Good, but experiences can be inconsistent. E.g., how much flavor the bourbon and chai buckeye have Edit: thanks for the reply! Will be back next time I'm in town
Carley O'Connor
Bought the traditional and coconut buckeyes - some of the best I’ve tried so far.
Melissa Hooper
Definitely not what I expected. I got a 6 pack, must have been an off day. They were flavorless, and I would have never even know there was peanut butter in them. Most tasteless Buckeyes I have ever had . Save your money and make your own.
Spaz Moorehead
Delicious variety of generously sized delights, with proceeds helping animals. Will definitely return! Well done, ladies!
Mike Kay
The best! All the different buckeyes are delicious! The staff and all the people that work there are super friendly. One of my favorite stops for me and they make great gifts!!
Sara Harrington
10/10 recommend!! They are made just right !!
David Trisel
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
Matthew Rankin
The vegan cookies and cream buckeyes were simply outstanding!! Not too sweet, plenty rich, and delicious! I ate all 3 :)
Mi Mi
Definitely recommend trying. So many yummy flavors to try. The peanut butter is creamy and chocolate just right. Cookie Butter Buckeye was my favorite
Rachel Jones
While their traditional buckeyes are delicious, what really sets The Buckeye Lady apart are their Stuffed Buckeyes. So many amazing flavors and even things you may not think would go great with peanut butter suddenly do. Great for gifting or just as a little treat for yourself. They also have Buckeye making workshops and my work team had a wonderful time with Alicia and her team!
We love the Buckeye Lady! Best quality buckeyes in Columbus. Plus all the great flavors they offer. Everytime I take Buckeyes for hostess gifts or presents everyone raves about them! They are also conveniently located next to my dentist! Ha ha! 😁😍
sam the man
First went to the Buckeye Lady about 2 years ago and have been coming back ever since. The diverse flavors are always something to look forward to and they always taste amazing, the service I recieve is always super kind and welcoming and I love coming back here. My favorite flavor is red velvet.
Matt M
Best place for Buckeyes hands down! Staff is super friendly and helpful.
BayLeigh H
10/10 the cookies and cream and the cheesecake are my favorite stuffed buckeyes and they have a rewards program
Daniel Intrater
We can't thank The Buckeye Lady team enough for being a part of our wedding and helping make it so unforgettable! The buckeyes were an absolute hit with our guests. We can't wait to come back for more. Thank you again for everything!
Highly recommend The Buckeye Lady for any occasion!
Good, but experiences can be inconsistent. E.g., how much flavor the bourbon and chai buckeye have
Edit: thanks for the reply! Will be back next time I'm in town
Bought the traditional and coconut buckeyes - some of the best I’ve tried so far.
Definitely not what I expected. I got a 6 pack, must have been an off day. They were flavorless, and I would have never even know there was peanut butter in them. Most tasteless Buckeyes I have ever had . Save your money and make your own.
Delicious variety of generously sized delights, with proceeds helping animals. Will definitely return! Well done, ladies!
The best! All the different buckeyes are delicious! The staff and all the people that work there are super friendly. One of my favorite stops for me and they make great gifts!!
10/10 recommend!! They are made just right !!
On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.
The vegan cookies and cream buckeyes were simply outstanding!! Not too sweet, plenty rich, and delicious! I ate all 3 :)
Definitely recommend trying. So many yummy flavors to try. The peanut butter is creamy and chocolate just right. Cookie Butter Buckeye was my favorite
While their traditional buckeyes are delicious, what really sets The Buckeye Lady apart are their Stuffed Buckeyes. So many amazing flavors and even things you may not think would go great with peanut butter suddenly do. Great for gifting or just as a little treat for yourself.
They also have Buckeye making workshops and my work team had a wonderful time with Alicia and her team!
Restaurantji Recommends
We love the Buckeye Lady! Best quality buckeyes in Columbus. Plus all the great flavors they offer. Everytime I take Buckeyes for hostess gifts or presents everyone raves about them! They are also conveniently located next to my dentist! Ha ha! 😁😍
First went to the Buckeye Lady about 2 years ago and have been coming back ever since. The diverse flavors are always something to look forward to and they always taste amazing, the service I recieve is always super kind and welcoming and I love coming back here. My favorite flavor is red velvet.
Best place for Buckeyes hands down! Staff is super friendly and helpful.
10/10 the cookies and cream and the cheesecake are my favorite stuffed buckeyes and they have a rewards program
We can't thank The Buckeye Lady team enough for being a part of our wedding and helping make it so unforgettable! The buckeyes were an absolute hit with our guests. We can't wait to come back for more. Thank you again for everything!
Highly recommend The Buckeye Lady for any occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...