14 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Lexington

“We got two large pepperoni pizzas and they were really good! Only critique is I wished there was a bit more sauce but overall we were pleased, definitely will be back.“

“Love going for breakfast and listing to Loretta sing while she cooks beautiful voice“

“I order here all the time, mostly online sometimes in person. The people that take care of me are fabulous. They put up with my jokes and sometimes bad humor and never miss a beat. My food has never been wrong, cold or late. Recommend this place at anytime. The crew here rocks, thanks guys, you’re the main reason I keep coming back.“

“The atmosphere in this little place is absolutely incredible! You feel like you're in an old-time western as you sit and eat. The food was good. I had the ribeye and was satisfied with the sear flavor and size. Everything was seasoned just right. The only reason I gave it 4 out of 5 stars is because My sides were a little cold but nothing I couldn't handle. I wish more people would support this local steakhouse as the owner is cool as all get out and they are just a small business in the middle of nowhere Trying to make it and survive after the COVID crisis that hit right when they opened unfortunately.

Vegetarian options: They have vegetarian options like stuffed bell peppers, jalapeno poppers, different vegetable sides and salads.

Parking: Parking in the front and the sides easy to access from The main Street.

Kid-friendliness: Kids will love this restaurant. It has the most unique decorations and atmosphere around this area.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp in the front with plenty of room for a wheelchair.“

“I ordered an Italian sub and it was amazing .And James the man that delivered it was so cool..I'll definitely order again...And when I called in to order the lady on the phone was very friendly ...“

“Modern remodel of a classic Pizza Hut restaurant! Friendly, fast and efficient service. Very clean store inside and out. Restrooms were in excellent condition and well maintained both Men’s and Women’s. Great pizza that comes straight to your table right out of the oven piping hot! Wait at least 5 minutes before attempting to eat it. That’s how hot it arrives at your table! Highly recommended for lunch or dinner!“

“Nice staff like Randi, good taste food with affordable price!“

“The best pizza around!! I work in Lancaster and live in Zanesville so I stopped the first time because it was on my way home. I have been hooked ever since! Keep up the good work Montell’s!“

“love pizza and best wings in town!!“

“We had it for the first time tonight and it was delicious!!“

“Very good food, will definitely be back, we got take out and it was still delicious!“

“No one can replace Pat wohrle and his carryout, but the new resurrected Shawnee crossing carryout holds strong, it's clean , the employees are friendly, down to earth, not to Mention the owners themselves, very nice and polite , couldn't talk to a more friendly set of owners“

“friendly staff great food 😋“

“We order a few times a month from Little Italy in New Straitville. It's also very fresh and the delivery drivers are also so kind and appreciative of any tip! We love the dill pickle pizza and the Cheesy potato pizza 🍕 The cheesy bread is also 10/10 !“