33 Best Ice Cream Shops near Newtown

“Just a classic, neighborhood whippy dip.
I've gone to this dairy corner my whole life amd it's just as good now as the first time I had it as a little kid!

Parking: Parking lot is VERY small.
On a busy day/night the lot fills rather quickly“

“The ice cream and experience were fantastic! The perfect place to stop for a sweet treat to celebrate, or just to brighten your day. The service was wonderful, the owners are so kind, radiating joy and passion. Everything I’ve had here is amazing. The cookie dough is nostalgic, the ice cream is creamy and perfectly sweet. Don’t even get me started on the shakes! They’re some of the best I’ve ever had. I’m not a fan of coffee even but the Java whip knocked my socks off! The atmosphere is the cherry on top, eclectic, cute, and inviting. If I could, I’d be there everyday!“

“Delicious icecream, brownies and cookies. Friendly staff. Fast service. A++ addition to the icecream scene in Cincinnati.“

“If you’re an ice cream lover like I am, then you’ve likely heard about the sumptuous creations from Jeni’s Ice Cream. Recently, I had the pleasure of trying out their newest location, and let me tell you, it has quickly become my go-to spot for a sweet treat!

From the moment you step into Jeni’s, you’re greeted by a vibrant and inviting atmosphere that perfectly reflects the fun and memorable experience that the ice cream promises. The selection of flavors is nothing short of extraordinary. They push the boundaries of traditional ice cream, featuring both classic and unique options that cater to every palate. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting scoop of Green Mint Chip or something more adventurous like their Biscuits & Peach Jam, there is something to intrigue everyone.

What truly sets Jeni’s apart is their commitment to quality. The ingredients are exceptionally sourced, and you can taste the difference with every creamy, rich bite. It’s clear that no corners are cut; each flavor is thoughtfully crafted to deliver a luxurious experience. Yes, the prices might be a tad higher than your average ice cream joint, but the quality you receive completely justifies the cost. It’s not just ice cream; it’s a gourmet experience!

Before Jeni’s opened its doors locally, I used to drive all the way to Columbus just to enjoy their delectable offerings. Having this top-notch ice cream available in my hometown has been a game-changer. It feels like a true gift to our community, making special occasions even sweeter and ordinary days feel a little more indulgent.

In conclusion, Jeni’s Ice Cream is a delightful addition that elevates our local food scene. With its incredible flavor variety, premium ingredients, and commitment to excellence, it’s easy to understand why it has become a beloved favorite. Whether you’re having a rough day or just in the mood for something special, make sure to treat yourself to the deliciousness that is Jeni’s – this gem is worth every penny!“

“In Hamilton we love having Aglamesis. Friendly competent service, great ice cream and chocolates. We wish you much success ….“

“One of my favorites. Plenty of seating and it's always clean. The staff are friendly and engaging. This is a larger location. Attached party room / play area. Parking is a challenge. Hands down the world's greatest ice cream. Donuts and other treats look tempting, but always good ice cream. More expensive than some other options, the quality reflects the price and the portions are generous.
If they are hosting birthday parties, you will struggle to find a parking space.“

“never had this until the food truck rally in Springfield...probably THE best frozen yogurt I've ever had...would highly recommend“

“The Best ice cream in the world and a fun time at Dog’s Night Out!“

“We booked the Hello Honey ice cream cart for our wedding reception, and it was an absolute hit! We couldn’t recommend their service for events more. Having three custom flavors alongside one of their signature menu options made for a unique and delicious treat that our guests couldn’t stop raving about. Not only was the ice cream itself incredible, but the cart added such a fun, interactive element to our reception. It was the perfect way to share a taste of local Cincinnati flavor with our out-of-town guests, and they loved it! If you’re looking for a memorable, crowd-pleasing addition to your event, Hello Honey’s ice cream cart is the way to go!“

“A real ice cream treat. Unique fresh flavors and light taste. please support this local creamery.“

“Great place for ice cream.“

“In Hamilton we love having Aglamesis. Friendly competent service, great ice cream and chocolates. We wish you much success ….“

“I ordered the s'mores milkshake......it was delicious“

“A Cincinnati institution since 1870. Delicious ice cream!“

“Stopped in during our vacation for the blueberry soft serve. YUM!! Very creamy and smooth, mild blueberry flavor. Highly recommend!!“

“Their cookies are so good!

Vegetarian options: Their cookies don’t have meat so they’re vegetarian.

