Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

59 Spruce St, Columbus
(614) 228-9960

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Milkiest Chocolate and Peanut Butter Waffle Bowl
Buttercrisp Waffle Cones
Brambleberry Crisp Pint
Fluffernutter Pie Pint
Texas Sheet Cake
Ice Cream Cone

Menu

Featured items
Buttercream Birthday Cake Pint
Buttercream frosting, golden cake, and a rainbow of sprinkles. What every birthday cake should taste like.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, egg
Rainbow BFY Pint
A smashing combination of tastes and aromas: passion fruit, raspberry, and key limeyogurts. Tropical, tart, and uber creamy.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks Pint
Salted and roasted ground peanuts with grass-grazed milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flecks.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, soy, peanut
Brambleberry Crisp Pint
Oven-toasted oat streusel and a sweet-tart "brambleberry" jam of blackberries and blackcurrants layered throughout vanilla ice cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, wheat
Gooey Butter Cake Pint
Cream cheese ice cream layered with crumbles of soft vanilla cake and swirls of made-from-scratch caramel-butterscotch sauce.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, egg
Brown Butter Almond Brittle Pint
Brown-butter-almond candy crushed into buttercream ice cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, tree nut (almonds)
Lemon Bar (DF) Pint
Punchy lemon curd, shortbread crust, and rich coconut cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: Tree Nuts (Coconut), Wheat
Milkiest Chocolate Pint
An ultra-lush milky chocolate, like a fine Swiss bar. Evaporated milk imparts concentrated milkiness and delightful chewiness.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Honey Vanilla Bean Pint
A vanilla to end all vanillas. Made with Fair Trade vanilla beans that are warm and complex in flavor and a perfect partner for a touch of honey and grass-grazed milk.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Coffee With Cream & Sugar Pint
Intelligentsia coffee steeped in cream. The sweet, complex flavor and robust aroma of freshly brewed coffee shines through.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Blackout Chocolate Cake Pint
A chocolate ice cream quadruple threat with cake, extra-bitter fudge, and chocolate pieces.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, soy, wheat
Salty Caramel Pint
Fire-toasted sugar with sea salt, vanilla, and grass-grazed milk. A perfect balance of salty and sweet.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Texas Sheet Cake (DF) Pint
Decadent chocolate cake crumbles, bittersweet fudge, and palate-gripping cocoa. Big, bold, beautiful.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)VeganContains: wheat, tree nut (coconut)
Darkest Chocolate Pint
Mouth-filling and palate-gripping with a pleasingly dry finish. The most amount of Fair Trade cocoa and the least amount of anything else.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Cold Brew With Coconut Cream (DF) Pint
Light and bright Slingshot Coffee cold brew sorbet twisted with lush coconut cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeVeganContains: tree nut (coconut)

