The Bagelry

3212 Madison Rd, Cincinnati
(513) 996-0141

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
Miss Vickie's Chips
Avocado Bagel Toast
Breakfast Sandwich
BYO Breakfast
Bacon Avocado
Single Bagel
Southwestern
The Garden
Queen City

Menu

Bagels and Spreads
Single Bagel and Any Spread
We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day. If you'd like a bagel with butter, please select single bagel and add butter.
Single Bagel
We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day.
Half Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the notes section during checkout which 6 bagels you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Cream Cheese (8 oz)
8 oz. Tub of our housemade cream cheese.
Cream Cheese (2 oz)
2 ounces of our housemade cream cheese.
Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the notes section during checkout which 12 bagels you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Brunch Bundle
A dozen bagels with 2 tubs of cream cheese. Please indicate in the notes section during checkout which 12 bagels (flavor) you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Bagel & Butter
Vegan Cheese (8 oz)
8 oz. Tub of our housemade vegan cashew cheese.

Egg Sandwiches
BYO Breakfast
Fresh cracked scrambled egg on your choice of bagel. Option to add cheese, meat, and or veggies. We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Queen City
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, glier's goetta, and american cheese on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the byo breakfast and customize away.
Southwestern
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, avril bleh sausage, pepperjack cheese, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, banana peppers, and red onions on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the byo breakfast and customize away.
Bacon Avocado
Egg, bacon, avocado, and sriracha on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the byo breakfast and customize away.
The GECCO
Goetta, egg, cheddar, and chive and onion cream cheese on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the boy breakfast and customize away.
The Garden
Fresh crackled scrambled egg, swiss cheese, roasted vegetable cream cheese, lettuce, onion, tomato, and red bell pepper on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the byo breakfast and customize away.

Bagel Sandwiches
Pizza Bagel
Garlic butter, pizza sauce, provolone, and Italian seasoning. Option to add pepperoni andor banana peppers. We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
NYC Lox
Brooklyn based acme lox, onion, tomato, capers, and plain cream cheese. We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Avocado Bagel Toast
Sliced avocado, sea salt, red pepper flakes, onion, and tomato on your choice of bagel.
BLT
Double bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of bagel.
Smoked Turkey
Lucius Q smoked turkey, housemade onion chive cream cheese, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bagel. Option to add bacon for full club experience!
Italian
Ham, pepperoni, jalapeno, garlic cream cheese, onion, tomato, and banana peppers. We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.

Sides
Miss Vickie's Chips
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
A Massachusetts originally brought to the next level in Cincinnati using premium chocolate and browned butter.
Lox (2 oz)
A single portion of lox from acme in Brooklyn, NY.

Beverages
Gatorade
See flavor and size options below.
Coffee (Large) (16 oz)
Tinker coffee Indianapolis, and single origin Malawi.
Coke (Can) (12 oz)
La Croix Seltzer Water
Bru Bros Nitro Vanilla Oat Milk Cold Brew (12 oz)
From Bru brothers, local Cincinnati coffee brewers and enthusiasts. Nitro cold brew coffee infused with oat milk and natural vanilla flavoring.
Diet Coke (Can) (12 oz)
Sprite (Can) (12 oz)
Bottled Water
Hot Chocolate (12 oz)
Coke Zero (Can) (12 oz)
Coffee (Small) (12 oz)
Tinker coffee Indianapolis, and single origin Malawi.
Apple Juice (Bottle) (12 oz)
Tropicana, 12 ounce bottle.
Bottled Tea
Bru Bros Nitro Cold Brew Coffee (12 oz)
Hot Tea (12 oz)
Orange Juice
Tropicana low pulp.
Chocolate Milk
Milk

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+17 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+16 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The atmosphere in the place we really nice. The workers were super friendly. The place was packed. The only reason it’s getting a 4 star and not a 5 is that I didn’t end up getting what I had actually ordered, probably due to how many people were there, but it was delicious. Recommend.
April 2025
The Bagelry has some of the best bagels in the city! Every time I visit, I’m blown away by the freshness and flavor. Kewon and the entire staff are always so friendly and welcoming, making every experience that much better. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or sitting down to enjoy your bagel, you’ll always leave with a smile. Highly recommend this spot if you’re a bagel lover!
March 2025
Fortunately, I live in Oakley 😊
Bagelry has been such a fantastic addition to Oakley…. I use to go to the Oakley Panera , but now I’ve switched to this successful family owned “ Bagel bakery”
Everything is so delicious !!
Gracias, Merci, Obrigado 😊
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Redtree Coffee and Art - 3210 Madison Rd
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Papa Johns Pizza - 3346 Erie Ave
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast Food
Flying Pig Irish Pub - 3265 Brotherton Rd
Pubs, Irish Pub, Pet Friendly

The Bagelry

3212 Madison Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45209
(513) 996-0141