Kid-friendliness: I mean kids love cookies plus they have new small cookies so it’s perfect for kids.“

“Best dessert place there is! I have bought the 4oz minis for 2 family functions and they are always hit! We especially love the banana puddings! Not to mention the brownies are to die for!! Perfect tasty bites that remain me of the corners of the brownie pan! Can’t wait to try the shakes and cookies next!!“

“Beautiful place, healthy yogurt and friendly staff.“

“Incredible ice cream as rated by a total ice cream snob. I ordered a scoop of s'mores which was massive. Every component was delicious. Two benches outside to sit on. Staff were lovely. Would recommend for an ice cream and walk afternoon.“

“Mariemont is one of the cutest cities in Ohio and of course they have Cincinnati's iconic ice cream! My boyfriend and I love to ride our bikes here and grab some ice cream! My go to is the Cookie Monster Sundae! I don't see it on every Graeters menu, but I see it here, and it's my favorite! We love the atmosphere and bench seating outside!

Parking: Great easy parking across the street and around surrounding street parking. All around cross walks too.“

“Inside is super cute. 1/3 of the dispensers were being cleaned or inoperable, so choices were limited. The staff interactions were mixed; the one we encountered in the dining room who was working on the machines was nice but the “cashier” didn’t seem too thrilled to be there. Not rude, just not pumped. 😉

The frozen yogurt was tasty, though, and they have a TON of toppings!!!“

“I like Crumbl, I was glad to see a semi-sweet chocolate chip cookie with pecans this week, but a little disappointed that I can barely see any pecans in the cookie. I really hope there are more hiding inside the cookie. Why is it that the samples on the counter always look better than the ones you receive in your box?“

“We love everything about you!“

“Best dessert place there is! I have bought the 4oz minis for 2 family functions and they are always hit! We especially love the banana puddings! Not to mention the brownies are to die for!! Perfect tasty bites that remain me of the corners of the brownie pan! Can’t wait to try the shakes and cookies next!!“

“Best custard ice cream and delicious burgers �“

“This place seems to be crowded everytime I visit, but the line moves fairly fast. It is a treat's only location, so no food is offered, other than ice cream treats. Sometimes the line can be unorganized, so it is best to ask where the end of the line is, so you don't get skipped!

Parking: Parking lot can get congested at times, and people backing out usually have a treat to contend with. So, be extra cautious when parking and leaving the lot.“

“The typical great Dairy Queen ice cream served here. Prices are great! Service is quick and the place is well kept up and clean. Staff are friendly and helpful.“

“Stopped in Wednesday after hearing great things about the cookies. The employee greeted me with a big smile and she was so polite. The store was spotless but best of all these cookies were amazing!!!!!! Not good —-AMAZING! The strawberry was so good I almost wrestled my co-worker for the last one.If you haven’t stopped in or placed an order you should do so immediately. They would make a great gift for graduates, new home owners, new parents etc. if my family/friends see this my birthday is in October and cookies are a great idea. :-)**Vegan options available**“

“First time here and the food was so delicious. Very reasonably priced as well!“

“The lady working here was so nice to my 3 year old and I, helping us find a flavor he might enjoy since he's the only child I know that doesn't like ice cream lol. Thank you for your help and kindness. Need more people like this in the world.“

“Consistently Exceptional Service at Nekter – Thanks to Alex! For the past six years, I've visited Nekter five days a week, making it more than just a juice bar for me—it's a part of my daily routine. Today, I feel compelled to write this review, not just because of Nekter's consistently delicious offerings, but to highlight an extraordinary employee who makes every visit unforgettable—Alex. From the moment you meet Alex, it's clear he's not your average employee. His infectious smile and genuine enthusiasm are evident from the get-go. Alex's approach to service is unmatched; he truly makes you feel like a friend, not just a customer. He remembers my name, asks about my day, and our conversations never feel rushed or routine. It's rare to encounter someone who exudes such natural charisma and joy in their work. Alex’s exceptional customer service has profoundly impacted my experience at Nekter. His attention to detail and consistent friendliness enhance the already welcoming atmosphere of the store. Whether it's his quick service, insightful recommendations, or just a cheerful greeting, Alex consistently goes above and beyond. Nekter itself deserves praise for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, but it's employees like Alex who breathe life into this ethos. His dedication is a significant reason why I keep coming back and why each visit is as enjoyable as the last. For anyone looking for not just a great juice or smoothie but a genuinely delightful service experience, head to Nekter and see Alex. You’ll understand why it’s more than just a place to grab a drink—it’s a highlight of the day, thanks to people like him.“

“The place was nice and clean. And business as usual. The customer service wasnt bad either, but there was just a sense of, customers being a nuance, feel. Maybe it's just my personal opinion, and I wasn't expecting rainbows and unicorns but, at least smile a little.“