The Pie Shell

Name: The Pie Shell
Address: 468 S Washington St, New Bremen, Ohio, 45869, US
Telephone: (419) 629-2625
Price range: $
Rating: 5

$ • Bakery

Hours:
468 S Washington St, New Bremen
(419) 629-2625

About The Pie Shell

The Pie Shell is a well-known bakery where passion and talent are evident in its products and service. The restaurant offers a variety of pies, including a standout New York cheesecake that is perfect for special occasions. Customers praise the crust, describing it as homemade and buttery, and highlight the wide selection of pies available, often sold by the slice when in stock. The bakery also sells several kinds of amazing cheesecake, flavored popcorns, cupcakes, and other treats. Many customers find the pies and cupcakes awesome and mention that they are always fresh and delicious. They often call ahead to order additional pies not usually on the shelf, and some have brought treats like pumpkin pecan crumble pies to family gatherings, which are always a hit. The bakery is known for fast, friendly service, and the place is always clean and busy, with plenty of paved, flat parking nearby. Visitors note how spotless the business is, and the desserts, such as chocolate peanut butter cupcakes and old-fashioned custard pie, stand out as favorites. The bakery has a strong community connection, supporting local families and events like a Dad’s celebration of life. Many customers appreciate the quality and taste of every item, including scotcheroos and other baked goods that are hard to resist. The bakery is mainly a carryout spot, with a reputation for delicious products, making it a favorite destination for pie lovers and those seeking tasty baked treats.