In the vast ocean of Western New York pizzerias, Main Street Pizzeria stands as a lighthouse for those of us questing for that perfect slice. The secret to their standout pizza? It begins with the crust - golden, with just the right crunch to softness ratio, it's a foundation strong enough to bear the weight of any topping yet delicate enough to meld seamlessly into every bite. The staff at Main Street Pizzeria are not just employees; they are custodians of quality, ensuring every visit is as welcoming as it is satisfying. Add to this mix their commitment to quality ingredients, and you have a recipe for success. Whether it's the vibrant sauce, the perfectly melted cheese, or the fresh, flavorful toppings, Main Street Pizzeria knows that quality is not just an ingredient but the main ingredient. From the moment you step in, it's clear: this isn't just another pizza place. It's a community staple where every slice is crafted with care, and every visit leaves you planning the next. If you're in search of a great pizza, look no further. Main Street Pizzeria doesn't just make pizza; they make memories, one slice at a time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Charlie McNeely
Delicious pizza. Fast, friendly service. You will love it. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
David Reynolds
Great service and excellent sandwiches!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Usef Meloned
As a local everyone knows me. Amazing pizza no matter what you get and never too busy. Definitely visit here for lunch if visiting Youngstown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
Eli Storrer
Cool people serving, visiting from out of town I went to see the Old Niagara Fort and felt so hungry afterwards. Got some of this Main Street Pizzeria Pizza and it was delicious, the service was nice, and I'm glad to have had the experience of eating here. Might look a little shabby, but it has a good atmosphere if you try it out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Pizza
Mark Wells
Not necessarily on the beaten path, although it is on the main street of a small town, this has to be what I would consider a hidden gem. Every morsel of food we tried was delicious. Any pizza you choose will be delicious, wings done exquisitely, and a meatball sub crafted with perfection.You can't go wrong with anything here.Top notch friendliness and service. The owner of this place went above and beyond make us feel welcomed and satisfied.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
David Swoope
Great pizza crust is great specialty pizzas are good to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aidan Hosie
Food is spectacular, but the inconsistencies in hours and days open is very upsetting. Multiple sources online shows different operating times/days, and they often close early without warning.
Rōbi Ventures (Rōbi Ventures)
This is a place that shouldn’t be missed if your in the area visiting. Don’t let the fact that it’s on the other side of a gas station steer you away. The food is delicious. The guys were super nice that helped us with our orders. We ordered a Calzone and a Stromboli and each of us had leftovers for another meal each.
Desales Berak
Very clean. Convenient location. Good food. Polite and professional staff. Fair price. What more could you ask for?
We ordered 2 steak grass no oil or anything on very dry barely any spinach cold roll .grandson pizza burned
ann janik
I love Main Street Pizzeria, has never got my order wrong. Delicious and perfect everytime
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charly Stevens
We may joke about the gas station pizza, but don't knock it till you try it. I've eaten there for years and never had a bad pizza, sub or otherwise, don't hesitate they will definitely surprise you.
P H
Pizza is consistently really good. Their salads are generously sized with fresh lettuce.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Stuckey
There are a lot of pizza places in this whole region, and for a little place in a little village they are mighty good! Don’t overthink your decision, call them and get a half try and wings!
In the vast ocean of Western New York pizzerias, Main Street Pizzeria stands as a lighthouse for those of us questing for that perfect slice. The secret to their standout pizza? It begins with the crust - golden, with just the right crunch to softness ratio, it's a foundation strong enough to bear the weight of any topping yet delicate enough to meld seamlessly into every bite. The staff at Main Street Pizzeria are not just employees; they are custodians of quality, ensuring every visit is as welcoming as it is satisfying. Add to this mix their commitment to quality ingredients, and you have a recipe for success. Whether it's the vibrant sauce, the perfectly melted cheese, or the fresh, flavorful toppings, Main Street Pizzeria knows that quality is not just an ingredient but the main ingredient. From the moment you step in, it's clear: this isn't just another pizza place. It's a community staple where every slice is crafted with care, and every visit leaves you planning the next. If you're in search of a great pizza, look no further. Main Street Pizzeria doesn't just make pizza; they make memories, one slice at a time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Delicious pizza. Fast, friendly service. You will love it. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Great service and excellent sandwiches!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a local everyone knows me. Amazing pizza no matter what you get and never too busy. Definitely visit here for lunch if visiting Youngstown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
Cool people serving, visiting from out of town I went to see the Old Niagara Fort and felt so hungry afterwards. Got some of this Main Street Pizzeria Pizza and it was delicious, the service was nice, and I'm glad to have had the experience of eating here. Might look a little shabby, but it has a good atmosphere if you try it out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Pizza
Not necessarily on the beaten path, although it is on the main street of a small town, this has to be what I would consider a hidden gem. Every morsel of food we tried was delicious. Any pizza you choose will be delicious, wings done exquisitely, and a meatball sub crafted with perfection.You can't go wrong with anything here.Top notch friendliness and service. The owner of this place went above and beyond make us feel welcomed and satisfied.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
Great pizza crust is great specialty pizzas are good to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is spectacular, but the inconsistencies in hours and days open is very upsetting. Multiple sources online shows different operating times/days, and they often close early without warning.
This is a place that shouldn’t be missed if your in the area visiting. Don’t let the fact that it’s on the other side of a gas station steer you away. The food is delicious. The guys were super nice that helped us with our orders. We ordered a Calzone and a Stromboli and each of us had leftovers for another meal each.
Very clean. Convenient location. Good food. Polite and professional staff. Fair price. What more could you ask for?
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered 2 steak grass no oil or anything on very dry barely any spinach cold roll .grandson pizza burned
I love Main Street Pizzeria, has never got my order wrong. Delicious and perfect everytime
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We may joke about the gas station pizza, but don't knock it till you try it. I've eaten there for years and never had a bad pizza, sub or otherwise, don't hesitate they will definitely surprise you.
Pizza is consistently really good. Their salads are generously sized with fresh lettuce.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
There are a lot of pizza places in this whole region, and for a little place in a little village they are mighty good! Don’t overthink your decision, call them and get a half try and wings!