9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mechanicsburg

Pizza Alley Pizza • $
10579 OH-4, Mechanicsburg

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger
Ham & Cheese Sub
Grilled Hot Dog
Grilled Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub
Curly Fries
Hamburger

“OMG, this pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever ate….you all need to open up a chain of pizza stores in the Springfield area and remember me when you start making millions.“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Frosty's Pizza Pizza • $
11 N Main St, Mechanicsburg

Customers` Favorites

Extra Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza

“Above average small town pizza. .. the crust had a unique flavor and the toppings were generous.. a little on the greasy side, and partially overcooked on one side, but still very tasty for pizza shop in a very small town. The drive up window (a house window in the alley) was convenient but am puzzled why they didn't use the lower half for an easier hand off of money/pizza. No website found, 1XL and 1 Large 2-topping for $35, so fair but not cheap, or quick (30min). They could be an awesome shop but seems they'll settle for decent.“

4.4 Superb10 Reviews
Goshen Lanes Pizza • $
10579 OH-4, Mechanicsburg

“We have attended multiple birthday parties and events at Goshen Lanes, it's always Fun, the Food is Great, and the service is 2nd to none. The Owners and Staff are Awesome! Best rates and party package deals around. Also, The lanes have been recently renovated , all New and in Great condition! Highly Recommended“

4.7 Superb26 Reviews
Creno's Pizza Pizza • $$
22 S Main St, Mechanicsburg

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Lasagna Dinner
Chicken Wings

“Ordered pick up last night, pizza was great hot, and really good cold the next morning. The Deluxe was great, had a pepperoni, and a custom one on their cauliflower crust which was really good. Thanks for the GF option! Also ordered a couple salads which were fresh. Will be on the lookout for more locations.

Dietary restrictions: GF pizza crust was really good.“

3.6 Good27 Reviews
CATAWBA GENERAL STORE Pizza • $
1 E Pleasant St, Catawba - 6.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Taco Pizza and Cheesy Bread
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Deluxe Pizza

“Absolute great first experience! The owner played MarioKart with my 10 year old son while we waited for our to go order! Got home we smashed every one loved the food. BBQ Chicken Pizza & Regular Pepperoni and Cheese. It was nice to have something different for once and be in such a warm, welcoming, and kid friendly place! Thank you guys we will be back and will support this business always!“

4.8 Superb45 Reviews
Home Town Pizza Pizza • $
5745 Cable Rd, Cable - 7.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread
Breadsticks
Pizza

“Best pizza ever.“

4.2 Good17 Reviews
Panther Pizza Milford Center Pizza • $$
27 E State St, Milford Center - 9.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

10 Old Fashioned Stromboli
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Stromboli Sauce
Pizza

“New to the area and grateful to have such an excellent resource close by. I've read some reviews about the service. I'd only offer my experience. The service was excellent. The food was priced well, well-made, and tasted great! Maybe with the other reviews, the Rona played a factor in things. Either way, offering a little grace and giving them another shot couldn't hurt. I know we will be back. Thanks to the staff, and keep flying your freedom flags;) ?“

3.9 Good9 Reviews
Joe's Lakeside Pizza Pizza • $
1585 Chickasaw Dr, London - 8.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“Moved to the lake recently this year and wanted to try out this local pizza shop.
Absolutely loved the food but wished they had got my pizza ordered correctly! The wings were flavorful and delicious as well. I will be coming here more often!“

3.9 Good12 Reviews
Yummy's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
37 S Mill St, Milford Center - 9.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab Ragoon Egg Roll Paired with Miller Lite
Combination Stir Fried Broccoli

“Our first visit. Nothing fancy but felt comfortable and at ease. Michelle was pleasant, friendly and courteous.Food was amazing. We had the Italian chicken special and some spicy teriyaki wings. Wings were crunchy good. Italian chicken was delicious. We’ll be back for stir fry.We also purchased a piece of carrot cake and some cookies to take home. All were made by Michelle. The carrot cake and cookies were awesome.

Parking: On street parking available. Some side street parking available around the corner

Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair accessible“

4.7 Superb16 Reviews