Mitchell's Steakhouse

45 N 3rd St, Columbus
(614) 621-2333

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Brussels Sprouts Applewood Bacon
Pan Seared Sixty South Salmon
Jalapeno Scalloped Potatoes
Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee
Prime New York Strip 14 Oz
Bone-In Filet Mignon
The Steakhouse Wedge
Chocolate Stout Cake
Pepper Pot Calamari
Chocolate Lava Cake

Menu

Featured items
Jalapeno Scalloped Potatoes
Prime Cowboy Ribeye 22 oz
Filet Mignon 7 oz
Mashed Potatoes
Carrot Cake
Brussel Sprouts + Bacon
Ora King Salmon
pan seared / mustard beurre blanc/shaved brussels sprouts saute
Buttered Asparagus

Appetizers
Crab Cake
sweet corn / traditional tartar
Spicy Lobster
tempura fried bites / sriracha aioli
Wild Mushroom Toast
grilled sourdough/red wine demi/parmesan
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
horseradish cocktail sauce
Tuna Tartare
ginger-garlic sauce, avocado, sweet soy, crispy wontons
BBQ Bacon Shrimp
napa cabbage slaw
Prime Meatballs
whipped ricotta, marinara
Pepperpot Calamari
jalapeno/cherry/pepperoncini

Soups + Salads
Classic Caesar
garlic croutons/parmesan crisp
The Steakhouse Wedge
applewood smoked bacon / tomato/house made blue cheese dressing
Lobster Bisque - Bowl
lobster mascarpone / poured tableside
Mitchell's Chop Chop
goat cheese / dates / tomatoes/ sweet corn / sherry vinaigrette
Roasted Beet Salad
red and golden beets, cippollini onions, goat cheese crema
French Onion (Bowl)

Sandwiches
Prime Black & Blue Burger
blackening spice, gorgonzola
Prime NY Dip
horseradish cream, natural jus, gruyere, steak fries
Prime Steak Burger
housemade special sauce, lettuce, pickles, aged cheddar
Prime Mushroom Burger
roasted mushrooms, gruyère, caramelized onions
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
applewood smoked bacon, garlic aioli

Steak + Chops
Prime Cowboy Ribeye 22 oz
Prime New York Strip 14 oz
Prime Ribeye 16 oz
Filet Mignon 7 oz
Prime Ribeye 12 oz
Filet Mignon 10 oz
Australian Lamb Chops
Prime New York Steak Diane
Mushrooms, Dijon, Worcestershire sauce

Compliment Your Steak
Wild Mushroom Saute
Oscar Style
Classic Diane Sauce
Bearnaise Sauce
Shrimp Scampi
Bone Marrow Butter
Cognac Peppercorn Sauce
Chimichurri Sauce
Maxwell Style

Signature Selections
Gouda Stuffed Chicken
gouda/creamy mustard sauce/mashed potatoes
Tenderloin Duet
twin 4oz filet medallions topped oscar style & shrimp scampi style
Filet Oscar 10oz
Tenderloin Trio
filet medallions topped three ways: oscar | shrimp scampi | wild mushrooms
Filet Oscar 7oz
lump crab/bearnaise/asparagus
Gorgonzola Crusted Ribeye 16oz
mushrooms/caramelized onions
Prime New York Steak Diane
Mushrooms, Dijon, Worcestershire sauce

Ocean
Ora King Salmon
pan seared / mustard beurre blanc/shaved brussels sprouts saute
Shrimp Scampi
grape tomatoes/ spinach/ fresh linguine/ white wine garlic sauce
Seared Sea Bass
dashi broth/miso butter/bok choy
Cold water Lobster tail
8oz, drawn butter
Seared Scallops
butternut squash puree, sage-brown butter vinaigrette

