Scarlato's Pizza
3231 McHenry Ave, Cincinnati
(513) 662-3323
Customers' Favorites
Large Pepperoni Mushroom and Pineapple Pizza
Chicken Tender on Bun
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Banana Pepper
Chicken Wings
Cheese Fries
French Fries
Extra Sauce
Plain Pizza
Meat Pizza
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I called 20 minutes before close, and was given exceptional service. They were so kind, and the pizza was delicious. They actually cook it in a stone oven! Not a conveyor belt. 10 out of 10. Thank you for the exceptional service, and taking care of me before closing.
Like many others, I've driven past this place countless times and never knew it was a pizza spot. I've been past the place during summer nights and remember seeing crowds and cars and still wasn't sure what the place was. I remember hearing my mom constantly mention this pizza while I was growing up as well. Today, I finally tried it and wasn't disappointed at all. The pizza is PERFECT to me. Unlike another famous pizza spot from Cincinnati, there's no...
Had a few one-topping pizzas delivered for a birthday party hosted nearby and I was pleasantly surprised by this pizza. The default is a thin crust square cut like LaRosa's and I would say it compares very favorably. If I'm on the West Side again I'll be making it a point to pickup or dine-in so I can check this place out a bit more thoroughly.
You May Also Like
Fish Express - 2463 Harrison Ave
![]()
Seafood, Chicken, Seafood Markets
Mexican Grill Wings and things - 2604 Putz Pl
![]()
Chicken Wings, Pizza, Mexican, Pet Friendly