23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lima

“Pizza is consistently delicious and fresh!!“

“Anytime I’m exiting I-75 and taking Bluelick road to north Lima, or vice versa, I try to stop into this place because they offer quick, affordable hot sandwiches for folks on the road“

“Awesome time and awesome food as ALWAYS!! Thank you Jamie and girls for helping make our birthday celebration there extra special!“

“workers today were awesome apart from one. but can understand today was chaos but girls did amazing with all issues that happened“

“great service and good food!“

“Went here about an hour ago, had the nicest lady serve me…hope she realized I left her a tip in cash at the counter not on the credit card. Anyway, THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA IN LIMA! The sauce is something you would crave! Finally we found a pizza place, I have tried them all since we moved to Lima…and I thought for sure I will have to start ordering off of Goldbelly…nope…found our spot!!“

“Most times very good, but tonight our fish tasted like it was overcooked. Very tough. Everything else was okay. Did a pickup and they had us pull over. Said it had about 5 minutes, bought it out 15 to 20 minutes later!“

“Never gotten food from there, but they have cigarettes and drinks in stock, an easy place to go for a quick trip and not leave your car. Pumps were running super slow when I gassed my car. I only put in $12.00 and it took almost 15 minutes to pump. But winter will do that to gas pumps/filters/submersible pumps, lots of gas stations have that problem when it's freezing. All in all, good place.“

“This pizza is the best if you eat it at the restaurant instead of takeout. Takeout seems to always not be cooked enough like it's rushed. Depends on the cook if we get our order just how we like it when we done in. Love the salad and chips and ranch. Great place for large groups.“

“Would never have thought of nacho cheese with bread sticks. What a game changer. Exactly what you will find here. The pizza is tavern style. Crust isn’t too thick but not thin and crispy. The sauce is a little on the sweet side but not that overly sweet sauce you find at some places. Nice and cheesy pizza for sure. I see why so many local people I know and the hotel we stayed at recommended them.“

“Perfectly cooked pizza and I dont usually get "boneless wings" but theres are very good.“

“Awesome time and food. Great place to stop and have a meal.“

“Best pizza in the area! Loaded with cheese and toppings and best prices! My favorite pizza and sandwich place. My son asks for it specifically and he’s a known pizza snob. Family that runs it is very friendly. It’s places like this that make you proud to support local businesses. So happy we tried them out, our go-to now!“

“The pizza was amazing really took the time to listen and present more than I could of asked for the atmosphere is beautiful very sweet people in this store definitely a family vibe had a long day with my partner this made it better 10/10 for this location wouldn’t mind coming back
Ps the pizza they customized for me didn’t have a chance“

“We have ordered multiple pizzas and have yet to complain about being undercooked or overcooked! Honestly one of the best pizzas around! And it is a very fast turn around! Every time I have ordered it had been 20 minutes or less, and pizza is always hot and delicious 😋“

“Love their food. It's hands down the best pizzeria in Lima. Those cinnamon sticks are to die for. They're supposed to be dessert but we eat them right away. Plus the price it's amazing too. I can get an 18in 2 topping pizza, cinnamon sticks, which is more like a small cake. A lasagna, and a 2 liter plus delivery for $40. You will pay that much for beer barrel alone and their sauce isn't sweet at all. Which is what I like. Everyone tht tries it loves it or else they're a jerk.“

“Food is always great now and uses quality ingredients, never disappointed! Has items that I want now. my new favorite drive thru closer to home.“

“We came for a visit from Florida have eat there since we moved to Florida bad service the food was not as good as they used to be. Waiting over a hour to get service the it took over a hour to get our food then they forgot 1 person order in our party. Didn't complain because we didn't want to wait another hour for food . What happened? This was on spencervile rd.“

“All around good place to eat“

“I love their Tower pizza best ever“

“We had a wonderful experience here for lunch! I got the supreme burger and it was cooked perfectly. The fries were crispy and crunchy! The salad was made very well and balanced. Our appetizer was the cheese curds. They were hot and crispy! They were served with a marinara sauce and seasoned perfectly. I highly recommend this restaurant! They also have games and a bowling alley! Our server was super friendly and helpful.“

“The night crew was amazing they went above and beyond to correct my order and gave me the pizza they made wrong which made my husband happy he loves meat pizzas thank you for being so awesome the food was great and thank you for giving great customer service“