23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Chillicothe

“Fantastic food, great service, fantastic staff! My favorite pizza. My favorite place!“

“spectacular never disappointed. Best in town. Support local. Fast , Friendly and Delicious 😋“

“We are from out-of-town and ordered from Main Street because it was close to the hotel. What a find! Pizza and salad were both delicious. Will definitely order again when we're back in town.“

“had a wonderful meal from Hooks on the Hill. the pizza tasted great, and was delivered promptly. they followed delivery instructions. it was a great experience.“

“Great service, the waitress is very nice.“

“SOB & Veggie Fries! Service was Amazing, when they knew, we knew what we wanted, they let us order, no rush. But once in, Appetizers were there almost immediately, and gave us time to chat and catch up and enjoy dinner. Then the awesome Jerry's Pizza on Paint came. Of course we ordered a Large, didn't even finish half. Now a late night snack. Normally do 10 to 1, Carryout. Today was the best Dine-in experience. ***** Valet Service was even offered. lol😁“

“Delicious Food Everytime, great service.“

“Love your pizza girl..... Just 3 scoops tho...lol“

“I spent my first weekend in NY walking 10 miles in 20 degree weather post-cyclone looking at overpriced walkups, wondering why the hell I moved here from Los Angeles. Starving, I Yelped the closest pizza place and had my answer. New York is the only city where, despite everything, you can walk into any neighborhood and find a slice of pizza that makes you forget everything you loved in your west coast past life. I used to think Joe's was the best, but this definitely took that spot. I thought, maybe I'm wrong. Maybe this just tasted so good because I was hungry that day and it was cold. To test this, I came here multiple nights in a row and still experienced no diminishing marginal returns. Instead, each visit made me crave this place more. The normal/triangular/non-square margarita is my fave. And although a warm slice tastes great while you're walking outside and makes you forget how cold it is, I much prefer to enjoy these in the large seating area in the back to fully engage in the experience.“

“great, affordable pizza. Chillicothe needed a new place the ones we have now have been underperforming.“

“great pizza at a affordable price, always will be a customer plus the cute purple haired gal working the front 🤩 not only is she pretty she makes a mean pizza. 11/16/23“

“They have the best $5 subs, could have the BEST subs in Chilliocthe. Located in the Velaro gas station on the corner of second and bridge st. Dont worry about bring located in a gas station. People who work there are friendly and accommodating. I havent tried their pizza but they do sell it by the slice along with fresh made to go. If you want a sub ( or ruben ) to go this is the place.“

“Ordered for pick up today after I got off work. Was ready when I got there, and smelled amazing! Employee was super nice who handed it to me. Couldn't wait to sit down and eat it! It was perfect! I made modifications and they were all correct. Thank you for making my dinner delicious Cristy's Chillicothe!“

“I love Jerry's Pizza it's the best pizza ever.“

“fun time and with a lot of laughs“

“Great spot with very good food. Atmosphere was very loud noise level which well may be totally normal for that style of pub, just not what I prefer.

The experience was great overall but it was hard to hear what the wait staff was saying over the music, televisions and patrons yelling to each other and the staff to be heard over the ambient noise level.“

“Everyone is so friendly here and always goes the extra mile to make your visit perfect! I forgot to order extra sour cream for the mariachi beef pizza and they gave me a few extra packets at no charge. You have to have plenty of sour cream bc the jalapeno peppers are kickin!“

“I live in Columbus and we have Roosters all over here. However, this is the absolute BEST Roosters we have EVER HAD!!! Now that we know how Roosters is supposed to taste we won't go to any other one!!! It takes us 55 minutes ONE WAY to visit this Roosters but once you taste their food compared to the food at Roosters in Columbus you'll understand why we are willing to drive 55 minutes ONE WAY to eat here!!! AMAZING FOOD, AMAZING SERVICE, AMAZING ENVIRONMENT!!! We are so grateful we came across this gem while in Chillicothe, Oh,!!!“

“I went through the drive thru. A very nice young man greeted me at the window with a smile. He took my name and he was very sweet and fast. The food was good, hot and fast which really was nice bc we were in a hurry. The food was done and good at that. Donatoes is our place for good, hot fast pizza and cheap for feeding a crew like i do. Go Christian you did great. Keep up the good work. I went through the drive threw but it still makes a difference with whom you come in contact with. I don't recall ever having a problem there.“

“manager went above and beyond to make our pizzas for a birthday celebration these dedicated employees came in early to make pizzas for our grandsons birthday. THANK YOU. AGAIN!!!!!!“

“Service was fairly quick. The app though showed the pizza was done when it took another couple of mins. Im still giving a 5 for service as there were 3 ppl flipping dough making pizzas. This place was rocking knocking through pizzas. I gave a 4 due to no tables or chairs to sit at if you do have to wait. All in all. A great place. Pizza was absolutely amazing!! So good. I had it half finished before I even got home.“

“Needed to feed a hard working medical office, that needed a hot , delicious meal. These guys came through!!! Was able to walk in and get a couple hot pizzas and crazy bread, ready to go!! Thank you so much! You all were so nice and made a great impression!! We will definitely be back. You’re team is outstanding and the food was delicious!! Thank you!!“