DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont

$ • Pizza, Italian, Pet Friendly

Hours today·

About DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont

DiCarlo's Pizza offers a unique pizza experience, baking the dough with the sauce before adding toppings. This results in a non-greasy pizza that is a local favorite. They also serve spectacular subs made on crust-type dough. While not suitable for a sit-down meal, DiCarlo's provides quick pickup service and is famous in the Valley for its distinct pizza style. Customers can request additional cheese if desired.

The St. Clairsville location is especially popular, with loyal customers who are recognized by the staff as soon as they walk in. Some find the tomato pie-style pizza with added toppings to be an interesting regional specialty, while others may not be as impressed. The cheese and sausage pizza was described as OK by some visitors, and the location can be busy. Many customers appreciate the delicious sauce and the texture of the crust, which make DiCarlo's a go-to for special occasions, birthday parties, and family gatherings in the area. Prices are a bit higher than expected, but many say it is worth it from time to time.

Menu

Add a Menu
DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont Menu
DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont
DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont
View All Photos

DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont Reviews

4.2
108 ratings
5
58%
4
23%
3
5%
1
14%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.0
Service
4.3

Share your opinion about DiCarlo's Pizza - Belmont

I just moved to belmont county in july 2024 and omgod by far my favorite pizza EVER. Although my favorite DiCarlo's is the St. Clairsville location, we love it so much that the St. Clairsville employee ( i believe he's the manager) knows us as soon as we walk in.
I just moved to belmont county in july 2024 and omgod by far my favorite pizza EVER. Although my favorite DiCarlo's is the St. Clairsville location, we love it so much that the St. Clairsville employee ( i believe he's the manager) knows us as soon as we walk in.
First time trying this kind of pizza, basically tomato pie served in squares with added toppings. We chose cheese and sausage. It was OK. Don't think we'd return. We were just passing through town, and this was close to our hotel. It was fairly busy, though....so I think it is a popular place.

Read All Reviews(108)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 8:45PM
Tuesday 11AM - 8:45PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8:45PM
Thursday 11AM - 8:45PM
Friday 11AM - 9:45PM
Saturday 11AM - 9:45PM
Sunday 2 - 8:45PM
Updated on: