50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bay Village

“Gina’s pizza is a west side gem! Their pizzas and salads are a crowd pleaser for a party of 1 or a dozen. Friendly service and such quality every time we order. I couldn’t recommend them enough.“

“After a quick trip to Dillard's, Cynthia and I headed to Chatty's Pizzeria to try their pizza. WOW is all I can say! Their food is delicious and they are quite hospitable! We enjoyed the tomato and basil pizza and a large house salad, too. We had the vegan mushroom roll and cheese bread. The dipping sauce that accompanied both was a homemade tomato and basil puree. Everything was perfect here. We'd highly recommend Chatty's Pizzeria.“

“Friendly staff! Everyone is always smiling. Fast delivery! Love the Pizza bowls. Looks neat“

“Had great service today (Christmas Eve). Ordered two pepperoni melts, one without pepperoni. Worker called back to confirm if I wanted 'no' or 'less' pepperoni on the one melt. I explained it was for my wife who is a vegetarian, and she allowed me to substitute mushrooms on it. When I arrived, she was cheery and had labelled the mushroom melt so we wouldn't get them mixed up. Truly excellent service.“

“The best pizza. In a long time“

“Best pizza I recommend the Jimmy Hoffa“

“Been a regular here since not long after they opened. Best pizza in the area, delicious subs, and an absolutely amazing staff! Literally can't say enough good things about Mimi's.“

“One of the best pizza places I’ve had in such a long time, in fact the best pizza place I’ve ever had. We will definitely be back“

“I don’t usually write restaurant reviews, but In Forno is an exception — because I genuinely believe they serve the best Neapolitan pizzas in Cleveland. I’ve been a loyal patron of this little gem in Avon for nearly a decade, and every single visit has left me with a full stomach and a happy heart. For years, George and Elizabeth worked their magic behind the counter, crafting pizzas that transported you straight to Naples. This summer, they passed their beloved oven — and their legacy — to Chris and Nicki, the new owners, as they embarked on new culinary adventures. When I dined there this week for the first time under the new ownership, I’ll admit, I was curious (and a bit nervous) to see if anything had changed. I’m thrilled to report that Chris and Nicki have beautifully carried the torch forward. The menu and recipes remain intact, and the pies are every bit as divine as ever. My go-tos are the Celeste, Burrata, and Picante Quattro Formaggi — each a masterpiece in its own right. But here’s a secret: the best pizza isn’t even on the menu. Do yourself a favor — grab a seat by the chef's table, order a drink, and ask him to surprise you with something special. Watching that wood-fired oven at work while your pizza takes shape is pure culinary theatre. I often joke that if I had to choose my last meal on earth, it would be at In Forno. Judging by the smiles and overheard conversations from other diners, I’m not the only one who feels that way. Chris and Nicki have done more than take over — they’ve honored what George and Elizabeth built, ensuring that every bite still tastes like tradition, passion, and perfection. So gather your friends and family, and head to In Forno for a slice of joy, a dash of nostalgia, and the best wood-fired pizza you’ll find anywhere in town.“

“The place is kind of cool but hard to park.. nice people.. the pizza is good but the sauce could use a lil more flavor it’s kind of tomato pastey if you know what I mean… but besides that it’s pretty good pricey but the dough is amazing best part about the pizza forsure“

“First time trying their pizza and salads. Delicious food and friendly staff!“

“Highly recommend! Delicious Pizza and great options if you don’t feel like pizza. Try their wings or cheesy fries! Yumm. Fast and good service as well!“

“Delicious food and Excellent service“

“Amazing, quality food. Creative, seasonal selections.“

“Heard about Forte Pi from friend about great chicken tenders and fresh, organic food. We ordered carry out "make your own" pepperoni pizza with mushrooms, chicken tenders and salad shaker. Everything was superb! Two tenders is enough for four people. Pizza crust amazing, thin and light. Lemon salad dressing fresh and light. Shared feast with view of Lake Erie. Friendly service with explanation of all menu options. Will definitely be back.“

“We ordered from Dante's today for the first time and let me tell you The pizza was perfect. And the Buffalo wings, barbecue wings OMG Absolutely absolutely amazing ...We will be ordering again to try other items thank you 😍“

“A group of us traveled from Wooster to the IX center for the auto show and wanted to try a local pizza place. Sauced was recommended by a lady in the Ohio pizza fanatics page, what a great recommendation! Very good pie, some of the best I ever had. The staff were very friendly, the wait time to receive our food was minimal. They have a few tables set up inside for dine in and a drink cooler with soda and water, so perfect if you wanna dine in. I got a pie with pepperoni, sausage, and ricotta cheese, absolutely banging 🤌🏻 the breadsticks were great also and come with red sauce to dip them in. Overall great experience and will be making more trips to this location!“

“This was our first time ordering from tomori’s. Wings, pizza and pasta were all fantastic! We will be back.“

“Nothing compares to Angelo’s“

“This place was so cute. The wine & cheese was delicious“

“Real ingredients. Excellent Pizza. I know Pizza. This beats everyone in NE Ohio. Middle Eastern healthy options as well. Delicious dough with no sugar added. Good prices. Eat this pizza. You will come back. Not NY Style which I like, however Noticed how it is so much better compared to everyone else. Add olive oil and garlic powder. Extra pizza sauce as well. Sauce is Excellent.“

“New Favorite Italian Spot! We came here for my brother’s rehearsal dinner, and wow—Matteo’s absolutely blew us away! My husband and I loved everything we had: the lemon chicken was tender and flavorful, the Alfredo cavatelli was creamy perfection, and the sausage and meatballs were just incredible. Honestly, I can’t even pick a favorite—they were all that good. The bread and butter? Probably the best we’ve ever had. The cozy, old-town vibe of the location just added to the charm, and the service was top-notch. You can really feel the care and warmth of a true mom-and-pop Italian place. We’ve officially found our new go-to spot. If you’re a fan of Italian food and great hospitality, do yourself a favor and check out Matteo’s!“

