7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bainbridge

“A little bit of everything for us country folk. From oil to olives and from bread to butter —this place has it all. They have excellent deli meat and cheese and they have one of the best pizzas around. You can get soft serve ice cream, cough and cold medicine, canned goods, fruit, candy, soda, pet supplies and even a flashlight if your heart so desires.
The owner is friendly as with the rest of the ladies working there. It’s clean, down home feel and if you want to order food and eat in — they have that too.
If you haven’t been here — you need to be.“

“The food is always amazing. We have tried a bit of everything. Their cheeseburgers and pizza are my favorites. The owners are very nice and friendly. I always spend extra time in there just talking to them. 10/10!“

“We had the absolute pleasure of making the drive on Ohio 41 from US 52 north into Bainbridge. The drive alone would've been enough to make our day but then we found this bakery.
The venue is literally in the middle of nowhere. Which was good because apparently nowhere is where you find the best bakers, using the best ingredients, to make some of the best bread and pastries I have ever had the pleasure of eating.
The service was great, the people there were all friendly, and my favorite part were the ingredient labels:
Flour, Barley Flour, eggs, sugar, milk, butter... didn't see any bizarre compounds whipped up in some lab by mad scientists. Simply things you grow, harvest, and bake in Nowhere. The drive was 3 hours one way, and if I have to take a month to walk back i will be on my way. WHAT AN AWESOME PLACE. Take it from a fat dude... It's that good.“

“I’ve lived in Bainbridge for around 6 months when I first tried fly girl I wasn’t a huge fan of the crust but it wasn’t bad pizza and it’s fairly priced so I continued to eat there. The other night I was expecting same old same old and let me tell you I was shocked! This was by far one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had the new crust is more fluffy and tastes great they had to remake my pizza because something happened to the first one but I didn’t have to wait long at all they were very fast, very nice, and it was very very delicious highly recommend!“

“We are camping at Paint Creek and decided to come into town for dinner. I'm very glad we did. This place is awesome. Even though they were super busy they were right on it. Our waitress was very attentive and she was very helpful. We ordered a meatball sub and a large pepperoni and sausage pizza. The sub came out toasted perfectly and was delicious. I forgot to snap a pic. The pizza was also delicious. I would highly recommend eating here.“

“Me and my wife recently ate at the Old Town Pizzeria and we thoroughly enjoyed it. We took part in a pan tossed and a pan tossed. She took the hand because she prefers more pizza sauce and crust. We thought greatness of the pizzas. We loved the atmosphere. It’s very laid back and chill It’s got a rustic (well remodeled) vibe with a sports theme and several iconic posters from star wars and Harry Potter. They even allow a local MC chapter to come in and sell merch for veterans and their awareness. The times we have been in the pizzeria l, the owner is trying out new items to add to his menu and he hands them out at no charge for customers reviews and really enjoyed the criticism.“

“Ordered 2 pizzas at 10:45 pm, both pizzas were made quick and had really good quality. An employee named ‘Aries’ was a really good person and handed me out a free 2 Liter on the house, after I told him we had a rough night. This man definitely deserves a raise and is excellent at his job in both making pizzas, and serving customers. This man is a lot more than just a pizza guy and has a really big heart. I offered to pay for the drink but this man is really nice and declined my offer and said it’s okay to take. Way to go Dominos in Greenfield, you get 5 stars for having such caring employees ??“