facebook instagram facebook instagram

Old City Prime

$$$ • Steakhouses, Bars

Hours:
215 S Main St, Lima
(419) 227-7463

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Old City Prime Reviews

4.4 - 88 reviews

Costly, but the food was delicious. We had the bacon wrapped scallops, meatloaf, salmon, plus drinks and deserts.Wheelchair accessibility: Have elevator for those unable to navigate the stairs

My husband and I had heard many wonderful things about this place so for a late Valentine’s dinner we decided to try it out.. We did have a reservation for 8 but we still did have to wait some time before being sat which would be why I was kinda annoyed/ probably more hungry to begin with. But it was ALL made up & worth the wait once you’re seated. The entire staff including the kitchen staff were very very polite. I didn’t catch my servers name but she was amazing along...read full review
We had reservations at 7 before the Shadow of Doubt show in the Upper Lounge. We arrive about 45 minutes early prepared to wait a while for a table. This place was absolutely slam packed. Chris, I believe, was the Maitre D. He was excellent to deal with; Extremely friendly and funny.Jessica was our server, one of 4 people that assisted our table. She went above any beyond to make sure she checked in regularly and take care of anything we needed. Every staff member we saw was...read full review

More Reviews(88)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
Thursday 5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 9PM
Saturday 5 - 9PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: