22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newton Falls

“Absolutely blown away by the quality, taste, and service!! We just had Tiger Den for the first time. We got our pizza from there for our daughter's birthday party...And kids and adults alike kept coming up to me and my husband asking where the pizza was from!! So delicious!! And at great prices!! Thank you, Tiger Den, for not only being present in the community, but excellent in what do!! We will definitely be repeat customers!!“

“Pizza is yummy and like that I can earn free pizza by creating a pizza profile and I love that I can save favorite pizzas I've ordered. I also like that I can donate the change in my order to St Jude. The website could be a little more user friendly to flow from one screen to another and not just on some screens. I still have to figure out how I can use my free pizza points. It's looks like I cannot access my saved pizzas to order and cannot add the free pizza to the end of my order, so I'm guessing I will have to create 2 orders and write down all the toppings and sauce from what I want to order the free one in 1 order and then go back and create a new order for my 2nd pizza, kinda a pain. The app is not better. I could not access my saved pizzas at all which is one of the perks of having a profile and adding the app to your phone. Also when I called the store they didn't know anything about the app or online experience kind of poor training. When I redeemed my free pizza, it would not let me upgrade the size like it has in the past for an additional charge and at checkout it did not let me redeem my free pizza, so I ended up paying for a medium that I normally would not have ordered and why I placed the order to begin with was because of the free pizza email I recieved.“

“Great pizza, chicken and JoJo's and friendly service!“

“Place is always great at being... well- Being the corner store pizza place

I can only imagine someone rating this poorly has some outrageous hatred for one particular staff or something, Given the factor Ive seen this have low review scores (At the time of writing)

Honest opinion? Better then the road downwards pizza hut and dominos unless you want a stuff crust for some reason“

“I have had some issues in the past and they always fix it! But we just ordered pizza and wings and it's the best pizza we have had from pizza hut! I even called to ask who made the pizza after we got home.. her name is Savanah..great job!“

“Best of both worlds here!!! Great tasting pizza and accompanied by rich and creamy ice-cream!!! This is a great place to have classic pizza options and then order some amazing ice-cream creations! The owners are super friendly and make you want to come back!“

“Food is delicious and the owner and staff are very friendly!“

“Around this area, there's not too many corner stores to do a quick pit stop. Not only does Lordstown Comeback have refreshments, but they have pizza you can buy at lunch hours, or order ahead for carry-out. Check it out, it's not too far from the Lordstown turnpike exit.“

“Stoneys consistently delivers delicious, fresh pizzas with a perfectly cooked crust, generous toppings, and flavorful sauce; the awesome staff and quick service make it a local favorite for a satisfying meal🍕❤️“

“They did originally make us the wrong type of pizza and didn't realize it til I got home but most of that I think was my step dad's fault cause he talks to much and is confusing lol but I called took it back and explained what I actually wanted and they made it perfectly correct and apologized and didn't charge us. The pizza tasted AMAZING. MY NEW FAV SPOT FOR PIZZA. MY DAUGHTERS LOVED IT TOO“

“I ordered a chicken salad on my way home from work. Walked and super fast. It was awesome. And the big chunk of bread……so yummy. It was huge too. Having the rest for lunch tomorrow 😊“

“im trying to apply and be one of your members at Cal's . i was wondering if anybody or anyone knows how to apply?, its greatly appreciated.“

“Great pizza, chicken and JoJo's! Great service. We have never had an issue!“

“My husband went into cardiac arrest while working on a house he was framing, and was luckily revived by the crew at an adjacent fire department. The incident happened in Bristol, but we are residents of Garrettsville. The town rallied around us to support us in a time of need. Domino's found out that the G-Men wrestling team was helping take care of our horse barn and provided them with free pizza. I am so thankful for the generosity.“

“I have been going here since I was young, the food is SO good! The staff is so nice and the whole atmosphere is so welcoming. The pizza is amazing as well as the pasta! Yum😋 My family of 5 usually spend around $80 all together which is not bad at all for 2 adults and 3 teenagers. Mauro is so friendly and welcoming and always greets us when we arrive. Such a wonderful guy! Jessica is the best waitress, you can’t tell me otherwise! My mom and dad chose to do their wedding here, my mom said,” I trusted them to make it stress free”. The sauce is soooo good we get it all the time for pasta nights! Joe deserves a round of applause, he’s so nice and makes the best food! Love you Joe🫶“

“this is one of milton's gems. Great food, great people, and a cozy location.“

“I absolutely love this pizza ! The only things that annoy me is that you apparently have the kids weigh everything.
Un 1979 I worked at a little Italian pizza shop .
We PILED on the toppings and cheese !
Maybe loosen up a little and let them put enough of both on to at LEAST cover the pizza .“

“Always fast and hot!! Thank you Domino’s“

“Had a mishap with my order tonight. Called and spoke with a very kind gentleman that apologized for the mistake and expedited our order. everything was hot and delicious and we're truly appreciative. great customer service truly makes all the difference.“

“Ive never had a better pizza! Great crust.“

“Best BBQ Chicken Pizza out there. Another company that answered hello!! Why are coming people answering their employers phone with hello. Train your people better, very awkward, why do i have to ask if I called the right place?

Come on Owners..... Get your kids to answer the phone Pizza Joe's.. Not dead silence when I call.. Then he is a total douche bag.. Your pizza is great the service is not. They make you want to call someone else.

Pay with cash it's a little bit cheaper. They charge more for credit card/debit card.“

“We used their catering service for 2 different events. Both events the food was delicious and plenty of it. We were very satisfied. We had many people ask who catered the food because they thought it was great. The prices are very fair too. Thank you!! 😊“