Trophy Pizza - Evendale

10325 Reading Rd # 102, Cincinnati
(513) 769-1111

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Slice with Pepperoni and Sausage
Half & Half Margherita Pie
Cheese Calzone with Sausage
Classic Pepperoni Pizza
Margherita Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
14 Plain Cheese Pizza
4 Meat Pizza Slice
Grandma Pizza Slice
White Pizza Slice

Featured items
Plain
Red sauce, parmesan, whole milk mozz. Customize with toppings of your choice
Half & Half Plain Pie
Our plain pie topped with different toppings on each half
Margherita
Red sauce, fresh mozz, basil, extra virgin olive oil. Customize with toppings of your choice
Classic Caesar
Chopped romaine, parmesan, creamy caesar. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two
Half & Half Grandma
Our Grandma Pie topped differently on each half
Mexican Coke
Classic Coca Cola made with real cane sugar in an iconic glass bottle
Deluxe Calzone
Add up to 4 fillings from to a cheese calzone. Served with pizza sauce
Fresh and Cool
Local mixed greens, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two
Grandma Slice
The comfort food of comfort foods. A slice of our sauce-on-top Grandma Pie
Plain Cheese Slice
This is the only slice you'll ever need. Perfectly crisp, chewy crust; fresh, tangy tomato sauce; freshly grated parmesan; and whole milk mozz
Boylan's Black Cherry Soda
Classic Black Cherry soda made with real cane sugar in New York
Peppery Pig Slice
A classic white slice finished with EVOO, baby arugula, freshly grated parmesan cheese, and prosciutto
Loophole
Chicken, cheese, bacon, jalapeño, caramelized onions, ranch
Boylan's Ginger Ale
Classic Ginger Ale made with real cane sugar in New York
Cheese Calzone
Parmesan, mozzarella and ricotta mix. Served with pizza sauce
6 Meatballs
Our house made meatballs made with beef, pork, veal & ricotta cheese along with a mixture of delicate, fragrant herbs and spices. Served in red sauce with freshly grated parmesan cheese
Peppery Pig
Ricotta, caramelized onions. Prosciutto, arugula, parmesan
White Slice
Garlic, olive oil, whole milk mozz, ricotta cheese, caramelized onions and basil in a harmony of flavors
The Bensonhurst
Local mixed greens, romaine, tomato, red onion, kalamata olives, prosciutto and pecorino Romano. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two

Classic Pizzas
Plain
Red sauce, parmesan, whole milk mozz. Customize with toppings of your choice
Half & Half Plain Pie
Our plain pie topped with different toppings on each half
Half & Half Grandma
Our Grandma Pie topped differently on each half
Margherita
Red sauce, fresh mozz, basil, extra virgin olive oil. Customize with toppings of your choice
White
Olive oil, garlic, whole milk mozz, ricotta, caramelized onions, basil. Customize with toppings of your choice
Half & Half White Pie
Our white pie topped differently on each half
Half & Half Margherita Pie
Our margherita pie topped with different toppings on each half
12" Gluten Free Pie
Grandma Pie
A beautiful pan pizza with whole milk mozz, fresh mozz, garlic, basil, parmesan and our bright tomato sauce on top.

Specialty Pizzas
Peppery Pig
Ricotta, caramelized onions. Prosciutto, arugula, parmesan
Loophole
Chicken, cheese, bacon, jalapeño, caramelized onions, ranch
Triple Crown
Meatballs, red onion, banana peppers

Slices
Grandma Slice
The comfort food of comfort foods. A slice of our sauce-on-top Grandma Pie
Plain Cheese Slice
This is the only slice you'll ever need. Perfectly crisp, chewy crust; fresh, tangy tomato sauce; freshly grated parmesan; and whole milk mozz
Peppery Pig Slice
A classic white slice finished with EVOO, baby arugula, freshly grated parmesan cheese, and prosciutto
White Slice
Garlic, olive oil, whole milk mozz, ricotta cheese, caramelized onions and basil in a harmony of flavors
Pepperoni Slice
A gift from the pizza gods. Our classic plain slice, topped with delicious cup & char pepperoni. Our best- seller.

Calzone
Deluxe Calzone
Add up to 4 fillings from to a cheese calzone. Served with pizza sauce
Cheese Calzone
Parmesan, mozzarella and ricotta mix. Served with pizza sauce

Meatballs
3 Meatballs
Our house made meatballs made with beef, pork, veal & ricotta cheese along with a mixture of delicate, fragrant herbs and spices. Served in red sauce with freshly grated parmesan cheese
6 Meatballs
Our house made meatballs made with beef, pork, veal & ricotta cheese along with a mixture of delicate, fragrant herbs and spices. Served in red sauce with freshly grated parmesan cheese

Salads
Classic Caesar
Chopped romaine, parmesan, creamy caesar. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two
Fresh and Cool
Local mixed greens, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two
The Bensonhurst
Local mixed greens, romaine, tomato, red onion, kalamata olives, prosciutto and pecorino Romano. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two

Drinks
Mexican Coke
Classic Coca Cola made with real cane sugar in an iconic glass bottle
Boylan's Ginger Ale
Classic Ginger Ale made with real cane sugar in New York
Mexican Fanta
Classic Fanta made with real cane sugar in an iconic glass bottle
Mexican Sprite
Classic Sprite made with real cane sugar in an iconic glass bottle
San Pellegrino Limonata Soda
Refreshing Italian soda made with real lemon juice
12oz Sprite Can
Lemon. Lime. 'Nuff said
Boylan's Black Cherry Soda
Classic Black Cherry soda made with real cane sugar in New York
12oz Coke Can
Anything but basic
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
A refreshingly carbonated Italian classic
12oz Ale 8
Is it Ginger Ale? Is it lemon-lime? Go south and ask a Kentuckian
Boylan's Seltzer
Classic Seltzer - water carbonated til it bites - made in New York
12oz Diet Coke Can
Skinny Coke
Gold Peak Sweetened Black Iced Tea
Gold Peak Unsweeted Black Iced Tea
Gold Peak Sweetened Green Iced Tea
Smart Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+18 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+17 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. The employees were great. If New York style is what you like, this place is for you. Hot, fresh and on time!. Cant wait to be back in town to have it again..
September 2025
I’ve been to Trophy Pizza at this location five times now, and never had anything but a great experience!
The eating area is always clean and bright, and the staff has always been exceptionally friendly and helpful!
The pizza itself is delicious! It comes out of the oven quick, so it’s hot, fresh and the crust is nice and crispy!
There are always many different types of slices under glass to choose from, so I usually make it a point to ask about...
September 2025
Very flavorful, fresh slices! This place is definitely the go-to spot for Great pizza. Salads are good too. The salad dressings are not that good, I've had the ceasar & the red wine vinegarette (which is not red) the only minor critique.
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Arby's - 10365 Reading Rd
Fast Food
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 2552 Cunningham Dr
Mexican, Fast Food
Burger King - 10425 Reading Rd
Fast Food, Burgers

Trophy Pizza - Evendale

10325 Reading Rd # 102, Cincinnati, OH 45241
(513) 769-1111