14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cortland

“While going to the Mosquito Lake causeway i seen this place and stopped.
GLAD I DID this place is such a gem... like it's literally the best ice cream ever, EVEN better then Dairy Queen..
---
Service was great, the lady in there was so kind and helpful in what I wanted to get, I got the Mecca Mud which is chocolate with caramel and brownie pieces - 100/10 It was so good ??????
All in all for sure was 100/10
---
I FOR SURE WILL be back to try more of their menu
---
Also by the way I have pictures below of the entire menu as of 8/2/2024

Parking: parking is somewhat bad. there is only like 10 or so spots.

Kid-friendliness: they have coloring books and stuff for kids to play with while they wait for the food.“

“All I can say is you guys are absolutely destroying and I mean shiting on handles LOL damn you guys might be some of the best ice cream I think I've ever had I like how it's significantly softer and I like the way that it melts down don't think I've ever had a product quite like yours it kind of reminds me of the texture of talenti and the viscosity of FroYo totally an amazing experience y'all need to stop on down to Katie's Korner“

“I went in last night. It was close to closing time. They probably only had 15 minutes left. I grabbed an ice cream cake and I needed them to draw a mouse on it. The girl asked the guy to draw it while she took a few orders from drive thru and he was worried and saying it looked bad but dawgggg this was the best mouse I’ve ever seen. The person who the cake was for asked how they did it so well. So although I didn’t catch their names, this was the best cake decorating I’ve ever seen. 10/10 thanks for putting up with my shenanigans“

“Cockeye Creamery is hands down our favorite local ice cream stop but we REALLY enjoy it during the fall with your flavors like Carmel apple pie and darkest hour. Seriously the best ice cream ever!!“

“We have liked every flavor we have tried so far!!! Buckeye is my favorite“

“Very friendly staff and yummy ice cream.. sometimes they get a lil busy and need more than 2 people but other than that it's great.. Gia waited on us tonight and she's the sweetest and most friendly young lady.. I give Gia 10 stars♥“

“serve safe environment. making sure employees are wearing gloves to prepare food and the order is correct. lady did give me my money back i had a hair in my hotdog. she said she could make new ones after pulling the hair out of the hotdog again without gloves. i said no just my money back. i wont be going back at all.“

“Nick's DQ is a throwback retro style DQ. He and his team are always friendly and courteous. Some may not agree because they can get overwhelmed at times at peak hours but they will always treat you with the utmost courtesy. My family and our four fur kids made going there a regular event during sunny summer days, and Nick would always be welcoming. Sadly we'll be hard pressed to find another DQ like his, since we're moving. We'll miss the good treats and good times.“

“I had my first Banana Split in years, and boy was it good! I watched the attendant make it, and my mouth watered while I watched! I left a $2 tip. The ice cream was expensive like everything else right now. No drive-thru and seating was outside only. I was very satisfied!“

“You can tell this DQ takes a lot of pride in their store. They make their buster bars, Dilly bars and ice cream sandwiches in the store so they are always super fresh. But one thing I've noticed is that their portions are very very generous, literally the Dilly bars and ice cream sandwiches or twice the size as I've ever seen. In the buster bars peanuts were actually crunchy. I just wish they were open year round.“

“Everything is clean in the store and the cakes look and taste excellent.
I actually live in the next city over, about 15 minutes away, with a DQ in it, and I will drive to this Dairy Queen.
This is the way a Dairy Queen should be run.“

“It's one place you always get smiles from young to old. No matter the cost this summer you have to go to the Dairy Queen. It's our tradition from generations 💗“

“giving them another shot here. don't make me regret it ;)“

“This is my favorite this to get from dairy queen before i try all the food menu items from DQ next year for smash it foodie XL. the employees were super friendly and the food was done well . there was a little wait but trust me its worth it. The chicken was cooked well so were the fries and the classic chili cheese dog was jus amazing the chile cheese dog in my ratings were 7.1 out of 10 the BBQ chicken basket for me is 7.8 out of 10 well done eastwood DQ! see you in the next review "Smash it foodie XL"

Parking: the spot coming out of the drive threw is hard to exit but it good everywhere else

Kid-friendliness: they are very kid friendly“