New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream
Recent Reviews
260 ratings
Great ice-cream, friendly service and fair prices.
A family tradition - 4 generations!
Be advised they only accept cash. It would be nice if they’d make that known on line. Drove all the way out to be directed to an atm at a nearby bar. No thanks
New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a popular spot known for its best homemade ice cream, including Sundays and root beer floats. Customers drive miles just to enjoy the delicious treats, and even the small cone is big enough to satisfy an appetite. The peanut butter sundae with chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, Reese's cup bits, nuts, whipped cream and a cherry is the best sundae, and customers also recommend the Blue Moon kids sundae. Favorites include butterscotch malt, biscoff cookie, salted caramel truffle, and orange creamsicle. Customers praise the variety of flavors and the friendly customer service. For flavors, check their Facebook page; the two locations have different flavors, with chocolate, vanilla and strawberry at both. Be prepared for a wait and remember it's cash only. Some suggest posting the daily flavors on social media earlier. Overall, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a must-visit for homemade ice cream lovers.