“I have been a couple time and had there gluten free crust. The pizza is SO GOOD, no exaggeration.❤️❤️❤️😁 F stars would absolutely recommend ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Amazing pizza and great atmosphere“

“It’s always the small family owned spots that make the best pizza. This is my favorite spot around strongsville and I’ve never had a bad experience. Highly recommend.“

“This is one of two places in the county that we will buy from. I grew up in NY and am a self proclaimed pizza snob. You can’t beat a Capri pie. It’s the closest to NY style pizza in NEO.“

“We love this place! We get lunch for our team here from time to time. Thanks!“

“We ordered a large Extreme Supreme. The toppings were fresh, the crust was melt in your mouth cooked to perfection, and the extra cheese was just right. We usually order extra sauce at other places but decided not to at Master P and glad we didn’t. The amount of ingredients to crust ratio was on point. We took our leftovers home and ate them cold and the pizza was still bangin’ 😎. It was my first time enjoying a Master P pizza and I will most definitely be back.“

“Sriracha bbq, sweet heat, and Asian peanut butter are top tier flavors me and my best friend about came from how good the wings are. I live 3 hours away and I would drive here again to eat the wings here. Michelle is the server I had is one of the best servers I’ve ever had. 11/10 best place to eat!“

“Cameos is the rising hot spot. The pickle bread is unique and very good! I also love their burgers and hot honey pizza - honestly everything is phenomenal!! Angelina, and Johnny always take great care of us, and always pay attention to our allergies. Were here often, come check it out.“

“First time ordering pizza from Bella. I ordered a pepperoni pizza online. Said it would be 30-35 min which was fine. I arrived and the pizza was waiting for me. I opened the box and it was hot and smelled so good. I got it home and it didn’t last long. It was so delicious. My only regret was not ordering a larger one.“

“Did not dine in but had door dash deliver. It was the best damn pizza I have had in many, many, years! Trust me,I know a good pizza! I had the pepperoni, hot honey, pepper flakes, ricotta pizza and it was fricken delicious!!! Layers of flavors. Perfect amout of ingedients where you're not choked by stringy cheese. It must be a Cleveland thing that the cheese is so thick you can barely chew the pizza. The sauce was perfectly seasoned, Crust was amazing, flavorful the right amount of crunch but soft and flavorful dough, proofed perfectly! Topped with a dollop of creamy ricotta. 10 stars for this pizza pie!“

“First of all you guys have amazing pizza! You are also great people! Thank you so much for providing the Westlake library with sandwiches and pretzels! It is much appreciated! Whatever seasoning you put on pretzels is so tasty!“

“We just had Pelicano's cater our monthly birthday lunch. Food is DELICIOUS (sheet pizza and salad) Was right on time and the delivery girl was very sweet and set it all up for us. Thank you Pelicano's we will definately use you guys again!!! :)“

“Came in with a fairly large group of ladies. All of the food was delicious! I had the chicken philly....soooo good! Jenna was our server. She was super sweet and handled all of our requests and needs with a smile. Highly recommend stopping in and giving this place a try. They really do care about their customers!“

“I’d like to keep this the best kept secret, but the tomahawk veal Marsala is, hands down, the finest meal I have ever eaten on Cleveland! Combine this with a cozy atmosphere, a friendly and efficient staff, and there’s no need to go anywhere else for an incredible meal!“

“Delicious pizza and great service“

“We had an all-around superb visit. Everything I ordered, including my drink, was marked GF and confirmed upon delivery as GF. The mussels were the best I've had in decades. The pizza reminded me of Italy. And dessert was a great finish. On top of all that, our server went above and beyond. Kudos all around. It was a memorable evening.“

“good food awesome employees“

“Got filet meals to go. we both really enjoyed. Bar looked fun af also. Ill be back.“

“I ordered a house garden salad but received otherwise. Pizza was crisp and golden.“

“Hop Brothers quickly became my favorite local spot after opening. The pizza is the best around! The dog friendly paw-tio is perfect for getting a bite with my little poodle.“

“Deep dish pizza deserves a good hearty crunch; complimenting its soft dough bed covered with sheets of sweet and tangy pizza sauce. Its the perfect balance of that big chain size and convience, while maintaining that grungy greasy mom and pop hole in the wall realness.“

“Favorite bar to get together with some buddies on the weekend and watch all the big games. Live music on Friday and Saturday is always a great time too!“

“I ordered angel hair pasta with marinara sauce & shrimp. The sauce was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I had take out & could smell its deliciousness before even opening the container. I could eat a vat of the sauce. This was my first visit & it won't be my last. I highly recommend this hidden gem.“

“chicken and waffles pizza is a must try“

“Thank you Jets for this unexpected “extra” pizza for our son’s birthday celebration! So very sweet! We are always pleased with your service and quality and will continue to order from you!“

“We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, first time since the change in management, and were very pleased with the generous cheese and toppings and delicious crunchy crust - overall delicious 😋 - however, we found very little sauce and the sauce we tasted was different 😢“

“The lady at the front desk of the hotel near the airport recommend Kicker’s pizza and glad we did. We ordered a pizza at 10pm after a long day traveling and we were hungry. The said it would take 45 minutes but we got it in 20! The pizza was great and the delivery was impressive! I’d recommend them.“

“The Best sauce and crust! Instantly a favorite ❤️ 🍕“