Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
CLOSED$$ •
3600 Morse Rd Suite A, Columbus
About Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Reviews
I booked a reservation for party of 6 guests for Mother’s Day @ 6:45p over the phone on May 3, 2025. I was told my reservation was secured, and they had taken my name and phone number down. I called to confirm my reservation this morning (Mother’s Day) and was told perhaps I had the wrong number/redirected to Molene location. I said no, this was for the Peoria location and had previously been told that the evening was fully open and made my reservation. They did not have my...read full review
Simple stated, Incredible
Good food, good service, and good atmosphere! Jordan gave fast, friendly service while training another colleague. Kudos!
Menu
People in Columbus Also Viewed
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse offers a range of delicious and fresh options, with standout dishes like the Filet with Bernaise. Despite having only one steak option, the Ribeye, the service is polite and attentive, with friendly bartenders and servers. Guests have reported excellent experiences with perfectly cooked meals and a pleasant atmosphere, enhanced by privacy curtains. While prices may be a bit steep, the quality and service make it worth the cost. The restaurant maintains a pristine look, with clean floors and an inviting atmosphere. Dishes like salmon, beef Wellington, broccolini, and asparagus have received praise for their quality. Although the restaurant is attached to a Hilton Garden Inn and may be overlooked, visitors are welcome to walk in during normal hours and enjoy a wonderful meal prepared by a talented master chef. The bartender has been highly appreciated for her professionalism and friendly service, helping to make visits memorable. Some guests noted that the wine and sausage bread were average and that there can be a short wait for service. However, there have been concerns about availability, such as a lack of draft beers and limited menu options. Overall, the restaurant aims to provide a great dining experience with delicious food and attentive staff, despite some challenges.