Sarah's Pizza & Subs Eaton
125 E Main St Suite #1, Eaton
(937) 456-6871
Customers' Favorites
Breadsticks with Cheese Pizza Sauce or Garlic Butter
Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs & Garlic Bread
Chicken Ranch Pizza
Mashed Potato Pizza
Super Deluxe Pizza
Breaded Mushrooms
Cheese Stix
Subs
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Sarah’s has the best pizza in town! Don’t bother with the chain pizza places(like Eaton Papa John’s). Been going here for over 20 years, never disappointed! Don’t settle for pizza that tastes like cardboard (like Eaton Papa John’s). Best Sarah’s pizzas to get are all meat, mashed potato, chicken bacon ranch, or straight up pepperoni. Breadsticks are tasty too😍
First order, ordered a large pep, bacon, xcheese. The bacon was real bacon, plenty of pep, it looked delicious but there wasnt extra cheese on it, and very little to no sauce, making it super dry. Was hoping for a new go to pizza joint.
The food is always good. The service and atmosphere hasn't been up to snuff since we got moved back. It doesn't have the hometown feel anymore the cashier is always rude and if you don't go in it seems like your order isn't done right.