Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream

All the bad reviews the past week are coming from a facebook post lol they wasnt rude to that lady she was actually rude to them. Im a women myself and that man gas been nothing but kind to me. DONT BRING OUTSIDE FOOD FROM OTHER PLACES AND SIT ON THEIR PATIO AND EAT IT. He asked u to leave because u was eating the chipotle from down the road…. THIS BUSINESS HAS THE BEST ICE CREAM AND THE OWNERS ARE WONDERFUL

Not for POC.

I cannot wait until this establishment closes. Beyond awful service 25 years ago and this obviously still stands to be true to this day. This man has no business running a business. It’s neat how my last review simply disappeared. Hands down the rudest service I’ve EVER encountered. Do better. Be better.

Ice cream was disgusting. I won’t be back! Strickland’s even Dairy Queen is better than this dump

Not treated very welcoming almost felt racist like

Not welcoming to any coloreds!!

I was taken aback by the rude behavior and attitude at this location, the owner asked me to leave due to having a Chipotle bag, while I was also a paying customer who purchased their ice cream, which seemed unreasonable to me. He did not like my presence at his location

Amazing Ice Cream 🍨
Be sure to follow the rules if you want a great experience.
Read the menu before you go inside. No dogs on the patio. No strollers inside. And wait outside for him to call your name. Also, do not park in the parking lot unless
you are a paying customer.

We got the fresh coffee ice cream and it was glorious.

My husband and I came looking for a place to specifically get coffee-flavored ice cream and I’m so glad we found this little gem! We got lots of history from the owner and the BEST coffee-flavored ice cream we’ve ever had!!! This place may not be around for much longer so get some while this place is still here!

guy is pretty curt, “no cones, only cups.” :(

Akron’s ice cream version of the Seinfeld Soup Nazi. No thanks.

TERRIBLE. I went today to get ice cream & it was served in chinese takeout containers. The owner SCREAMED at me to look at the menu outside. Then, after ordering, he made me stand outside (again) in the pouring down rain & freezing cold. This was the worst restaurant experience I have ever had. I will not recommended this place to anyone. Save yourselves and do not come here!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Banana ice cream with hot fudge and peanuts is amazing 🍨

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Sundae

Too expensive 11$ for a regular sized milkshake that's just outrageous

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Where is the food? I wanted to get some pasta for dinner and have ice cream for dessert, but the old man behind the counter snapped that there is only take out ice cream. I got a $9 milkshake and waited outside for it, when he handed it to me he shouted “what’ll you have?” at me again and I dipped. The milkshake was runny and foamy and the cup is light, not worth $9. The experience is weird and unnerving.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1