I was here in town on business and by far the BEST restaurant in town! Not only was the bartender Nicole absolutely amazing (listen to her recommendations you won’t regret it!) but easily the top 3 best filet I’ve ever had (and I travel all over the country) My only suggestion for the owner is you have to do better marketing bc if it wasn’t for the front desk person at my hotel I wouldn’t have never found this place bc you guys weren’t anywhere near the front page on google when I looked up nearby and best restaurants and you were only 1.5 miles from my hotel! Quick suggestion drop off some cards with the front desk people at the nearby hotels (with maybe some kickback incentives) and you’ll triple your weekday business! The only restaurant that cards up there was roadhouse… no disrespect to roadhouse but people want to try non corporate chains when they travel to different areas. Other than that amazing job on creating a very classy, upscale environment with some of the best food I’ve had especially the bread pudding dessert (maybe rename it to something like mind blower) bc if it wasn’t for Nicole I would’ve never thought to order it. Keep up the great work!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caitlyn Martin
Food was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory Kufchak
This is an outstanding dining destination. The prime rib is exquisite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: OC Prime French Dip, Caesar Salad, Baked Potato
Haley Masters
I wish I could say I enjoyed OCP. BUT. I don’t get to. I made a reservation for 2 for dinner and when we got there the hostess said it would be an hour even with the reservation. So they ruined my anniversary dinner. SO THANK YOU FOR LITERALLY NOTHING.
john schmenk
Costly, but the food was delicious. We had the bacon wrapped scallops, meatloaf, salmon, plus drinks and deserts.Wheelchair accessibility: Have elevator for those unable to navigate the stairs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Gibson
My husband and I had heard many wonderful things about this place so for a late Valentine’s dinner we decided to try it out.. We did have a reservation for 8 but we still did have to wait some time before being sat which would be why I was kinda annoyed/ probably more hungry to begin with. But it was ALL made up & worth the wait once you’re seated. The entire staff including the kitchen staff were very very polite. I didn’t catch my servers name but she was amazing along with everybody else who checked on us! To the guy who made our salad at our table (that was the most amazing salad I’ve ever had) the manger even stopping by the table to ask how everything Was. All around amazing. & not to mention it was literally the best food I’ve ever tasted! I’ve never been so satisfied after leaving a restaurant. Definitely worth trying!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Huck
Its was our first time here. Food, atmosphere and staff were AMAZING. Thank you John Heaphy for a local high quality restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: OCP Tableside Caesar, New York Style Cheesecake, Loaded Baked Potato
Aaron Norris
We had reservations at 7 before the Shadow of Doubt show in the Upper Lounge. We arrive about 45 minutes early prepared to wait a while for a table. This place was absolutely slam packed. Chris, I believe, was the Maitre D. He was excellent to deal with; Extremely friendly and funny.Jessica was our server, one of 4 people that assisted our table. She went above any beyond to make sure she checked in regularly and take care of anything we needed. Every staff member we saw was doing an amazing job and they were all welcoming and enthusiastic!As for the food, we had everything from "The Godfather", appetizers, prime rib, and veal. Everything was delicious. The higher price is worth it when you see what you get. It was an excellent choice to spend our evening. Can't wait to coke back again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Randal Tuttle
Best Steak I have ate in 64 years, Excellent treat for my Wifes 61st birthday, nothing bad only good. Be honest I cant afford to go there except for special occasions but wonderful. I hope this review get to them. Loved it and Thank You !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Allen
My husband and I came on recommendation from a friend. Beautiful restaurant and wonderful food. The steak was perfectly cooked as were the sides. Our waitress was so attentive and helpful and the service overall was perfect. The only negative was what we observed from what seemed to be one of the managers. He was so rude to the waiters and servers, even snapping his fingers at one waiter who was doing 3 jobs of cleaning tables, delivering food and singing happy birthays to different tables. The servers and waitstaff were nothing but responsive, helpful and top notch and I couldn't imagine doing such great work then being snapped at like a dog. He needs to do better and appreciate the employees he has.
