I have been going here for 45 years always been great for pizza bagels donuts and strudel. Never went to a bakery I liked more. I just wish they would spend a few hundred bucks to paint ,new floors,and clean it up. It looks the same as 45 years ago.Staff is always pleasant.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Petro
The cream cheese pillows are the best ever.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Nicole Mezic
I went to Buettner's to get some Christmas cookies. I was SHOCKED at how expensive they were, $35 for 1.5 lbs. of cookies that tasted good but were sloppily decorated and broken. The woman at the counter was rude and the minute I walked in and started looking at what they had she rudely asked "SO?" like I should be instantly ready to order. There was nobody else there so no need to rush me.I know prices are up everywhere but $35 for 1.5 lbs. of cookies is STEEP for barely enough cookies to fill a tray. I didn't get a receipt either, feeling gouged, I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Bakery
James O.
A friendly neighborhood bakery boasting an assortment of Nut rolls , french pastries and pecan rolls
lee puterbaugh
This Old World Bakery is amazing!
Bert B.
Some of the best pastry in the Collinwood area. It is the goto location for the church crowd on Sundays and the usual workers during the week. The Chinese cookies are outstanding. The workers have always been extremely helpful.
Megan Howard
While they have an extensive selection of beautiful looking treats, they were all old and stale. I ordered about $20 worth of various things and they all tasted several days old and honestly, two items (a custard filled long john and a cream cheese filled doughnut) had spoiled. The lemoncake was moist and yummy but the brownie was dry and old and the snuggle was inedible. I do not recommend this place.
T K.
I've been coming to this bakery ever since I can remember. My mother loved their pastries, my family, my friends, and now my coworkers are all now crazy about them! There is just something about them that makes them taste extra Good! It's not a fancy smancy looking one inside, but that's also what I love about it. More of an "Old School" vibe... Which is cool. Try them, you'll love them.
Becky Baby
The lady at the shop was very sweet but I will never eat from there ever there was hair wrapped all around my donut when I took it out the bag
Larry Rodgers
Giving Goldies a run for the money. Old school. Looks like the neighborhood bakeries from the 60's and 70's when dounuts where a 0.10 each.
This is a small family owned bakery and they never disappoint. All of their pastries are wonderful but my absolute favorite are the pizza bagels. I eat them cold they’re so good but of course can be wonderful to warm up in the oven. I highly recommend. If you’re ever over in this part of town, it could’ve been easy for you to pass this but it’s on the Main St., East 185th St. right on the border of Cleveland and Euclid. This is a must stop. The main street is in the middle of a rejuvenation project so I’m really looking forward to all the businesses up and down east 185th getting a much-needed facelift as these businesses are very well deserving of it. I’ll make sure to update my photo after the rejuvenation is complete but again in the meantime don’t let the looks deceive you.
Ryan
Delicious and a great variety, friendly staff too!! Wish I lived closer :/
K. Deadwyler
If you love donuts, Buettner's has the very best and freshest donuts in cleveland!! So get yourself over there to get one, a 6-pack, 12-pack, and a cup of coffee, or two, a pizza, or any other pastries you may want. You can't go wrong! Thank you Buettner's for putting your best donuts ? forward!!
Bob F.
Very friendly service and Great Christmas cookies. The kolaczkis are fantastic.Been going here for years and they never disappoint.
Arthur Charlton
Stopped for the first time this past weekend. We are new to the neighborhood and wanted to try the local places. The baked goods are so good. Everything looked great and I can’t wait to stop back and try more little bites of heaven they make. The lady was super nice and patient. Highly recommend.
I have been going here for 45 years always been great for pizza bagels donuts and strudel. Never went to a bakery I liked more. I just wish they would spend a few hundred bucks to paint ,new floors,and clean it up. It looks the same as 45 years ago.Staff is always pleasant.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cream cheese pillows are the best ever.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
I went to Buettner's to get some Christmas cookies. I was SHOCKED at how expensive they were, $35 for 1.5 lbs. of cookies that tasted good but were sloppily decorated and broken. The woman at the counter was rude and the minute I walked in and started looking at what they had she rudely asked "SO?" like I should be instantly ready to order. There was nobody else there so no need to rush me.I know prices are up everywhere but $35 for 1.5 lbs. of cookies is STEEP for barely enough cookies to fill a tray. I didn't get a receipt either, feeling gouged, I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Bakery
A friendly neighborhood bakery boasting an assortment of Nut rolls , french pastries and pecan rolls
This Old World Bakery is amazing!
Some of the best pastry in the Collinwood area. It is the goto location for the church crowd on Sundays and the usual workers during the week. The Chinese cookies are outstanding. The workers have always been extremely helpful.
While they have an extensive selection of beautiful looking treats, they were all old and stale. I ordered about $20 worth of various things and they all tasted several days old and honestly, two items (a custard filled long john and a cream cheese filled doughnut) had spoiled. The lemoncake was moist and yummy but the brownie was dry and old and the snuggle was inedible. I do not recommend this place.
I've been coming to this bakery ever since I can remember. My mother loved their pastries, my family, my friends, and now my coworkers are all now crazy about them! There is just something about them that makes them taste extra Good! It's not a fancy smancy looking one inside, but that's also what I love about it. More of an "Old School" vibe... Which is cool. Try them, you'll love them.
The lady at the shop was very sweet but I will never eat from there ever there was hair wrapped all around my donut when I took it out the bag
Giving Goldies a run for the money. Old school. Looks like the neighborhood bakeries from the 60's and 70's when dounuts where a 0.10 each.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a small family owned bakery and they never disappoint. All of their pastries are wonderful but my absolute favorite are the pizza bagels. I eat them cold they’re so good but of course can be wonderful to warm up in the oven. I highly recommend. If you’re ever over in this part of town, it could’ve been easy for you to pass this but it’s on the Main St., East 185th St. right on the border of Cleveland and Euclid. This is a must stop. The main street is in the middle of a rejuvenation project so I’m really looking forward to all the businesses up and down east 185th getting a much-needed facelift as these businesses are very well deserving of it. I’ll make sure to update my photo after the rejuvenation is complete but again in the meantime don’t let the looks deceive you.
Delicious and a great variety, friendly staff too!! Wish I lived closer :/
If you love donuts, Buettner's has the very best and freshest donuts in cleveland!! So get yourself over there to get one, a 6-pack, 12-pack, and a cup of coffee, or two, a pizza, or any other pastries you may want. You can't go wrong! Thank you Buettner's for putting your best donuts ? forward!!
Very friendly service and Great Christmas cookies. The kolaczkis are fantastic.Been going here for years and they never disappoint.
Stopped for the first time this past weekend. We are new to the neighborhood and wanted to try the local places. The baked goods are so good. Everything looked great and I can’t wait to stop back and try more little bites of heaven they make. The lady was super nice and patient. Highly recommend.