9 Best Bakeries in Lima

Miss Mel's Bakery Bakery • $
2545 Sherwood Dr, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Custom Cookies- Signature Recipe
Birthday Cake
Sugar Cookie
Macaron

“I definitely recommend Miss Mel's! I ordered custom macarons for my dad's retirement party and they were delicious and cute too. He loved them and they were a hit at the party (hence the late photo after a few had already been gobbled up). Miss Mel's was great to work with and also accommodating with pick-up.“

5 Superb84 Reviews
Calla Lily Cakery Bakery •
1311 N Metcalf St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“I ordered a last minute cake for my daughter's 4th birthday and Calla absolutely killed it! I had the happiest little chicken on her special day, the cake looked and tasted amazing! Thank you for working you magic with such little time, we are so greatful and will definitely be ordering again, not so last minute though!“

5 Superb29 Reviews
Mello-Creme Donuts Bakery • $
625 W North St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Cream Filled Long John Creamstick
Doughnuts

“Have been coming here since I was in daycare and just graduated from hs......I swear their donuts have the most homey feel and are always the best of the best!“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
Cake Lady Bakery • $
1705 Mound Rd, Lima
5 Superb13 Reviews
Joy's Cookies Bakery • $
1750 Frail Rd, Lima

“All of Joy's products are homemade which makes for some wonderfully new and unique flavors (grape sugar cookie!) I haven't tasted anything I haven't liked from Joy!“

4.9 Superb8 Reviews
Sara's Sweets Bakery • $
435 S Eastown Rd, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
Assorted Half Dozen Cupcakes
Dozen Assorted Brownies Bars
Soft Frosted Sugar Cookie
Assorted Dozen Cupcakes
Assorted Dozen Cookies
Pecan Sticky Bun
Trail Mix Cookie
Buckeye Cookie
Birthday Cake

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We ordered 10 dozen mini Key Lime cupcakes from Sara’s Sweets for our event and they were amazing! Big hit with everyone — sweet, tangy, and perfect. 🍋🧁“

4.9 Superb79 Reviews
The Meeting Place on Market Coffee Shops • $
220 W Market St, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Pesto Grilled Chicken Wrap & Tomato Soup
Jalapeño Popper Grilled Sandwich
Mozzarella Pesto Grilled Cheese
Maple and Bacon Cupcakes
Blondie White Chocolate
Tomato Bisque Soup
Toasted Bagel
Muffin
Gluten

“I have passed by a few times and finally decided to go in today to see what they have. Seeing they had a grilled cheese and soup combo, and that being my daughter’s favorite, we stayed for lunch. The tomato bisque was delicious, and I asked and just as I figured, homemade. I have only had 2 tomato bisque soups in my life that were that good! We will be back.“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Nickles Bakery Inc Bakery • $
1950 N Sugar St, Lima
3.7 Good29 Reviews
Cinnabon Bakery • $
2400 Elida Rd, Lima

Customers` Favorites

Classic Roll Combo
Caramel Pecanbon
Cinnamon Roll
Churro Stick
Minibon

“Have been in town visiting family and I’ve checked this place out a few times while in the (sad) mall. The Cinnabons seem to be good no matter what time of the day you arrive. Run low close to end of day. The staff is friendly and helpful. The little table could use a bit more sprucing up from time to time, but overall good experience! The classic with an extra icing is hard to beat!“

3.3 Good24 Reviews