14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mcarthur

“great pizza the other night,“

“The best pulled pork sandwich on homemade bread. The cinnamon rolls are great.“

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“

“I love this place. Holden is excellent at taking care of customers awesome pizzas, subs, salads and much more. Will not disappoint 💕“

“I recently visited Mama Renies and was impressed by the quality of the food and the service,also very clean, will be back“

“Think of the great bars in Urban Cowboy or The Deer Hunter! A place where Cledus would stop to “put some groceries down his neck”. This place drips character! It oozes from the 50 year old paneling. The windows are boarded up and you can’t tell if it’s even open. They even had a projection TV and an effing cigarettes machine! (Out of order). Food was awesome and cheap ($6.50 for a bacon cheeseburger. $4 for more fried and delicious ravioli than one can eat). The server was amazing and this will be a regular stop whenever I pass through.“

“My all time favorite is pepperoni mushrooms and extra cheese! My go to meal!! Oh yes and the great smiles..“

“My family went this weekend to celebrate our yearly birthday celebrations. The food was awesome. The interior was awesome. The best part of our experience was the service! Great experience, highly appreciated and highly recommend!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Papi’s Family Pizza in Hamden, Ohio is hands down the best pizza spot around! Every bite tastes like it’s made with love, and you can really tell they put care into everything they serve. The atmosphere is so warm and welcoming—it honestly feels like home the moment you walk in.
The staff are some of the friendliest people you’ll ever meet, always making sure you feel taken care of and appreciated. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or getting food for a big group or party.
If you’re looking for amazing pizza and a place that treats you like family, this is it. Highly recommended“

“Dominos for the win $4.99 for a medium one topping pizza 🍕is the best one we have had from DOMINOES in years !!!! Fresh and hot from the oven, sauce tasted fantastic and they have hard working people in there rocking out pizza after pizza feeding people for really little money this fair week!!!! I dont know if management has changed recently but I have seen her posts recently supporting her workers and tonight I saw workers that were dedicated to their customers — and God bless the ones outside in the heat and then rain serving customers. We will be back for pizza like this Way to go Wellston Dominos“

“Our group of guys stopped in for pizza while at deer camp and were not disappointed. They have a great selection of specialty pizzas and the flavors were great (we got the animal, landfill and pepperoni w/ hot honey).

Bonus that they also serve beer and have a Keno machine.

We will definitely be back again next year.“

“This is a local pizza spot with a comforting feel to it. Our waitress was super nice. We sat outdoors which had plenty of seating and had a nice look. We ordered the gluten free cauliflower crust blt pizza and it was absolutely amazing! It was the best cauliflower crust I’ve ever had. We will be returning and I would definitely recommend this to anybody looking for a good GF pizza.“

“Love eating at the Patio !!!“

“We are new to town and decided to order out tonight. Let me tell you,when I say the food was fabulous that doesn't even describe how great it was. The lady on the phone was so polite and helpful. The delivery was prompt and the food was hot. Thank you all so very much for such a wonderful experience!! Keep up the great work I will definitely be ordering in the future!“