Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
3219 Seaman Rd, Oregon
(419) 277-4010

About Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasy's offers a delicious thin crust pizza with a chewy dough that is not tough. The sauce strikes a balance between sweet and Italian flavors, and is evenly dispersed. The pizza features plentiful cheese that holds the toppings well, preventing them from sliding off. They offer a variety of unique toppings, including pierogi pizza and pepperoni, which customers find amazing. The seasonal pierogi pizza is highly recommended and considered a great choice all year round. The restaurant has a fun vibe and serves quality ice cream, which customers have praised as delicious and worth trying. One customer, who is diabetic, noted that their pizza raised their sugar to 140, lower than other thin crust options they have tried. The staff is friendly and helpful, making the experience enjoyable, and prices are seen as very good for the quality of food. This place is quickly becoming a favorite for many, with some calling it the Toledo area's best kept secret.

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

4.8
84 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
82%
4
8%
3
6%
1
4%
Food
4.7
Atmosphere
4.7
Service
4.6

Share your opinion about Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

Restaurantji Rating

Pizza is great, we love their ice cream and the kids working for them are amazing. Great place. We love it. It’s our go to spot when we want a delicious pizza fast!

This pizza is AMAZING!

Listen, I know garbage when I see it.....and this is NOT garbage!

This classic, and arguably thin, pizza is baked perfectly! The right amount of pizza sauce combined with the perfect amount of cheese makes my mouth water EVERY time!

I must admit that the employees here are absolutely amazing as well! They are always so helpful & so friendly.

My ONLY complaint is that the pizza box is square and it makes it difficult to...read full review

This pizza is AMAZING!

Listen, I know garbage when I see it.....and this is NOT garbage!

This classic, and arguably thin, pizza is baked perfectly! The right amount of pizza sauce combined with the perfect amount of cheese makes my mouth water EVERY time!

I must admit that the employees here are absolutely amazing as well! They are always so helpful & so friendly.

My ONLY complaint is that the pizza box is square and it makes it difficult to...read full review

Read All Reviews(77)

Menu

Add a Menu
Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's Menu
Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's
Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9:30PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 11AM - 9:30PM
Friday 11AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 9:30PM
Sunday 11AM - 9:30PM
Updated on: