10 Best Caterers near Elyria

“We used Pink Peppercorn Catering for my daughter's bridal shower. They did a taco bar and it was amazing! 5 stars definitely recommend! Thank you for the great food!!!“

“Great wings great bartender and nice atmosphere!“

“We held our wedding reception at Tom’s this past weekend (10/4/25) and the evening was PERFECT! The food, staff, bartenders, and security - were awesome! Everyone at our venue expressed how delicious the food was and how beautiful the event center was decorated. I can’t speak enough about how perfect this place is!

Tell all your friends - it’s a hidden gem!

Ps - Bringing your own alcohol is an added perk - it saved us $1,000s!“

“Amazing food ! Can’t say I’m ever disappointed. I got there at least once a week.“

“Alexia and the team at Thyme are INCREDIBLE. we were fortunate enough to work with alexia and co. while planning our wedding and not only were we impressed with the food options and how delish everything was, but alexia literally made the process SO easy and stress-free for us! we hosted a 225 person wedding in october and our only worry was feeding all our guests good food in a timely manner. alexia provided constant reassurance and allowed us to focus on other small details while having confidence that our guests would be full and happy. every single person we have talked to have commented on the food and how it was the best food and easiest dinner process at a wedding or large event they have ever experienced! so incredibly thankful for the team who worked our wedding and also just thyme in general for having the greatest group of people! in addition to that, my husband and i wanted to incorporate some of our favorite foods and other restaurants from cleveland to give our guests a lil “taste of cle” and tid bits from our love story. alexia seamlessly coordinated donuts, cookies, ice cream, bagel sandwiches, stadium mustard and some very last minute dietary restrictions into the best night ever! from servers passing out appetizers to delivering mitchel’s on the dance floor, you did it all. we are forever thankful for you guys and making one of the best nights of our lives also one of the yummiest! if you are contemplating using thyme for your event, don’t debate any longer. just go with them, you can’t and won’t be disappointed! oh and get the mashed potatoes, they are to die for!!!“

“Thank you for catering our anniversary luncheon on 3/22/25. Everyone loved the food (brisket, chicken paprikash, and vegetable lasagna) and I really appreciate that you accommodated all our food allergies. You went above and beyond making a 1/2 pan of vegan lasagna. I was so grateful there were leftovers.“

“Sterks Catering did not disappoint last evening. They catered for my husband's retirement party and everything was so delicious! The roast beef, city chicken and cabbage rolls could not be beat! Shelly and John are so accommodating and helpful. Our Family has used this business for many years and will continue to do so in years to come. Thank you so much!“

“We had my daughters grad party 8-7. Everything was perfect. I have never seen a more beautiful grad party. The food was super. And the staff was beyond amazing. Thank you so much ♥️“

“I had my wedding reception here and to say it was a dream is such an understatement! Jill is AMAZING! She will get your event planned and set up beyond your expectations! The food was INCREDIBLE! My guest are still talking about it this reception and it’s two months later! Host your event here and I promise you you won’t regret it! Also ask for Laurel as your bartender! She was absolutely amazing and went above and beyond for all my guest! Can’t say enough positive things about this place and their staff!“