The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH

$$ • Caribbean, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly

Hours:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-In-Bay
(419) 285-5397

About The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH

The Keys, located in Put-in-Bay, OH, offers a lively atmosphere and great service. While the food may be a bit pricey, the portion sizes are generous and the quality is generally good. The restaurant has a lovely setting, with an outside bar and live music, as well as open air seating inside. Customers have enjoyed the seafood options, such as mahi mahi tacos, grouper, perch basket, and conch fritters, all described as delicious and on point. The atmosphere is described as super cool and close to the real Keys, with strong drinks and street corn dip adding to the experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, with some customers noting excellent service, even helping with unexpected issues like printing a paper ID. On certain nights, the restaurant offers deals on flatbreads and frozen drinks, making it a more affordable option. Overall, The Keys is a must-visit spot for anyone in Put-in-Bay, known for its great food, lively ambiance, and welcoming staff.

Customers' Favorites

The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH Reviews

4.2
264 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
69%
4
14%
3
5%
2
3%
1
9%
Food
4.3
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
4.3

Share your opinion about The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH

Restaurantji Rating

Read All Reviews(264)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH Menu
The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH
The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 7PM
Tuesday 11AM - 7PM
Wednesday 11AM - 7PM
Thursday 11AM - 7PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 11AM - 7PM
Updated on: