11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Athens

“I infrequently get to the Athens area, but always get a take and bake pepperoni or margarita pizza. ***** 5 star rating.“

“The pizza is excellent and the prices are very reasonable...highly recommend!“

“I infrequently get to the Athens area, but always get a take and bake pepperoni or margarita pizza. ***** 5 star rating.“

“The food is amazing! I highly recommend the brussel sprouts appetizer. Everything was great from the service, the atmosphere, to my Stabby Cat beer. We will definitely be back.“

“It's kind of dingy, but that's honestly the ONLY negative thing I can think of (and it's really just because of the history of the buildings here). The food (especially the pizza) is amazing and their servers and bartenders are so attentive and nice! They don't serve martinis or old fashioneds because it's more of a craft beer place with basic drinks, but their sister bar next door has more high end items and we're looking forward to trying it soon!“

“The service was super friendly and fast. Both staff members seemed like they genuinely enjoyed what they were doing. I had my food about 10 seconds after ordering and paying. The pizza was fresh and the taste and texture was perfect. The prices were also great. Perfect all around“

“Great flat crust!!!!!!!!!!!“

“I placed my order online. It was ready on time, the gentleman working the drive-thru was polite as well.

I did not know that there are 2 business in this building and 2 different drive-thrus one is Donatos and the other is a coffee shop. I pulled through the wrong one. Just wanting to make sure others know.“

“For my most recent visit there were only 2 employees working so it took a little longer than expected, I order online and this is the first time in 4 different visits that they got my order right! These 2 employees are rock stars! This is in Athens, O 5pm on Tuesday 6/24/25.“

“Everyone’s friendly but one girl. She actually caused me out because she kept getting my order wrong. She was very nasty with just about every person she waited on. We used to get food from here every weekend . I actually quit getting food here for almost a year. I went back a couple of weeks ago . The same girl was there I just ignored her and didn’t tip her. The whole time I was paying for my food she was giving me the evil eye.“

“Been a little while since we ordered. Got a lrg pan 3 topping deal with breadsticks and 2 liter. The pizza was made on time. We ordered it seven hours ahead of time. Young man at the counter was polite. Quality of food was great. Brought me back to a Friday night in 1992. Good job and will order again.“