Angelina's Villa

5450 E Livingston Ave, Columbus
(614) 866-7827

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Quala Merritt

Family owned cheap prices and yummy😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Juah Nimely

I am done ordering from here, never again (after 12 years) and disputing charge with my bank bc they refused to credit me for the missing topping. Word of advise, do not pay for delivery, go in and look at your pizza, make sure all your toppings are there before paying, if order is not correct just don’t pay and walk out bc who in the world waiting for another 20-30 mins for their food. The pizza was dry, sour and salty as well and I don’t like they closed the drive thru bc it’s not safe over there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Ordman3681

First Time Ordering today.
Pizza is wonderful!
Spaghetti and Lasagna are Tasty!!
My wife (who is VERY picky with her wings) Said they are the best she has had in a while!
You now have a new regular!!
Thank you and much continued success!

Food: 5

Audrey b

Update:
Thank you for the reply! It shows you truly care. I'm sure your food reflects it as well.

Take out or delivery only. No dine in. They really update the info on here

cheniqua barton

My first time there , I ordered the chicken spaghetti and the chicken was definitely not done or not real meat at all! I’m a organ transplant patient and I called in and they said that’s just how it is and it’s pre made before they even get it and they just run It through the oven twice. They was not willing to replace it they basically just said oh well!

Food: 2

Johnna Bailey

The best pizza ever & I've been getting pizza there for over 5 years now !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef Pepperoni Pizza

evildog123

Chicken for chicken parm is chicken nugget material. Would be great if it were regular chicken.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Jordan L

Pros: Tried this for the first time a few weeks ago and have already been back twice. I just get a medium pep with extra cheese and it’s very good. The crust, the sauce, cheese, I love every bite. I did get an Italian sub the first time also and didn’t like it all. It was not that tasty and soggy (threw it away) so I won’t get it again but I came specifically for the pizza so I wasn’t that mad over it.

Cons: they charge extra just for using a card to pay no matter the amount and it’s a percentage of whatever you’re buying. It’s 2025, why is this a thing here? Idk any other restaurant that charges additional JUST to use a card as payment. The only time I see this done is at drive thrus or corner stores if you spend less than $5. Also last time I came, the man at the register made me put $0.17 on my card just for garlic sauce. I thought I had enough change but I didn’t. I know it’s not his fault but I definitely get money hungry vibes from this establishment. Yes I will be back! 😂

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sweet Tee

I've been told about Angelina's Villa a few times and just how good the pizza is. One particular highlight is they offer beef pepperoni. Today, my team at work had a lunch meeting and we decided to to bring pizza from a few different places to try. I ordered from Angelina's. I can't rate the service or the atmosphere because my son picked up my order for me and brought it to my job. What I can rate is the pizza and man is it SO GOOD!!! It was hot, fresh and flavorful!! I ordered a beef pepperoni pizza (I forget what it's called on the menu) and a buffalo chicken pizza. The beef pepperoni was cooked to perfection in my opinion...crispy, curled edges and soft but chewy in the middle. I gave up pork a few years ago and haven't had a pepperoni pizza since. This was worth every penny!! If I thought about going back to pork, I would have changed my mind today. The buffalo chicken pizza is a great sauce to toppings ratio and it has just a hint of kick to it and the perfect level of saltiness. Yum!! My team ate every piece!! I'm getting another one this weekend. If you haven't tried Angelina's Villa, please do so. You will not be disappointed!

Food: 5

Mozella “Mobetta” Ibrahim

I was visiting from out of town and searched for a spot that had beef pepperoni. This was the first one that came up and was close to my hotel. Their pizza is in the style of Donatos pizza and flat bread style. I prefer a traditional pan style or New York style myself, but it was tasty. I also ordered wings the were not tasty at all. They were huge which is not good if you care for taste and healthy meat. A huge chicken mean it's pumped full of crap to get it that size and you can taste it in the meat. I prefer a natural size wing non hormones. So I didn't eat one wing but my companion didn't care about such things and ate them, so my money wasn't totally wasted. Overall the pizza was OK but pass on the wings if your choosy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ryan Ry

Terrible customer service
Everyone acts like they don’t wanna be there
The one guy took my order was rude
The girl came in from outside didn’t wash her hands and started making pizzas that’s trifling
Nobody hands are clean enough for me I don’t understand why food establishments don’t make employees wear gloves and make sure they are changing them you can’t be touching your hair , phone , money and proceeded to make someone food

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tom Rager

This is the 1st time my wife and I tried your pizza. We are so impressed!! We ordered the special 11.99 pepperoni pizza and the cheesy garlic bread WOW!! The sauce was so full of flavor the crust thin crispy and buttery!! Loaded with cheese and the round cup pepperoni it the staple everyone loves! This will not be our last time getting your delicious food. Looking forward to trying other things from your menu!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Larry Virden

Ran in, got a pizza and sub. Both were okay.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Rod Peterson

Great pizza, definitely not going to complain about the price. This place is my new go to whenever I'm in the area

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Strother

Very nice owners

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...