East of Chicago Pizza

94 N Main St, Rittman
(330) 925-3278

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Neil Rainey

Nice place to get pizza. The subs are great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Parrish

while waiting on our pizza they where kind enough to give me a bottle of water to make my son a bottle for the wait!! excellent place. kind people.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Rhonda Hines

They screwed up our order AGAIN! We ordered 2 weeks ago, they screwed it up. They corrected it. Ordered again today & screwed it up again! My husband graciously paid for their screwup along with the correct order. Asked for owners name & contact information, they are not allowed to give that out. Never ordering again!!

Jack

They gave me the wrong pizza and didn't toast my outrageously expensive sub sandwiches. They always screw something up here. east of chciago is very good, just not this location. This location will burn your pizza or you will get a raw dough pizza. I dont know whats wrong with their oven or if its operator error over there, or they just dont care, but they give East of Chicago a bad name

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza

Kevin Rogers

Every time I try to order from here it's cash only. And never have online ordering available. Haven't been able to try the food in a long time due to this so I cannot rate the food.

Teri Vinson

$40.00, everything was cold, had to heat pizza & garlic bread for 20 minutes in oven, had to heat mozzarella sticks & popcorn chicken in air fryer. Ordered crispy crust got thin crust, like a cracker. If I wanted to cook I wouldn’t have ordered out. We’re Giononos fans but decided to try another local pizza place, never again ?

amanda stackhouse

Said order would be delivered 45 minutes to a hour and still haven't gotten our food a hour and 15 minutes later

Bryan George

Good pizza and subs.

Cheryl Whiting

East of Chicago has always been a favorite of mine. Don't get to eat from there very often anymore. Everything has gotten so expensive. If we could afford it, I wouldn't mind eating from there once a month, maybe more.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Chicken Wings, Chicago Style Medium 12

Holly Newkirk

First was a raw pizza that wasn't even cut, the correction for it was a fight. Tonight I've waited and hour and half, called and they had no idea of delivery time even though I was told 45 mins

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Tom Pummell

Place is terrible. Don’t answer phone. Never take cards. Cash only like 1986. Don’t waste your time.

Unknown

This place is filled with great workers, always hard at work never giving up, id trust this business is really building from the people and atmosphere around them, thx to all who work there.(“next time tipping 15$ just to say thx”)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Stuffed Pepperoni Foldover, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Cinnapops

Nancy Love

So, did a online order at 8:13 pm said 30 minutes. Arrived at 8:45 pm door was locked then a young man come to door and was asked did you get my online order and his response was... Haven't got any scene 3 pm ( people order I'm sure) and showed me a tablet with black screen. Not 1st time that this has happened so with that being said I'll take my business else where. Hello Fox pizza! This place is a joke and so are the employees. Won't recommend or order from here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Denise Harkness

Take out great food.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Deluxe Pizza

david fields

Ordered a pizza for delivery and not only was it over an hour and no pizza deliveredbut we called at 9and they were closed so we didn’t even have a chance to order from a different place.Everybody at that place is a piece of garbage.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...