Frosty's Pizza

$ • Pizza

11 N Main St, Mechanicsburg
(937) 834-1900

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Frosty's Pizza Reviews

4.4 (13)

Pretty good pizza. First time trying them. I thought crust was good and had the right amount of sauce for me. I personally would like a little bit more cheese. I would come back and try them again.

Above average small town pizza. .. the crust had a unique flavor and the toppings were generous.. a little on the greasy side, and partially overcooked on one side, but still very tasty for pizza shop in a very small town. The drive up window (a house window in the alley) was convenient but am puzzled why they didn't use the lower half for an easier hand off of money/pizza. No website found, 1XL and 1 Large 2-topping for $35, so fair but not cheap, or quick (30min). They full review

More Reviews(47)


View all photos


Monday 4 - 9PM
Tuesday 4 - 9PM
Wednesday 4 - 9PM
Thursday 4 - 9PM
Friday 4 - 10PM
Saturday 4 - 9PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: