7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bainbridge

“Very good little hidden gym in the middle of nowhere. I was suggested their pizza by a coworker, and I was not disappointed. Very very good. The staff was very friendly. They have lots of great items like Ski pop and candies you can’t find many other places. Definitely worth a try if you’re in the area. They also have a location in Bainbridge.“

“Such a good, good pizza! The workers tonight were all very nice, too! Did I mention how good that pizza is!? 🤣🫶🏼“

“We stopped in while camping at Pike Lake! We ordered a pepperoni pizza, bbq wings, hot wings (both boneless & traditional), side of fries and fried mozzarella sticks for an app. All of it was delicious! We loved the garlicky buttery crust. The mozzarella sticks had a different coating that was different but soo good! Our kids ate up all their wings and gave them a 👍🏻 ! We’re glad we stopped in! Nice atmosphere as well. If we’re in that area again- would def come back down to try.“

“On a long road trip and need a place to stop? This is the place! This is an amazing little bakery for a snack to eat out on the front picnic benches.
This bakery is ran by the Amish. All of them are really kind and make all of the amazing foods! I recommend the Jalepeño-Cheese Pretzel- it was fantastic! Nice and fresh, a good spice but not too hot, just a great snack!
This is for sure the place to stop at least once if you're passing by!“

“Pizza was amazing, it was hot, crispy crust, amazing garlic flavor lots of pepperoni and cheese on it and the pizza is huge .. you can get a smaller one but I love the fact you can get one that big... the wings were delicious.. plenty of sauce instead of dry & brittle ..they were moist, juicy & plenty of sauce for the taste.. highly recommended Old Town Pizzeria 2 in Greenfield..Prices are reasonable and for the size of the pizza for 20 bucks you can feed your family compared to other places that have a large pizza that only is for two people.. the pizza is so good we even got another large to take home to have for a couple days later...
We were there on 4-19-2025“

“We are camping at Paint Creek and decided to come into town for dinner. I'm very glad we did. This place is awesome. Even though they were super busy they were right on it. Our waitress was very attentive and she was very helpful. We ordered a meatball sub and a large pepperoni and sausage pizza. The sub came out toasted perfectly and was delicious. I forgot to snap a pic. The pizza was also delicious. I would highly recommend eating here.“

“Ordered 2 pizzas at 10:45 pm, both pizzas were made quick and had really good quality. An employee named ‘Aries’ was a really good person and handed me out a free 2 Liter on the house, after I told him we had a rough night. This man definitely deserves a raise and is excellent at his job in both making pizzas, and serving customers. This man is a lot more than just a pizza guy and has a really big heart. I offered to pay for the drink but this man is really nice and declined my offer and said it’s okay to take. Way to go Dominos in Greenfield, you get 5 stars for having such caring employees ??“