Old city prime with that old school gangster flare, it's like you've walked into a movie set. The service is impeccable, and oh my Scott will serenade your occasion with one of the purest voices I've heard in a long time.WAIT.. The food is an upscale steak restaurant. I had the king prime rib (Please have them sear it before the bring to table and what a joy) a perfect medium prime rib with auju ..my my my.One extra note old city prime has live performances you can attend in their separate upstairs venue. I recommend making an evening out of it eat first then go upstairs to enjoy the concert.We enjoyed the Urban Jazz Coalition with their mix of smooth jazz, R&B, and Funk. The band was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ann Love
I was genuinely disappointed in the quality of the food I took my grandmother for her 85th birthday and I asked for everything upgrade there was on the food bill was almost 700$ lobster was just nasty they refused us a booth even tho had 2 elderly ladies with us to asta was overcooked crab was fishy tableside ceaser was wet n disgustingly fishy I wish I could get the money back my grandmother can’t stop complaining thanks a lot drinks were the best part n the bread never again do not waste your money Applebees is better
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jessica R
Servers and bartender are great. The poor female bartender needs someone else behind the bar with her other than the older guy that obviously hates his job and refuses to do anything in regards to customer service other than the bare minimum of preparing server drink tickets and delivering snarky remarks. We waited an hour and 40 minutes for our meal to arrive when we were the 4th couple to arrive to the restaurant. We watched people who arrived 20 minutes after us finish their main course before we even received our meal. It’s absolutely absurd when youre spending $200+ for dinner, and even then it comes out lukewarm at best. The food is good. The communication and efficiency between staff is something I’d expect at an Outback Steakhouse.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Joel Walker
Had reservations at 8 didn't get seated til after 9 after being told it would be 20 min wait. Had plans after dinner we had to cancel bc of late seating. For the amount of money paid for the dinner was not worth the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Joshua Sharninghouse
This is a one of a kind place in Lima. The food and service is truly amazing but you will pay for it. Perfect spot for anniversary or celebration.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak with Shrimp, Oysters Rockefeller, Stuffed Mushrooms
I was here in town on business and by far the BEST restaurant in town! Not only was the bartender Nicole absolutely amazing (listen to her recommendations you won’t regret it!) but easily the top 3 best filet I’ve ever had (and I travel all over the country) My only suggestion for the owner is you have to do better marketing bc if it wasn’t for the front desk person at my hotel I wouldn’t have never found this place bc you guys weren’t anywhere near the front page on google when I looked up nearby and best restaurants and you were only 1.5 miles from my hotel! Quick suggestion drop off some cards with the front desk people at the nearby hotels (with maybe some kickback incentives) and you’ll triple your weekday business! The only restaurant that cards up there was roadhouse… no disrespect to roadhouse but people want to try non corporate chains when they travel to different areas. Other than that amazing job on creating a very classy, upscale environment with some of the best food I’ve had especially the bread pudding dessert (maybe rename it to something like mind blower) bc if it wasn’t for Nicole I would’ve never thought to order it. Keep up the great work!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is an outstanding dining destination. The prime rib is exquisite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: OC Prime French Dip, Caesar Salad, Baked Potato
I wish I could say I enjoyed OCP. BUT. I don’t get to. I made a reservation for 2 for dinner and when we got there the hostess said it would be an hour even with the reservation. So they ruined my anniversary dinner. SO THANK YOU FOR LITERALLY NOTHING.
