Pizza Cottage
$ • Pizza, Vegetarian
Hours:
23401 US-23, Circleville
(740) 474-3620
About Pizza Cottage
Customers' Favorites
Pizza Cottage Reviews
Share your opinion about Pizza Cottage
6 dollars extra for banana peppers, on top of an all the way pizza for 25.99. waitress would not fix it and said that was the price. insane. won't be spending anymore here. check your receipts and ask ahead of time what upcharges are asking they just charge whatever.
Terrible service. Waiter never came to check drinks after taking our order. Finally walked out after waiting 40 minutes on pizza. On the way out he told me to “chill out dude it’s just pizza“. Absolutely terrible waiter. It’s a shame because Pizza Cottage is definitely my favorite pizza but do yourself a favor and go to any of the other locations besides this one.
Terrible service. Waiter never came to check drinks after taking our order. Finally walked out after waiting 40 minutes on pizza. On the way out he told me to “chill out dude it’s just pizza“. Absolutely terrible waiter. It’s a shame because Pizza Cottage is definitely my favorite pizza but do yourself a favor and go to any of the other locations besides this one.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
People in Circleville Also Viewed
Pizza Cottage is a popular restaurant known for its delicious and affordable pizza. The Hawaiian and All the Way pizzas are highly recommended by customers. The fresh and tasty salad is a great option for a well-rounded meal. The restaurant maintains cleanliness and follows hygiene measures, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable. Despite a minor issue with a drink order, the service is generally considered pleasant and efficient. The kind staff adds to the overall positive experience. Some customers also utilize the convenient drive-through service.
Customers have praised the restaurant's BLT pizza, which is described as the best leftover pizza they've had in over 20 years, with the same great taste. The onion rings, served with a cheddar cheese sauce, are also a hit, coming out hot and fresh. While the pepperoni with extra cheese pizza was a bit spicy for some, it was still considered very good. The cheese bread, however, was not as well-received, as it was made with a sub bun instead of the same dough as the pizza.
The restaurant's cleanliness is a mixed bag, with the floors being described as very sticky, causing shoes to stick to the ground. The music selection, which included heavy metal with profanity, was also not considered family-friendly. However, the overall dining experience is still positive, with customers indicating a willingness to return.