I order from the New Straitsville location. The food is always good and the staff is always friendly. I also like having an option that delivers! Gotta feed my little pizza monster! 😆
Greg Freeman
Amazing place! The smell of the pizza is so tantalizing you can't help but have something! I had their Pizza Sub, extra cheese! The sauce is amazing, the sub bun was cooked to perfection! The cheese was perfectly melted and the pepperoni had the perfect texture you would expect, and the flavor was perfectly balanced! The service was fast and friendly! Clean (huge!) dining area, kitchen was in order and well maintained bathroom! I love supporting small businesses and this one is absolutely Top Notch! If you are out in the Lake Hope area, and looking for a great meal, with high quality food, fast friendly service, look no further! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub
Nick Green
I love their food. But… my last two orders have been literal nightmares. Starting last week I ordered on a busy night I’ll give them that. I call after patiently waiting 2 hours I get told they forgot about me and that my food is sitting there. After having to sub an item out. I’ll admit I was upset and simply just hung up. So without prompting they bring this food that had been in the bag under a heat lamp for who knows how long. Bun soggy the chicken wings they subbed out had so much sauce I coulda drank it. Then tonight. I call to get my replacement. Order the food long wait. Have no worries I just simply want there food I can wait. Hour and 45 minutes goes by I call they say 25 more minutes with an initial wait time of 1:30. They call me back a few minutes later to tell me they don’t have what i ordered. Wonderful. Super glad that my favorite restaurant has new management and this is how it’s going.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Randy Dearing
And The Help was nice as me.wahooooooo
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AM P
We had a great experience at Little Italy Pizza. The staff was friendly and the food was so good. Will return again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Lewis
If you can't make more orders, shut down your online ordering or atleast have the decency to call me and tell me you won't be making my food. Put the order in 40 minutes before close and didn't realize it would never be coming until 40 minutes after the delivery time. I like your food but this is bullshit.
kyle wendt
I walked in and they guy was supper welcoming. Was short handed tonight and seemed busy! We ordered a 14 inch pizza with pep and banana peppers along with a chicken parm. The food was excellent. The chicken parm my wife loved and had plenty of flavor! With us being from Buffalo the pizza was slamming! The sauce was awsome and had a little sweet to it! I just wanna say that I would absolutely recommend this place for pizza! Well done sir!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza
Nicole Rice
Visited Hocking Hills (Nelsonville) from Detroit area- daily pizza eaters here! Little Italy (Nelsonville) definitely made it to my list of top 5 favorite pizzas I’ve ever eaten!🍕😍
Cyndi White
Andrew was amazing! He was doing everything there....answering phones, waiting tables, cooking, running the drive thru....he was non-stop busy while we were there. He deserves alot more than what he's making an hour.
After traveling several hours from MI, we checked into our hotel and started searching for places to grab a bite. It is a Sunday at 7:30, so not much was open, but Little Italy was there for us! Andrew was an excellent and attentive server. We got our food quickly, and it was delicious. We tried the "cheesy potato" pizza, cheese bread and garden salad. All of it was fresh and done to perfection! If you're staying near Hocking Hills, be sure to check out Little Italy!
Kid-friendliness: The dining area is spacious, there is a picnic table outside also.
I ordered pizza the other night. The boy said 45 min for delivery. Waited an hour and 15 min still no pizza. So I call back. Kids says gonna be another 45 minutes to an hour because driver has more calls coming in. I canceled order and will try again later. Pizza there is my favorite in town so will try again another time
Benny Spears
Hands down the worst place to order from ordered at 6:20 it's now 5 after 8:00 what kind of pizza place is this they cancel my order because they couldn't find my address it's not even two blocks away from them!!!!!
Service: 1
Drpy
Hands down our fave! Never is there not a smiling face! Andrew can brighten the worst of days! And the food is fantastic. Just an all around good experience. ALWAYS SUPPORT LOCAL! They support all our area youth programs also which is another reason why we support! Won't be disappointed by eating here!
This was by far the best pizza my boyfriend and I encountered while in Nelsonville, OH. We ordered our custom pizza from Andrew, who was professional, welcoming and very accommodating. Our pizza came out exactly how we had ordered it, and the ingredients were tasty, fresh and good quality. The pricing for the food there is also extremely good value. This is truly a gem in this small Ohio community. We highly recommend it if you are passing through the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Shane RN
Ordered Pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers... Received just pepperoni. Disappointed, but decent pizza all the same.