Costly, but the food was delicious. We had the bacon wrapped scallops, meatloaf, salmon, plus drinks and deserts.Wheelchair accessibility: Have elevator for those unable to navigate the stairs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I had heard many wonderful things about this place so for a late Valentine’s dinner we decided to try it out.. We did have a reservation for 8 but we still did have to wait some time before being sat which would be why I was kinda annoyed/ probably more hungry to begin with. But it was ALL made up & worth the wait once you’re seated. The entire staff including the kitchen staff were very very polite. I didn’t catch my servers name but she was amazing along with everybody else who checked on us! To the guy who made our salad at our table (that was the most amazing salad I’ve ever had) the manger even stopping by the table to ask how everything Was. All around amazing. & not to mention it was literally the best food I’ve ever tasted! I’ve never been so satisfied after leaving a restaurant. Definitely worth trying!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Its was our first time here. Food, atmosphere and staff were AMAZING. Thank you John Heaphy for a local high quality restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: OCP Tableside Caesar, New York Style Cheesecake, Loaded Baked Potato
We had reservations at 7 before the Shadow of Doubt show in the Upper Lounge. We arrive about 45 minutes early prepared to wait a while for a table. This place was absolutely slam packed. Chris, I believe, was the Maitre D. He was excellent to deal with; Extremely friendly and funny.Jessica was our server, one of 4 people that assisted our table. She went above any beyond to make sure she checked in regularly and take care of anything we needed. Every staff member we saw was doing an amazing job and they were all welcoming and enthusiastic!As for the food, we had everything from "The Godfather", appetizers, prime rib, and veal. Everything was delicious. The higher price is worth it when you see what you get. It was an excellent choice to spend our evening. Can't wait to coke back again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Steak I have ate in 64 years, Excellent treat for my Wifes 61st birthday, nothing bad only good. Be honest I cant afford to go there except for special occasions but wonderful. I hope this review get to them. Loved it and Thank You !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I came on recommendation from a friend. Beautiful restaurant and wonderful food. The steak was perfectly cooked as were the sides. Our waitress was so attentive and helpful and the service overall was perfect. The only negative was what we observed from what seemed to be one of the managers. He was so rude to the waiters and servers, even snapping his fingers at one waiter who was doing 3 jobs of cleaning tables, delivering food and singing happy birthays to different tables. The servers and waitstaff were nothing but responsive, helpful and top notch and I couldn't imagine doing such great work then being snapped at like a dog. He needs to do better and appreciate the employees he has.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Oysters Rockefeller
Restaurantji Recommends
Old city prime with that old school gangster flare, it's like you've walked into a movie set. The service is impeccable, and oh my Scott will serenade your occasion with one of the purest voices I've heard in a long time.WAIT.. The food is an upscale steak restaurant. I had the king prime rib (Please have them sear it before the bring to table and what a joy) a perfect medium prime rib with auju ..my my my.One extra note old city prime has live performances you can attend in their separate upstairs venue. I recommend making an evening out of it eat first then go upstairs to enjoy the concert.We enjoyed the Urban Jazz Coalition with their mix of smooth jazz, R&B, and Funk. The band was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I was genuinely disappointed in the quality of the food I took my grandmother for her 85th birthday and I asked for everything upgrade there was on the food bill was almost 700$ lobster was just nasty they refused us a booth even tho had 2 elderly ladies with us to asta was overcooked crab was fishy tableside ceaser was wet n disgustingly fishy I wish I could get the money back my grandmother can’t stop complaining thanks a lot drinks were the best part n the bread never again do not waste your money Applebees is better
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Servers and bartender are great. The poor female bartender needs someone else behind the bar with her other than the older guy that obviously hates his job and refuses to do anything in regards to customer service other than the bare minimum of preparing server drink tickets and delivering snarky remarks. We waited an hour and 40 minutes for our meal to arrive when we were the 4th couple to arrive to the restaurant. We watched people who arrived 20 minutes after us finish their main course before we even received our meal. It’s absolutely absurd when youre spending $200+ for dinner, and even then it comes out lukewarm at best. The food is good. The communication and efficiency between staff is something I’d expect at an Outback Steakhouse.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Had reservations at 8 didn't get seated til after 9 after being told it would be 20 min wait. Had plans after dinner we had to cancel bc of late seating. For the amount of money paid for the dinner was not worth the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
This is a one of a kind place in Lima. The food and service is truly amazing but you will pay for it. Perfect spot for anniversary or celebration.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak with Shrimp, Oysters Rockefeller, Stuffed Mushrooms