Vegetables & Potatoes
Mashed Potatoes
Jalapeno Scalloped Potatoes
Buttered Asparagus
Brussel Sprouts + Bacon
Forest Mushrooms
Hand-Cut Fries
Lobster Mac + Cheese
Chargrilled Broccolini
Roasted Sweet Potato
Cauliflower Gratin

Kids
Chicken Fingers + Fries
Kids Cheeseburger + Fries

Desserts
Carrot Cake
Chocolate Stout Cake

Beverages
Iced Tea
Fountain Style Coke
Fountain Style Diet Coke
Fountain Style Dr Pepper
Fountain Style Sprite
Coffee
Coffee, Decaf

Allergy Notice
Allergy
"If you have a food allergy, please call the restaurant to speak with a Manager after placing your order."

Sandwiches & Burgers & Entree Salads
Grilled Chicken Ceasar
Garlic croutons, Parmesan crisp.
Prime NY Dip
Horseradish cream,natural Jus, gruyere.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Applewood smoked bacon,garlic aioli.
Prime Steak Burger
Housemade special sauce, lettuce, pickles, aged Cheddar.
Grilled Reuben Sandwich
corned beef, sauerkraut, gruyere cheese, special housemade sauce
Prime Steak Burger
housemade special sauce, lettuce, pickles, aged cheddar
Prime Mushroom Burger
roasted mushrooms, gruyère, caramelized onions
Chicken Chop Chop Salad
Goat cheese, dates, asparagus, tomatoes, roasted corn.
Blackened Salmon Ceasar
Garlic croutons, Parmesan crisp.
Black & Blue Wedge Salad
Blackened Sliced Tenderloin, applewood smoked bacon, tomato, house made blue cheese dressing.
Shellfish Cobb Salad
lobster, crab, shrimp, gorgonzola, bacon, egg, tomato, sweet corn, white balsamic

Allergy Notice
Allergy
"If you have a food allergy, please call the restaurant to speak with a Manager after placing your order."

Specialty Lunch Entrees
Prime Steak Frites
prime flat iron, grilled and sliced, chimichurri, hand-cut fries
Pan seared Sixty South Salmon
shaved brussels sprouts + bacon sauté, mustard beurre blanc, mashed potatoes
Oven Roasted Chicken Breast
mushroom ragout, mashed potatoes, broccolini
Lunch Filet Mignon
4oz, mashed potatoes, broccolini
Lunch Filet Oscar
4 oz, lump crab béarnaise, asparagus, mashed potatoes
Lunch Shrimp Scampi
grape tomatoes, spinach, fresh linquine, white wine garlic sauce

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+74 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+73 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went there Saturday night 11/22/25. Right off the bat, my water glass was dirty. When ordering dinner, I was informed that they were out of baked potatoes. A steakhouse out of baked potatoes at 6:30 pm on Saturday? Surely you jest!
The place is loud, but that is to be expected with the high ceilings. Service was above average but not quite as attentive as I would expect for a place with their high prices.
My wife almost found a piece of lobster in the lobster...
November 2025
There were a couple of errors in the orders received, but nothing egregious, and all errors were corrected. The biggest problem was the amount of time it took to receive our food. Granted, we were a large party, however, the restaurant was well aware of our reservation, and it was confirmed previous times before our arrival. Open table states that reservations are for two hours. It was 90 minutes before half of our party received their entrees, so we were fortunate that the restaurant...
November 2025
We sat down and it took over 15 minutes for us to order and after we did and got our 1st course they put the wrong food in front of everyone. We went for my father in laws birthday and they decided when he was opening his gifts would be the perfect time to try and put his food in front of him. It was awkward and a little uncomfortable trying to figure where to put his gift bag and cards and his food plate. They could have waited an extra 5 minutes for us to finish that before...
November 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

GENJIGO - 77 E Gay St
Japanese
Latitude 41 - 50 N 3rd St
Bar, American, New American
Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails - 73 E Gay St
Bar, Lounges, American, Vegan, Vegetarian

Mitchell's Steakhouse

45 N 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 621-2333