Captain Tony's Pizza

13202 Shaker Square, Cleveland
(216) 561-8669

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kate Theobald

Vegetarian options: Toppings are customizable, and there are a lot of vegetable options, such as broccoli, eggplant, artichokes, spinach and fresh mushrooms. They also offer a variety of salads and pasta dishes which can be made vegetarian easily.

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Pac man

??? Pizza was so delicious, ? Yummy for my tummy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Tammora Reed

I had the misfortune of being the second to last order of the night, and my food was terrible! I got old dry garlic bread ends that I would not have given to my furry daughters. My seafood pizza was the worst and I felt like it was missing ingredients. I have always loved Captain Tony's, but this experience sucked!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

The Murf Murf

Online ordering didn't work. It acts like there is nowhere to order from. I tried calling first time nobody answered. I gave it a couple minutes and I called again and then a guy answered and was talking to somebody else, but then he started talking to me and it was hard to hear him It sounds like he was really far away so I just gave up.

Betty Love

This restaurant used to be good years ago in the early 2000s. Like a lot of things, it has gone downhill. I went there recently and ordered chicken parmesan. I got a ton of gooey spaghetti, two tiny pieces of chicken, hard chewy garlic bread, and no napkins or utensils to eat them with. The only good thing was the male worker, who was very polite.

A young lady was sitting behind the register; however, she had no customer service skills. I asked her if I could use the restroom. She had this look on her face like, "Why are you asking me?"

The nice male worker suggested that I sit outside and eat because of the noisy work that was being done inside the restaurant. I would not have minded sitting outside that beautiful day, but the tables looked like they had not been wiped off in weeks. Leaves and dirt covered the tables. It makes me wonder how clean the area is where the food is prepared.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Zane Johnson

The bathroom is absolutely disgusting, the sink, the walls, the urinal, and the toilet all gross. The door looks as if it will crack when I shut the door. And there was a used sponge just sitting in the sink, along with a large, fowl smelling bucket just sitting on a random chair in the bathroom. Oh also, no soap. I will not comment on the food. The service was good.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 4

Janeese Austin

I love the pizza! Glad to see this place is still around after all these years. Says a lot

Nestor H Garcia

Excellent and delicious pizza, strongly recommend, and the service was great!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 5 Cheese Pizza - A Different Taste for Pizza Large

Thaddaeus Garrett

They never have delivery driver every time I walk in they have attitude as if they don’t want to be bothered sorry that you guys are lazy teenagers

Rodney Wilson

Great Pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish

Isaac Kidd

Awful customer service! On 5/6/24 they did not answer the phone for three straight attempts. Answered on the fourth attempt and placed me on hold for 5 minutes before hanging up on me. I called back and they said they were not taking orders because it they were closing soon - an entire hour prior to the listed closing time.

Naomi Camara

HI I love getting my pizza from Captain Tony's, it's always sooo good!! Thank you. From

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roshan

Meh, felt like I could have made this at home. Fresh ingredients but bland. Eggplant Parm was 2 thin slices of eggplant on a bed of mostly spaghetti... Vegetable pizza was also bland, even with

Food: 1

Woods

Nice Place for a Pizza Restaurant Nice service. did a bit of trolling with my friends that work there! really fun and good pay!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Chimene Anderson

Great food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...