Working in town and I googled pizza and looks like I picked the right one. The guys were helpful. I went with the Philly cheese calzone and was glad I did! It was very tasty and chose the smaller portion and it was more than enough. They were moderately busy, but only took about 20 minutes to get my food.
Blonde Psyduck
The pizza tastes good. Both of my attempts there, though, I tried to order an extra large pizza and instead I get the large. It sounded like the guy put the phone down today while we were talking and our conversation was painful. I wasn't overcharged thankfully but now both visits I'm left hungry after dinner. Guess it isn't meant to be.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
RASHID WILLIAMS
In a quest for the ultimate pizza experience, I ventured into Big Tony's Pizza with high hopes and a rumbling stomach. However, what awaited me was a culinary letdown of epic proportions.First and foremost, the absence of tomato sauce on the pizza was perplexing. A pizza without its signature sauce is akin to a car without wheels – it just doesn't work. Instead, I was greeted by a dry, lackluster crust that resembled more of a breadstick than a pizza base. The texture was dense and chewy, lacking the airy lightness that characterizes a well-crafted pizza crust.The toppings, while plentiful, failed to salvage the disappointing base. Despite opting for a variety of toppings, including pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers, they were unable to compensate for the absence of sauce and the lackluster crust. Each bite felt like a chore, as I struggled to muster enthusiasm for what should have been a delightful dining experience.Service-wise, Big Tony's Pizza fell short as well. The staff seemed indifferent to the lackluster quality of their offerings, displaying a nonchalant attitude that did little to reassure me of their commitment to culinary excellence.In conclusion, my experience at Big Tony's Pizza was underwhelming, to say the least. With its dry crust, absence of tomato sauce, and indifferent service, it failed to deliver on the promise of a satisfying pizza experience. I'll be taking my appetite elsewhere in the future.eally like it
Max
I called in to order a 14" Pepperoni and a chicken tender dinner. I was told they were closing early today but would still fill my order. I got there before the early closing time and paid -for what I ordered-. When I got home I found out that I had received was a 12" Cheese Pizza and a 6-Piece BBQ Boneless wing. I was over-charged 7$ for the wrong order. I don't dispute the base quality of the food, but my evening is worse for this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Tabbetha G.
This was our first time ordering Big Tony's. We ordered garlic knots, pizza, salad, and eggplant. The kids devoured the garlic knots. The salad was typical and the house dressing was good. The cheese pizza was good- but we would just as easily order from any competitor. The let down of our dinner was the eggplant. The eggplant itself was perfectly breaded but the pasta sauce is not something I would eat again. We threw all of the pasta the eggplant sat on away.
Rob K.
Ordered pepperoni lovers 14" for 22.99 on app, if you like your thin crust delivered in a puddle of grease, this is your place. Honestly ate 1 piece and threw away, not a good pizza.
angel wolfe
Best pizza ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Slick Nick
Ordered delivery so can't speak for done in experience. But, I must say that I was thoroughly impressed with the quality here. Best pizza I've had in Ohio (moved from Chicago). Also the calzone was phenomenal!
Food: 5
Jennie M.
It was alright. Not bad just alright. We had the steak and cheese calzone. It was bland but looked like a million bucks for sure
T Thacker
I liked it got a large pepperoni pizza and sub love the bread on sub nice and crispy not soggy first time trying good
Truly my favorite pizza restaurant, from the hand made crust, to the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ty Weisman
Best sub I’ve ever had!! Friendly staff and quick service for an awesome lunch deal ? highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
warsame hasan
Favorite place to get pizza from! Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim Garavuso
Ordered 13 pizzas and salad for a large lunch meeting and Big Tony’s came through in a big way! They were on time and I got rave reviews from those who attended the meeting about how good it was! I had googled pizza delivery near the meeting address and Big Tony’s had 4.8 stars and now I know why! Adding my 5 star review to add to it! Big Tony called me the next day to see how the order was. Who has time to do that these days? Super impressive! I’ll order again from Big Tony’s!
