The Rutherford Café

$ • Sandwich Shops, Salad

Hours:
9 E William St, Delaware
(740) 990-0085

About The Rutherford Café

The Rutherford Café, situated on Williams St near Sandusky St and close to a BP station, is a cozy restaurant that offers made-to-order meals. Notable dishes include the Smokey Sandusky sandwich, grilled cheese, and Lebanon bologna. The café features a variety of sides, such as horseradish pickles, which are highly recommended. The atmosphere is relaxed, with quiet music and well-decorated interior. The service is friendly and efficient, even when customizing orders. Customers praise the food quality, especially the sandwiches, with some mentioning the Southern Peach with Hickory Ham and peach as a favorite. Prices are reasonable, with a half of a sandwich and a fountain drink costing around $11. Seating may be limited, but the quick counter service and affordability make it an attractive option for a meal in Delaware.

Customers' Favorites

The Rutherford Café Reviews

4.6
108 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
76%
4
14%
3
9%
1
1%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about The Rutherford Café

Restaurantji Rating

I love The Rutherford Cafe! They have delicious food with vegetarian + vegan options. Everything I’ve had is delicious and it’s not just a deli sandwich shop. Their flavors have depth using the perfect balance of quality ingredients!

I love The Rutherford Cafe! They have delicious food with vegetarian + vegan options. Everything I’ve had is delicious and it’s not just a deli sandwich shop. Their flavors have depth using the perfect balance of quality ingredients!

Delicious Salads! Second time coming!

Read All Reviews(108)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
The Rutherford Café Menu
The Rutherford Café Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
The Rutherford Café
The Rutherford Café
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 6:30AM - 3PM
Tuesday 6:30AM - 3PM
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday 6:30AM - 3PM
Saturday 8AM - 3PM
Sunday 8AM - 3PM
Updated on: