So happy to have stumbled across this yummy place in this cute town!
Jim Cary
Had the weekly special tonight - Lobster Filled Pasta. We often buy the weekly special but this was the BEST we have ever had. Paired it with a Pinot Grigio - Bottega Vinaia - which was recommended. Excellent. Highly recommend.
sean steiner
Great staff Excellent fish and chips
Jeanne Trombly
I enjoyed their cold noodle dish at the Cincinnati Open. Incredibly fresh tasting and home made. In hot weather what a perfect dish!
Eileen Bowen
Just tried Lobster Bakes at the Cincinnati Open. The lobster on the lobster roll was fresh but it was hard to decide how it tastes because the filling was so skimpy. The chips with the fish and chips were hot, fresh and tasty. The fish part however was so fishy it was hard to eat it without gagging. Not good when the best part of your $50 meal ais the fries you can get anywhere.
Ed Lizak
Great fish and more. Some sushi grade, just let them know you will be eating raw.
Maggie Ibrahim-Taney
What a fantastic find and were absolutely blown away! We ordered the lobster roll and the fish and chips - both were phenomenal and the Narragansett was the icing on the cake!
The lobster roll was *perfectly* done: buttery, fresh, and loaded with tender lobster meat. No fillers, no nonsense - just pure New England flavor. It felt like we were right on the coast of Maine.
The fish and chips were crispy, golden, and seasoned just right. The fish was flaky and fresh, and the fries were hot, crispy and satisfying.
The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the whole place had a laid-back, coastal vibe that made the experience even better. We’ll definitely be back!
Kirk Brady
Freshest seafood and nicest people
Steve K.
Great local place. fresh seafood and related items in this small, authentic- feeling New England seafood retailer. It's small and can get a bit crowded inside, but patience is a virtue ( according to my grandmother...;). Their selection is good and I recommend the fresh Verlasso salmon . Also their ala carte appetizers. Try it, you'll become a regular patron like me. Call ahead for pickup to savensome time.
First time visiting the store. Kind friendly service. The smoked trout will have me coming back often. The parking lot was empty when I first pulled in, so at first did not know if open. Just go up to the door and you will be happy you did.
Jon Hughes
Got a literal “taste” at Taste of Cincinnati on 5/24/25. I would love to tell you how the “Lobsta” tasted but it was 80% bun and lettuce – nothing like the advertised picture. Tasty = Sure… Portion = a measly rip-off. Seriously. I’m not one to leave a bad review but these people should not rip people off like this.
Beth Bextermueller
Yummy fish and chips! We lived in England for 4 years and often enjoyed a fish and chips pub dinner. The Shack offers the same delicious taste and service! It is always a short drive to Newtown and so worth it for a lovely evening and experience at The Shack on a Saturday!
Skylar Jade
You have to try this place. The food is top tier, the staff is incredibly accommodating, and we could not have personally planned a better experience. If you like seafood, you will love this place. I will be coming back here for anything seafood related that I need.
andy creighton
Great, small place. Laid back and very friendly. Food was excellent. It is a little pricey but still a great value (fresh fish isn't cheap) and they have lower cost items on the menu too. Highly recommended, we will be back!
So happy to have stumbled across this yummy place in this cute town!
Had the weekly special tonight - Lobster Filled Pasta. We often buy the weekly special but this was the BEST we have ever had. Paired it with a Pinot Grigio - Bottega Vinaia - which was recommended. Excellent. Highly recommend.
Great staff Excellent fish and chips
I enjoyed their cold noodle dish at
the Cincinnati Open. Incredibly fresh tasting and home made. In hot weather what a perfect dish!
Just tried Lobster Bakes at the Cincinnati Open. The lobster on the lobster roll was fresh but it was hard to decide how it tastes because the filling was so skimpy. The chips with the fish and chips were hot, fresh and tasty. The fish part however was so fishy it was hard to eat it without gagging. Not good when the best part of your $50 meal ais the fries you can get anywhere.
Great fish and more. Some sushi grade, just let them know you will be eating raw.
What a fantastic find and were absolutely blown away! We ordered the lobster roll and the fish and chips - both were phenomenal and the Narragansett was the icing on the cake!
The lobster roll was *perfectly* done: buttery, fresh, and loaded with tender lobster meat. No fillers, no nonsense - just pure New England flavor. It felt like we were right on the coast of Maine.
The fish and chips were crispy, golden, and seasoned just right. The fish was flaky and fresh, and the fries were hot, crispy and satisfying.
The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the whole place had a laid-back, coastal vibe that made the experience even better. We’ll definitely be back!
Freshest seafood and nicest people
Great local place. fresh seafood and related items in this small, authentic- feeling New England seafood retailer. It's small and can get a bit crowded inside, but patience is a virtue ( according to my grandmother...;). Their selection is good and I recommend the fresh Verlasso salmon . Also their ala carte appetizers. Try it, you'll become a regular patron like me. Call ahead for pickup to savensome time.
Everything is always fresh!
Restaurantji Recommends
First time visiting the store. Kind friendly service. The smoked trout will have me coming back often. The parking lot was empty when I first pulled in, so at first did not know if open. Just go up to the door and you will be happy you did.
Got a literal “taste” at Taste of Cincinnati on 5/24/25. I would love to tell you how the “Lobsta” tasted but it was 80% bun and lettuce – nothing like the advertised picture. Tasty = Sure… Portion = a measly rip-off. Seriously. I’m not one to leave a bad review but these people should not rip people off like this.
Yummy fish and chips! We lived in England for 4 years and often enjoyed a fish and chips pub dinner. The Shack offers the same delicious taste and service! It is always a short drive to Newtown and so worth it for a lovely evening and experience at The Shack on a Saturday!
You have to try this place. The food is top tier, the staff is incredibly accommodating, and we could not have personally planned a better experience. If you like seafood, you will love this place. I will be coming back here for anything seafood related that I need.
Great, small place. Laid back and very friendly. Food was excellent.
It is a little pricey but still a great value (fresh fish isn't cheap) and they have lower cost items on the menu too.
Highly recommended, we will be back!
Loading...