Wyoming Pastry Shop

505 Wyoming Ave, Cincinnati
(513) 821-0742

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kajuana G

I ordered my baby’s birthday cake the actual cake was good but I was very disappointed the art work was very sloppy. What I asked for versus what I got. We spent over two hundred dollars .☹️

Lydia Lander

The condescending rudeness of the woman working left a really sour taste rather than what I went in for. I anticipated a sweet experience like I’ve had every time I’ve stopped in when in town. I hope the cake I purchased for my family is better than her attitude and sincerely hope this isn’t the norm for this Wyoming icon. In fairness there was a very nice smiling young lady who tried to help and without her we would have had a horrible experience.

Abby Thieken

Just stopped in as we saw it driving by and the woman who helped us was so sweet and the place is adorable and let me tell you the pastry's were DELICIOUS!!! We will be back for sure!

Victoria Bartos

Amazing pastries and baked goods plus helpful and friendly employees!

Jonathan Johnson

Went in to get a birthday cake made for my fiancé .The two women just sat at the table and didn’t even acknowledge me

NATRANZ910

Ordered my daughter cake from here after being told how good this bakery was. I'll say the girl who took my cake order when I came in to place it was very personable and courteous, customer service from her was 100. I also had gotten some donuts, cupcakes, and cookies the day I placed the order. Didn't care for the carrot cake cupcake. The coconut donut was pretty good. Their smiley face cookie reminded me of a healthier version of Busken's. My kids ate the cupcakes and said they liked them. The birthday cake was mediocre in flavor. The icing was too sweet. It was half yellow, half white, with the yellow being the preferred of the two. Nobody from the birthday party was blown away by it. It was very beautiful tho, just lacking in taste. And you can't have leftovers longer then a day or so or the cake part gets hard.

Angi Kraft

Gorgeous cookies and holiday treats. The best cake ever. My little grandson's 1st birthday was a hit because of his smash cake and cookies. So yummy. Such a quaint little place to have treats and donuts. Super friendly staff and very pleasant atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake

Kimberly Demoss

Her cake was beautiful. The cupcakes tasted great as always

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Zach Bellman

Everything is made with love and tastes like it. Prices are crazy low (7$ for a whole coffee cake), they could be charging a lot more. Super friendly staff. Sells out early, which is the baking world means ur doing something right.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut

Victoria Brinkman

Chocolate Torte, Gingerbread cookie

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Sky Beans

I’ve going to fufu bakeries in the past where they charge an ungodly amount for 1 doughnut. This place is nothing like that, the doughnuts were fresh and the staff was kind. All at an affordable price point. I love pastries and sweet treats. Its nice to find an affordable bakery that taste great.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut

Heather Ferris

The cake we received from this establishment was truly outstanding, surpassing our expectations in flavor and excellence. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dixie Barker

I got my cake on Saturday and it was scrumptious. Will definitely return. Thanks Wyoming Bakery. You did not disappoint

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Lillie

The cronut is heaven sent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

SB

Donuts were squished in a bag. When I got home icing was on tissue paper placed between donuts and off the donut itself. I guess back to Graeters where they use a box and no tissue paper on top. And this was no young person behind the counter doing it. I made a 50 minute car trip to receive these donuts. per friend recommendation, where I've had other tasty goods of yours in the past. I won't be back. Keep yur little pastry shop.

Loading...