Fate Cakes

1360 Cherry Bottom Rd, Columbus
(614) 219-9429

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Vanilla Birthday Cake Standard Size
Happy Birthday 12 Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cake
Chocolate Cake
Wedding Cake

Menu

Popular Assortments (12 pcs)
Custom Assortment (12 pcs)
Mix and match up to 4 tempting flavors to make your own delicious dozen. Pricing varies by selection
Happy Birthday Cupcakes (12pcs)
Surprise someone special on their birthday with these special Happy Birthday cupcakes.
Ohio State (12 pcs)
We're celebrating scarlet and grey with these buckeye-themed cupcakes. Perfect for any student or fan of the Ohio state university. They're bound to go ‘nuts'.
Rainbow Swirl (12 pcs) (Colors May Vary)
These rainbow buttercream cupcakes pop with bright colors. Add toppers and these could even be perfect for a unicorn party, tie-dye birthday, or just a great way to celebrate summer or an outdoor barbecue or event.
Floral Bouquet (12 pcs) (Designs May Vary)
They're beautiful, edible, and most importantly delicious! One of our most popular varieties make the perfect gift for every occasion.
Sophisticated & White (12 pcs)
What better way to showcase a treat more classically and simply than these beautiful cupcakes. Our white silky buttercream is the backdrop with some pearl sprinkles and single silver bling.
Colored Rosettes (12 pcs)
Choose between two colors as the beautiful rosettes on top of these twelve cupcakes.
The Classic (12 pcs)
Our signature buckeye cupcake is the perfect addition to this simple but delicious mix. The best way to eat these treats is with a cupcake in each hand and we're sure they'll be devoured quickly. The vanilla lovers and chocolate lovers are always paired nicely together and red velvet and buckeye flavors will continue to be a crowd favorite.
Gender Reveal (12 pcs)
Announce your baby's gender with these beautiful and delicious pink/blue swirl cupcakes. Choose a colored center or leave it as a surprise!

Cupcakes
Buckeye (3 Total Cupcakes)
O-H…I-O! Buckeye lovers delight! Chocolate and peanut butter are paired beautifully with this rich cupcake and silky buttercream. These explosive flavors are a crowd favorite. Garnished with a delicious, savory candy buckeye, you're ‘nuts' if this wasn't a center treat at your next party or event!
Chocolate Birthday Cake (Colors May Vary) (Standard Size)
Decadent rich, dark chocolate cupcake topped with chocolate buttercream and sprinkles. What goes better with chocolate then more chocolate. A chocoholics dream! A dark and moist chocolate cupcake topped with fluffy chocolate buttercream and even more chocolate (sprinkles) to satisfy anyone's chocolate cravings. If you like your chocolate cake rich and full of flavor we'll guarantee your taste buds
Cookies N' Cream (3 Total Cupcakes)
A cookie lovers delight. Influenced by our favorite cookie, this cake is our signature chocolate, but the garnish is the real masterpiece of this dessert. We chop Oreo cookies in chunks top them on our signature vanilla buttercream which we could eat with a spoon by itself. We're ready to cuddle up on the couch with this ‘Lil treat.
Red Velvet (3 Total Cupcakes)
Draped in velvety goodness, this vibrant redhead is the talk of the town. Rich and savory in flavor, there's almost a sophistication in how the dark red hue combines with our moist, chocolate cake. As if this cake wasn't already overly desired, a creamy and light vanilla buttercream adds an extra pairing of flavors no one could resist. A gingerly touch of bright red sugar sprinkles makes this treat unforgettable.
Salted Caramel (3 Total Cupcakes)
Salt and caramel unite. Our homemade toffee and caramel inspire this decadent cupcake. A taste bud tantalizing delight of vanilla cupcake and vanilla buttercream with a generous amount of the buttery toffee and drizzle it liberally with our loaded caramel.
Strawberry Shortcake (Standard Size)
This cupcake feels like summer. As one of our most popular cupcakes, it's a light and airy yellow cake covered with creamy vanilla buttercream and then topped with strawberry juice drizzle and a ripe, fresh strawberry. And it's not just pretty to look at. The buttercream and cake practically melt in your mouth. Fresh and juicy strawberries added to this delectable cupcake are what make your mouth water. (yea, we caught your drooling). The crisp fruit flavor paired with the light buttery cake will keep your tastebuds begging for more.
Triple Chocolate (3 Total Cupcakes)
What goes better with chocolate than more chocolate. A chocoholics dream. A dark and moist chocolate cupcake topped with fluffy chocolate buttercream and even more chocolate (sprinkles) to satisfy anyone's chocolate cravings. If you like your chocolate cake rich and full of flavor we'll guarantee your taste buds will be satisfied with one – or maybe two.
Vanilla Birthday Cake (Colors May Vary) (Standard Size)
Flavorful vanilla cupcake topped with a creamy whipped vanilla buttercream and white sanding sugar. All things vanilla! A flavorful, light, fluffy and satisfying vanilla cupcake topped with a generous heap of whipped and creamy vanilla buttercream. A white sanding sugar adds the perfect decoration to a flawless treat.
Vanilla Lovers (3 Total Cupcakes)
All things vanilla. A flavorful, light, fluffy and satisfying vanilla cupcake topped with a generous heap of whipped and creamy vanilla buttercream. White sanding sugar adds the perfect decoration to a flawless treat.

Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie Bites Bag (1/5 lb)
We've cut up our delicious chocolate chip cookies and bagged them for a 1/5 pound of deliciousness. The bag itself is about 2 jumbo cookies and perfect as a snack or to the top on your favorite ice cream.
M&M Cookie Bite Bag (1/5 lb)
We've cut up our delicious m&m cookies and bagged them for a 1/5 pound of deliciousness. The bag itself is about 2 jumbo cookies and perfect as a snack or to the top on your favorite ice cream.
Chocolate Chip Sammy
Our most popular chocolate chip cookie sandwiched between silky buttercream and dipped in chocolate sprinkles
Jumbo Chocolate Chip
Crispy edges with a gooey center. This 4-inch jumbo chocolate chip cookie is mouth-watering delicious.
Jumbo M&M
Crispy edges with a gooey center. This 4-inch jumbo m&m cookie is mouth-watering delicious and is such a colorful treat in every bite.
Jumbo Oatmeal Cream Pie
Two of our soft and rich oatmeal cookies are stuffed with a decadent vanilla buttercream. These are one of the most popular items we sell daily, and typically go out of stock before the end of the day! Get one (or two) while you can!
Jumbo Peanut Butter
SUPER SOFT! This 4" Jumbo peanut butter cookie is mouth watering delicious and topped with salty gourmet peanuts, giving it the most sweet/salty and crunchy texture!
Jumbo White Macadamia Nut
Crispy edges with a gooey center. This 4-inch jumbo white chocolate chip macadamia nut cookie is mouth-watering delicious. The perfect combination of sweet/salty and crunchy.

Other
Brookie (1 sl)
Our signature combination of a bottom chocolate chip layer, chocolate brownie center and topped with our rich and silky chocolate buttercream.
Cake Pop (1 pc) (Designs & Flavors May Vary)
These are practically brownies covered in chocolate. A soft and moist cake pop is dipped in chocolate and we garnish with some cute sprinkles! The flavors vary every day between vanilla, chocolate and red velvet.
Jumbo Buckeye (GF)
This one's a big one. 4x the size of a standard-sized buckeye candy. Are you an Ohio fan, or, Ohio state buckeye fanatic. This homemade candy is for you. Our homemade buckeyes are a popular treat for any Ohio state university student and tailgating. These candies are a staple for any party in the local area and have become a traditional dessert and treat at most parties and events around the Columbus area. Made and rolled by hand, these delicious and rich candies are a sweet gift to deliver for any birthday or special occasion.
Jumbo Rice Treat (1 sl) (GF)
Delicious and crispy treat with a buttery marshmallow taste. Decorated daily with a variety of designs.
Lemon Blueberry Cake (1 sl)
Our most popular item is always our daily menu. A moist lemon and blueberry cake topped with a generous swirl of vanilla buttercream.

Cheesecake
Oreo Cheesecake (1 sl)
Possibly the best cheesecake ever. Our regular customers sell us out of this treat almost every day. A creamy and light cheesecake is mixed with oreo bits with a layer of cookies between the crust. We top the whole dessert with a rich layer of chocolate ganache and each slice gets a swirl of vanilla buttercream and cookie to garnish.
Reese Cup Cheesecake (1 sl)
Our customers swear this is the best cheesecake they've ever had, even better than the big brand restaurant. Light, creamy, and rich in flavor, this peanut butter cheesecake is based on top of a graham cracker crust with Reese cups between the layers then topped with a solid layer of chocolate ganache and garnished with more Reese cups.

Valentine's Day
Chocolate Covered Strawberries (6ct)
A half dozen (6) fresh strawberries dipped and drizzled in a delicious chocolate
Chocolate Covered Strawberries (12 ct)
A dozen (12) fresh strawberries dipped and drizzled in a delicious chocolate
Rose Cupcakes (6ct) (Flavors: Chocolate and Red Velvet)
Half dozen (3 Chocolate, 3 Red Velvet) buttercream rose decorated cupcakes.
Rose Cupcakes (12 ct) (Flavors: Chocolate and Red Velvet)
Full dozen (6 Chocolate, 6 Red Velvet) buttercream rose decorated cupcakes.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+27 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+26 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Fate Bakery is a fabulous one-woman show and she delivered the most spectacular 2-tier cake for our pre-wedding party that I have ever seen! Our guests literally raved about how tasty and moist the cake was and how delicious the frosting tasted. And the calla lilies that were created for the topper were simply exquisite. Thank you so much - we will recommend you to everyone!! Shirley Lange
July 2025
Our little Godzilla cake was the cutest thing I’ve ever seen in my life. The cake and icing itself was DELICIOUS. I also really appreciated how easy and quick communication was. Will definitely be ordering again for future events!
July 2025
I had a wonderful experience ordering a birthday cake for my husband's birthday! Marie was so responsive and helpful! The cake was beautiful and so delicious! Highly recommend!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Los Guachos - 1344 Cherry Bottom Rd
Mexican, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Buffalo Wild Wings - 1380 Cherry Bottom Rd
Chicken Wings, American, Sports Bar, Vegetarian
Panda Wok - 6771, 1390 Cherry Bottom Rd
Japanese, Chinese

Fate Cakes

1360 Cherry Bottom Rd, Columbus, OH 43230
(614) 219-9429