I got chicken Alfredo from here and there wasn't even any Alfredo sauce! It was just cheese and noodles with the most disgusting chicken I've ever tasted in my life. A huge waste of money
Working in town and I googled pizza and looks like I picked the right one. The guys were helpful. I went with the Philly cheese calzone and was glad I did! It was very tasty and chose the smaller portion and it was more than enough. They were moderately busy, but only took about 20 minutes to get my food.
The pizza tastes good. Both of my attempts there, though, I tried to order an extra large pizza and instead I get the large. It sounded like the guy put the phone down today while we were talking and our conversation was painful. I wasn't overcharged thankfully but now both visits I'm left hungry after dinner. Guess it isn't meant to be.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
In a quest for the ultimate pizza experience, I ventured into Big Tony's Pizza with high hopes and a rumbling stomach. However, what awaited me was a culinary letdown of epic proportions.First and foremost, the absence of tomato sauce on the pizza was perplexing. A pizza without its signature sauce is akin to a car without wheels – it just doesn't work. Instead, I was greeted by a dry, lackluster crust that resembled more of a breadstick than a pizza base. The texture was dense and chewy, lacking the airy lightness that characterizes a well-crafted pizza crust.The toppings, while plentiful, failed to salvage the disappointing base. Despite opting for a variety of toppings, including pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers, they were unable to compensate for the absence of sauce and the lackluster crust. Each bite felt like a chore, as I struggled to muster enthusiasm for what should have been a delightful dining experience.Service-wise, Big Tony's Pizza fell short as well. The staff seemed indifferent to the lackluster quality of their offerings, displaying a nonchalant attitude that did little to reassure me of their commitment to culinary excellence.In conclusion, my experience at Big Tony's Pizza was underwhelming, to say the least. With its dry crust, absence of tomato sauce, and indifferent service, it failed to deliver on the promise of a satisfying pizza experience. I'll be taking my appetite elsewhere in the future.eally like it
I called in to order a 14" Pepperoni and a chicken tender dinner. I was told they were closing early today but would still fill my order. I got there before the early closing time and paid -for what I ordered-. When I got home I found out that I had received was a 12" Cheese Pizza and a 6-Piece BBQ Boneless wing. I was over-charged 7$ for the wrong order. I don't dispute the base quality of the food, but my evening is worse for this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
This was our first time ordering Big Tony's. We ordered garlic knots, pizza, salad, and eggplant. The kids devoured the garlic knots. The salad was typical and the house dressing was good. The cheese pizza was good- but we would just as easily order from any competitor. The let down of our dinner was the eggplant. The eggplant itself was perfectly breaded but the pasta sauce is not something I would eat again. We threw all of the pasta the eggplant sat on away.
Ordered pepperoni lovers 14" for 22.99 on app, if you like your thin crust delivered in a puddle of grease, this is your place. Honestly ate 1 piece and threw away, not a good pizza.
Best pizza ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Ordered delivery so can't speak for done in experience. But, I must say that I was thoroughly impressed with the quality here. Best pizza I've had in Ohio (moved from Chicago). Also the calzone was phenomenal!
Food: 5
It was alright. Not bad just alright. We had the steak and cheese calzone. It was bland but looked like a million bucks for sure
I liked it got a large pepperoni pizza and sub love the bread on sub nice and crispy not soggy first time trying good
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Truly my favorite pizza restaurant, from the hand made crust, to the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best sub I’ve ever had!! Friendly staff and quick service for an awesome lunch deal ? highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Favorite place to get pizza from! Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered 13 pizzas and salad for a large lunch meeting and Big Tony’s came through in a big way! They were on time and I got rave reviews from those who attended the meeting about how good it was! I had googled pizza delivery near the meeting address and Big Tony’s had 4.8 stars and now I know why! Adding my 5 star review to add to it! Big Tony called me the next day to see how the order was. Who has time to do that these days? Super impressive! I’ll order again from Big Tony’s!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Mozzarella and Roasted Tomatoes, Margarita Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
I got chicken Alfredo from here and there wasn't even any Alfredo sauce! It was just cheese and noodles with the most disgusting chicken I've ever tasted in my life. A huge waste of money