27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Atwater

“We wait to go here. Needed tractor parts and waited til they were open. Love this restaurant Good food, great employees, such a big selection I have trouble deciding what to order. We always get a pizza to take home for next meal. Pizza is not made like this in most shops. This is so close to where we have to stop we are sure to include time to have a meal. Bless the owners for such a nice place to relax and enjoy the great food.“

“I went to here for a benefit and had no idea this was a campground. Very friendly people and looked like lots to do. If you are a camper I would recommend checking them out.“

“Thank you for the delicious pizzas for our flight instructor meeting yesterday! Perfect amount of sauce and cheese - so tasty! Everyone enjoyed them!😀“

“ordered there for the first time a day or two ago best philly,chicken parmigiana,and noodles/sauce/cheese i have ever had yummmmm“

“My first time checking this place out. I was honestly surprised at how good the pizza is. (Good for them, since all they sell is pizza.)

I'm pretty sure Victorio's has been around for a while. The only bad part of that is it doesn't look like they've cleaned the place, ever. Everything from ceiling to floor is coated with decades of grease. (If the owner is reading this, just look up at the light fixtures. Seriously, nasty. Have some pride.)

I read some reviews and noticed a lot of the complaints said they used to be better. If that's true, I would have loved to try their pizza back when the shop was clean.“

“Went for breakfast.

Good quality diner food. We both had the half farmer breakfast, coffee, and ordered a stack of blueberry pancakes.

What I feel was a good value for the food that we got - had plenty of surprisingly affordable options on the menu.
Total cost before tip was $21.

The only thing I think was missing from the experience was some background music in the place - every single booth was filled with customers that morning, but the conversations were super quiet, felt like eating in a library.

Our server was great and attentive.

The pic is from midway through eating (forgot to get it before we started eating).“

“The best place in NE Ohio!“

“Just ordered from here. Awesome food. Thank you. Definitely will order again.“

“Last review must have went somewhere else for her pizza. I met Ms. Fake Polish and Gems and couldn’t have had a more different experience. Friendly, professional, & went out of her way to be nice to my son and showed him the toys and books he could use while we waited for our food. Place was spotless. My guess: wanted their money back and wasn’t happy with the response. Always the best idea to trash an independent business just because you didn’t get your way. Class act. Food was great. Sauce wasn’t my favorite—but we will be back for sure, just ask for light. Crust is the star here for sure.“

“They are so well organized and awesome so very courteous well took good care of me when I was getting my pizza tonight. These are crazy times and I’m thankful that the dominoes team is handling this well.“

“Best wings I’ve ever had in my 43 years of traveling the United States. Try the medium with a side of garlic sauce. 🤤😋“

“We love Romeo's! The pizza is always hot and fresh and delivery is quick. Our fav local pizza spot!“

“All around great service! John took my order and was very professional and friendly. Pizza was well made, bread sticks were delicious too. Best Domino's I've had in a long time! Nothing was too greasy, over cooked, over sauced, under cooked. Definitely recommend this pizza shop!“

“Great food as always normally Me and My husband would get subs here for lunch when we ordered this time we tried the pizza foldover it was so good you get 2 nice size pieces for $12 Me and My husband honestly ciuld just split one order they were Toasted perfectly With Garlic and Butter definitely recommend trying them Can't go wrong with East Chicago Yummy!!“

“They have an amazing cauliflower crust pizza! I get to follow my diet and eat what everyone else is eating! Reasonable prices for EXCELLENT food 5 stars recommend HIGHLY! And they deliver!“

“Thank you for always taking in some of the 10U girls softball team of ravenna when we are hungry after games or practices! You all are so great to us! We thank you!!!!“

“I had not been to a Godfather's Pizza Express before, but I was glad I stopped in. They have some items premade that you can just grab and pay for, which is very convenient. They also make items to order, but make sure you get your order in at least ten minutes or so before they close, so they have time to cook that you want. I really enjoyed both the personal pan pepperoni pizza and the small cheese sticks that I purchased.“

“Awesome pizza late at night!!! Thank you so much it was delicious 😋 ♥️“

“Great place to get food from and the delivery driver's are very nice they are very popular and it may take a bit to get your order during rush times however the cool thing is if you order delivery they won't make the food until the driver is back to deliver it hot and fresh your food don't sit around when is comes out of the over the driver takes it to you hot out of the oven“

“Best service I’ve had all week. The staff is respectful to customers and each other. The kitchen is clean, organized, and efficient. If you want a good laugh, walk onto Dunkin’ Donuts on state st on a weekday and watch the staff insult their coworkers, and the drive thru and in store customers.
Great job, Gioninos!!“

“I absolutely love the pepperoni crazy puffs they're just so cheesy and delicious! I always call and order what I want they always make it quick it's always just sometimes less than 10 minutes away because when they're fresh right out of the oven that's when they're the best“

“We ordered the chicken tender meal (3 large tenders and 3-4 big jojo's, coleslaw and choice of sauces) and this is by far the best lunch or dinner package for $10 in Portage county. Staff is friendly and competent, although they are buried with orders during peak times ... it's still worth it! We have also, enjoyed their pizza, salad and Italian sub all with the same quality.

While this is a take-out shop, the Bar/restaurant next door has the same management and we often will bring our food there and there are various parks nearby that are fun too!

We don't understand the negative reviews here, but suspect made by competitors, competitors customers or an unusual circumstance. See our picture below!“

“the subs were great.the chicken was done (not bloody).everything was done and very good.very friendly ppl there.thank you ..“

“This is one of the very few places that have the dining room still open you can eat wonderful customer service LeBron vacation at a football game and we went to this place.... It feels like we stepped back into time.... Where I live at now they don't have a Pizza Hut with everything still available in it this place really brought back memories thank you (Canton Ohio)“

“Ordered on line thinking I’m ordering through pizza oven themselves, no it’s doordash, paid over $10:00 more for my order and I was picking it up myself .. very deceiving.. have had pizza oven pizza all my life will never order again.“

“Stopped in on Sunday evening around 7pm, no idea if they had been busy or not but no customers when I walked in. Ordered 3 boxs of the Crazy Puffs was told only 1 left, I ask how long a wait for more was told that's all today, gave me excuse someone called off and no one came in today to make any, or something like that. So I bought the one box because my wife really likes them. When we got home my wife was disappointed to find out they had no sauce,cheese or pepperoni inside of them, just plain dough.“

“Beautifully remodeled. Perfect for any event. This place has a bar, kitchen, stage for live music, beautiful artwork and a water fountain. Can't wait to go back!“