my favorite spots to eat & have a few cocktails. The food is always incredible and the staff are attentive & friendly. I’ve eaten here several times and have loved it each time.”

4.6 Superb296 Reviews
Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen 1315 Middle Country Rd Ste 5, Centereach Ice Cream Shop • $$
1315 Middle Country Rd Ste 5, Centereach - 9.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut
Caramel Crunch
Pints
Root Beer Float
Cherry Amaretto
Kulfi
Dream Ice Cream
Campfire S'Mores
Ice Cream Taco
Chocolate Chips Dark Choc Sauce

“Love the flavor selection and the waffle cone chips are the bomb! I get mine to go in a cup and use them instead of a spoon! 😋 My son raves about the campfire smores flavor! 🔥 🍫”

4.8 Superb116 Reviews
Tico's Empanadas 55 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point Latin American • $
55 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point - 3.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tostones
Buffalo Chicken
Yuca Fries
Beef and Cheese
Rice and Beans
Cheeseburger
Chicken and Cheese
BBQ Chicken
Loaded Baked Potato
Sweet Plantains

“Amazing Food. Authentic flavors delicious..”

4.8 Superb121 Reviews
The Shabby Tabby Cat Cafe 197 W Main St, Sayville Cafe • $$
197 W Main St, Sayville - 0.73 miles

“I had a very upsetting and unsafe experience with this business. During our visit, my young daughter was bitten by their cat. What should have been treated with urgency and genuine conncern was instead brushed off- both the over and her employee responded with sarcasm and dismissiveness when I voiced my frustration. I had to make multiple requests to speak to the owner in regards to this incident-yet during a later phone call, she admitted she had been there the entire time. This kind of avoidance is extremely unprofessional, especially when a child's safety is at risk. Due to the bite, my daughter required a medical evaluation and treatment, resulting in medical expenses. I had mailed the ower receipts of the co-pays and requested a refund of my daughter's medical co-pays which i still haven't received. Allowing an animal that bites to be around customers, especially children poses a serious safety risk. The lack of professionalism, empathy and accountability is how this situation was handled is unacceptable. Then to my surprise, this compmay enjoys mocking their customers on TikTok videos. One wasn't made of my daughter, but these video's paint a clear picture of how the owner, Ryan and her employee's think of their loyal customers. I cannot recommend this business nor-even give it one star!”

4.7 Superb220 Reviews

Get more info in our app

Download app for free

Open