Pints
Rainbow BFY Pint
A smashing combination of tastes and aromas: passion fruit, raspberry, and key limeyogurts. Tropical, tart, and uber creamy.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Gooey Butter Cake Pint
Cream cheese ice cream layered with crumbles of soft vanilla cake and swirls of made-from-scratch caramel-butterscotch sauce.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, egg
Coffee With Cream & Sugar Pint
Intelligentsia coffee steeped in cream. The sweet, complex flavor and robust aroma of freshly brewed coffee shines through.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Brambleberry Crisp Pint
Oven-toasted oat streusel and a sweet-tart "brambleberry" jam of blackberries and blackcurrants layered throughout vanilla ice cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, wheat
Lemon Bar (DF) Pint
Punchy lemon curd, shortbread crust, and rich coconut cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: Tree Nuts (Coconut), Wheat
Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks Pint
Salted and roasted ground peanuts with grass-grazed milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flecks.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, soy, peanut
Buttercream Birthday Cake Pint
Buttercream frosting, golden cake, and a rainbow of sprinkles. What every birthday cake should taste like.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, egg
Blackout Chocolate Cake Pint
A chocolate ice cream quadruple threat with cake, extra-bitter fudge, and chocolate pieces.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, soy, wheat
Darkest Chocolate Pint
Mouth-filling and palate-gripping with a pleasingly dry finish. The most amount of Fair Trade cocoa and the least amount of anything else.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Texas Sheet Cake (DF) Pint
Decadent chocolate cake crumbles, bittersweet fudge, and palate-gripping cocoa. Big, bold, beautiful.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)VeganContains: wheat, tree nut (coconut)
Honey Vanilla Bean Pint
A vanilla to end all vanillas. Made with Fair Trade vanilla beans that are warm and complex in flavor and a perfect partner for a touch of honey and grass-grazed milk.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Brown Butter Almond Brittle Pint
Brown-butter-almond candy crushed into buttercream ice cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, tree nut (almonds)
Cold Brew With Coconut Cream (DF) Pint
Light and bright Slingshot Coffee cold brew sorbet twisted with lush coconut cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeVeganContains: tree nut (coconut)
Salty Caramel Pint
Fire-toasted sugar with sea salt, vanilla, and grass-grazed milk. A perfect balance of salty and sweet.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Wildberry Lavender Pint
Intensely fruity with the brambly berry flavor of pulverized blackcurrants. Scented with sweet orange and lavender essential oils.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Dark Chocolate Truffle (DF) Pint
Complex and ethereal flavor from the best cocoa the world has to offer. Finishes with an ultralight hint of coconut cream.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeVeganContains: Tree Nuts (coconut)
Milkiest Chocolate Pint
An ultra-lush milky chocolate, like a fine Swiss bar. Evaporated milk imparts concentrated milkiness and delightful chewiness.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Boozy Eggnog Pint
Silky egg custard spiked with nutmeg and Uncle Nearest whiskey. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, egg
Buckeye Frenzy Pint
Like a peanut butter cream candy with a chocolate shell and crispy rice treat center. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, soy, peanut, coconut
Genmaicha & Marshmallows Pint
Toasted rice green tea-infused ice cream with vanilla marshmallows. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk
Merry Berry Pint
Brambly berry buttermilk cream with amaretti cookies and raspberry coulis. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk, tree nuts (almonds), egg
Middle West Whiskey and Pecans Pint
Middle West Spirits whiskey-fueled ice cream-with notes of butterscotch, honey, and vanilla-laden with crunchy, salty, toasted pecans.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, peanut, tree nut (pecan), wheat
Pineapple Upside Down Cake Pint
Tart pineapple with red cherries, golden cake, and a gooey caramel swirl.(Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: milk, wheat
Rum Ball (DF) Pint
Rum-soaked dark chocolate cream with tangerine and crumbled cake. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Contains: tree nut (coconut), wheat
White Chocolate Peppermint Pint
A swirl of pink and white peppermint with white chocolate freckles. (Pints may come hand-packed if pre-packed pints are sold out.)Gluten-FreeContains: milk

Cones, Sprinkles & Sauces
Buttercrisp Waffle Wedges
Jeni's unique recipe! Buttery and nutty with a hint of salt- the perfect flavor pairing for all of our ice creams. (Comes in a set of 8.)Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Buttercrisp Waffle Cones
Jeni's unique recipe! Buttery and nutty with a hint of salt- the perfect flavor pairing for all of our ice creams. (Comes in a set of 5.)Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Sugar Cones
Flaky cones with great caramelized flavor. Made on vintage cast-iron equipment by our friends at Jagger Cone. Includes 12 cones carefully packaged in our shops. Please note, cones could chip and crumble a bit during delivery transport. VeganContains: soy, wheat
Cake Cones
Classic, slightly salty cake cones. Made on vintage cast-iron equipment by our friends at Jagger Cone. Includes 12 cones carefully packaged in our shops. Please note, cones could chip and crumble a bit during delivery transport.VeganContains: soy, wheat

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+55 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+54 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We were walking around the market and ended up here somehow. The flavours were very interesting and they were very patient, allowing us to taste many of the flavours. The ice cream was really tasty and it was a nice treat while walking around the market.
January 2025
Recommend: brambleberry crisp, honey vanilla bean,
Good: sparkling cherry pie
Ok: nebula berry, purple star born
Meh: waffle cone

I'm impressed by how tart nebula berry was but it wasn't to our taste.

Ice cream is lovely and has a very clean finish but melts quickly.

The employees are kind and offer samples

I was not particularly a fan of the waffle cone which was pretty...
July 2024
This is a busy place later in the day! After noting the traffic patterns on walks through the market, I decided to visit a little after their opening on a Saturday at 9am. I was able to easily look at the offerings and sit at one of the few tables right at the shop. I selected three flavors to try: double dough, salted caramel, and Texas sheet cake. I can see why Jeni’s gets so much hype, because not only were they delicious, but the texture was smooth and wonderful.
June 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Bubbles Tea & Juice Company - 59 Spruce St
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Bubble Tea
Stauf's Coffee Roasters - North Market, 59 Spruce St
Coffee, Coffee Roasteries
Hubert's Polish Kitchen - 59 S, 59 Spruce St
Polish

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 228-9960