Pastaria

59 West Spruce St, Columbus
(614) 228-2850

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chipotle Cream over Bowties
Grilled Chicken Breast
Three Cheese Lasagna
Mini Cannoli 3
Caesar Salad
Creamy Sauce
Pesto

Menu

Uber Eats
Wild Mushroom Prosciutto Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Caesar Side Salad
Includes Caesar dressing on the side.
Chicken Parmesan with a bed of linguine
Chicken parmesan, on a bed of linguine. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Three Cheese Lasagna
Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Tiramisu
Shiitake & Sun Dried Tomato Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Meatballs (3)
Added to your pasta meal.
Italian Sausage Creole
Served on Penne pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Tomato Alfredo
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Mini Cannolis (3)
Traditional Meat Sauce
Served on Linguine. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Chipotle and Tomato Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Smoked Salmon Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Roasted Garlic Rosa
Served on Linguine. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Arrabbiatta
Spicy red sauce on Penne pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Tossed Green Side Salad
Choose Ranch, or Italian dressing.
Puttanesca
Served on Penne pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Extra Pasta
Added to your pasta meal.
Artichoke and Gorgonzola Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Volare Mushroom Trio
Served on Penne pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
White Clam
Served on Linguine. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Extra Sauce
Added to your pasta meal.
Eggplant Parmesan
Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Pesto
Served on Fusilli pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Fresh Mozzarella
Added to your pasta meal.
Sliced Grilled Chicken
Added to your pasta meal.
Spinach and Prosciutto Cream Sauce
Served on Bowtie pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Tomato Basil
Served on Fusilli pasta. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Entree Caesar Salad
Served with Caesar dressing on the side. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Deluxe Baby Green Side Salad
Includes balsamic dressing on the side.
Entree Tossed Green Salad
Choose Ranch or Italian Dressing on the side. Comes with bread and garlic butter.
Entree Deluxe Baby Green Salad
Served with Balsamic dressing on the side. Comes with bread and garlic butter.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+28 photos
Photo credit: google
+27 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pastaria is my go to in the North Market! I have tried many sauces and have never been disappointed but I love spicy so my favorites are Sausage Creole and Chipotle cream. One of the employees suggested to mix them and let me just say… wow 🤤 Always great food and service, and I love that you can get fresh pasta and containers of sauce to go - highly recommend!
October 2025
My favorite Italian in Columbus! Super cute area as well.

I’ve enjoyed several of their sauces with my pasta - my favorites are the Chipotle aoli & tomato Alfredo! I also love the pear/gorgonzola ravioli. The chefs are the real deal & you can tell it’s homemade from scratch. Everything always tastes really fresh & they have a great selection of apps as well.

In addition to frequently dining/takeout, my baby shower was hosted...
October 2025
We chose Pastaria to cater our wedding. Working with Carolyn, the owner, was a smooth process. The food at our wedding was nothing short of delicious! Enjoyed by everyone. The servers during our wedding were polite and helpful. I would definitely recommend Pastaria for your next event.
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sarefino's Pizzeria & Italian Deli - 59 Spruce St
Pizza, Pet Friendly
Culinary Classics Catering by Pastaria - 59 West Spruce St
Caterers, Italian, Vegetarian
Barrel & Boar - 59 Spruce St
Barbecue, Barbeque, American

Pastaria

59 West Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 228-2850