I order from the New Straitsville location. The food is always good and the staff is always friendly. I also like having an option that delivers! Gotta feed my little pizza monster! 😆
Amazing place! The smell of the pizza is so tantalizing you can't help but have something!
I had their Pizza Sub, extra cheese!
The sauce is amazing, the sub bun was cooked to perfection! The cheese was perfectly melted and the pepperoni had the perfect texture you would expect, and the flavor was perfectly balanced!
The service was fast and friendly!
Clean (huge!) dining area, kitchen was in order and well maintained bathroom!
I love supporting small businesses and this one is absolutely Top Notch!
If you are out in the Lake Hope area, and looking for a great meal, with high quality food, fast friendly service, look no further! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub
I love their food. But… my last two orders have been literal nightmares. Starting last week I ordered on a busy night I’ll give them that. I call after patiently waiting 2 hours I get told they forgot about me and that my food is sitting there. After having to sub an item out. I’ll admit I was upset and simply just hung up. So without prompting they bring this food that had been in the bag under a heat lamp for who knows how long. Bun soggy the chicken wings they subbed out had so much sauce I coulda drank it. Then tonight. I call to get my replacement. Order the food long wait. Have no worries I just simply want there food I can wait. Hour and 45 minutes goes by I call they say 25 more minutes with an initial wait time of 1:30. They call me back a few minutes later to tell me they don’t have what i ordered. Wonderful. Super glad that my favorite restaurant has new management and this is how it’s going.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
And The Help was nice as me.wahooooooo
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a great experience at Little Italy Pizza. The staff was friendly and the food was so good. Will return again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you can't make more orders, shut down your online ordering or atleast have the decency to call me and tell me you won't be making my food. Put the order in 40 minutes before close and didn't realize it would never be coming until 40 minutes after the delivery time. I like your food but this is bullshit.
I walked in and they guy was supper welcoming. Was short handed tonight and seemed busy! We ordered a 14 inch pizza with pep and banana peppers along with a chicken parm. The food was excellent. The chicken parm my wife loved and had plenty of flavor! With us being from Buffalo the pizza was slamming! The sauce was awsome and had a little sweet to it! I just wanna say that I would absolutely recommend this place for pizza! Well done sir!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza
Visited Hocking Hills (Nelsonville) from Detroit area- daily pizza eaters here! Little Italy (Nelsonville) definitely made it to my list of top 5 favorite pizzas I’ve ever eaten!🍕😍
Andrew was amazing! He was doing everything there....answering phones, waiting tables, cooking, running the drive thru....he was non-stop busy while we were there. He deserves alot more than what he's making an hour.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Pepperoni Sausage Banana Peppers Pizza, Salad
After traveling several hours from MI, we checked into our hotel and started searching for places to grab a bite. It is a Sunday at 7:30, so not much was open, but Little Italy was there for us! Andrew was an excellent and attentive server. We got our food quickly, and it was delicious. We tried the "cheesy potato" pizza, cheese bread and garden salad. All of it was fresh and done to perfection! If you're staying near Hocking Hills, be sure to check out Little Italy!
Kid-friendliness: The dining area is spacious, there is a picnic table outside also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Bread, Cheesy Potato, Pizza, Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered pizza the other night. The boy said 45 min for delivery. Waited an hour and 15 min still no pizza. So I call back. Kids says gonna be another 45 minutes to an hour because driver has more calls coming in. I canceled order and will try again later. Pizza there is my favorite in town so will try again another time
Hands down the worst place to order from ordered at 6:20 it's now 5 after 8:00 what kind of pizza place is this they cancel my order because they couldn't find my address it's not even two blocks away from them!!!!!
Service: 1
Hands down our fave! Never is there not a smiling face! Andrew can brighten the worst of days! And the food is fantastic. Just an all around good experience. ALWAYS SUPPORT LOCAL! They support all our area youth programs also which is another reason why we support! Won't be disappointed by eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Bread, Pretzel Sticks, Supreme Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Sub, Pizza, Pepperoni Sausage Banana Peppers Pizza, Salad
This was by far the best pizza my boyfriend and I encountered while in Nelsonville, OH. We ordered our custom pizza from Andrew, who was professional, welcoming and very accommodating. Our pizza came out exactly how we had ordered it, and the ingredients were tasty, fresh and good quality. The pricing for the food there is also extremely good value. This is truly a gem in this small Ohio community. We highly recommend it if you are passing through the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Ordered Pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers... Received just pepperoni. Disappointed, but decent pizza all the same.
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...