Frosty's Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours:
11 N Main St, Mechanicsburg
(937) 834-4400

Ratings

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Reviews for Frosty's Pizza

Above average small town pizza. .. the crust had a unique flavor and the toppings were generous.. a little on the greasy side, and partially overcooked on one side, but still very tasty for pizza shop in a very small town. The drive up window (a house window in the alley) was convenient but am puzzled why they didn't use the lower half for an easier hand off of money/pizza.

Frosty's Pizza is definitely a hidden gem in the South Bay! I've been to Howlin' Rays in LA a few times, and this is highly comparable. We ordered the spice level Hot and it was delicious! It was in between Howlin' Rays medium and hot levels. Perfect amount of spice! The chicken is made to order, so expect about a 20-30 minute wait. I recommend ordering sides and having that come out first to hold you over. It is definitely worth it. We also ordered the garlic fries, which were...read full review
Above average small town pizza. .. the crust had a unique flavor and the toppings were generous.. a little on the greasy side, and partially overcooked on one side, but still very tasty for pizza shop in a very small town. The drive up window (a house window in the alley) was convenient but am puzzled why they didn't use the lower half for an easier hand off of money/pizza. No website found, 1XL and 1 Large 2-topping for $35, so fair but not cheap, or quick (30min). They could...read full review

More Reviews(30)

Hours

Monday 4 - 9PM
Tuesday 4 - 9PM
Wednesday 4 - 9PM
Thursday 4 - 9PM
Friday 4 - 10PM
Saturday 4 - 9PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.