15 Best Italian Restaurants near Sheffield Lake

“Ordered 3 pizzas today; they were scrumptiously delicious. Thank you for the gr8 employees and being so convenient and very reasonable prices.“

“Almost perfect every time!
Wonderful food and WARM CRUSTY BREAD.
Usually, we have to ask for cocktail napkins...lol...first world problems... otherwise, we love going there.
Veal Fratello and Shrimp Fratello are our favorites.
Also... the Calamari.“

“Food was wonderful and portions are huge! Great desserts and salads are amazing. Excellent service! Will be back.“

“Disappointed in meatballs. Recipe not same as before. Too much filler maybe breadcrumbs and lesss meat!!! Go back to original recipe. Miss Miller Lite also!“

“We recently celebrated our 50th wedding anniversary at Aticas’ Italian restaurant in Avon. The job that Erin, did in making the arrangements for our 17 guests in their private room went well beyond our expectations. Celia, the waitress did an outstanding job serving both the adult and children's menu requests. The staff on a whole made sure that the day would be special for us. The Arancini on their antipasti menu were exceptional as were any of the Secondi dishes. We would happily return and would highly recommend the restaurant to others.“

“We love it here, so much we ate here twice this week. The pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had and the customer service is fantastic. I can’t recommend this place enough. We will be frequenting Olde Town Pizza often!“

“Server must of been new. 2 of us ask for no onions an no tomato in our salad. So she brought condiments on the side WHY? Plus we were charged ea for salad but have to share 2bowls with 6 other people. Don't understand that at all. No mgr available to tt. Will not go back. We were a party if 12 .“

“Went to a party here..food and service were excellent…food out quickly and tasted great…servers were so friendly and efficient“

“Delicious! Definitely will be back!“

“We stayed in Elyria 4 The night & The motel worker recommended this pizza place 2 us. I am so glad she did , cuz The pizza was amazing. Very delicious. & Very friendly delivery, right 2 e room . If ur In the area & Looking 4 a good pizza , I would highly recommend u Ordering from here . When we’re in the area again, we will definitely get another pizza . Delicious“

“We had a party of 17 for lunch. Everyone loved it!! The food was delicious, it was very clean and comfortable, and the service was excellent! Highly recommend! Everyone in our group wants to come back. Thank you for the great meal and making our family get together a great one!!“

“I stopped by WB Pizza yesterday during lunch I ordered a large meat lovers pizza, pan crust, which is their thick crust. I had a few questions. The manager answered them, she was very polite and took time to take care of me. I was very pleased with my choice. The food was amazing. I will be returning.“

“So I'm a regular here I'd say 🤣 I order a good amount of times, never an issue. Yesterday I ordered on the app and put pay in store, I was gonna use a debit card, their machines were down everywhere, they took my name and number and trusted me, I didn't get a call before I went up there today to pay what was owed. The manager I usually see everytime was going to just give me the food but I respected what they did and paid it. They are all really great, friendly ppl. Download the app if you love their pizza like me!“

“Very accessible. The food was hot and fresh. Even the pizza ? sauce had spices. Really impressive! I asked for my pie to have cheese to the edge - done. Let's top it off that your pie is sitting on parchment paper!!! Not cardboard. I'll gladly return and pay for these extras.“

“Delicious! We ordered the garden salad with house Italian, a pepperoni butter crust pizza, a Sicilian pepperoni pizza, and the Italian donuts.

The garden salad was very basic and dressing was a simple vinegar forward house Italian. Fresh ingredients in the salad, so I can’t complain!

The Sicilian was very good, square pizza with crispy oily pepperonis… but the star for me is the butter crust! It has so much sauce on the top, it is absolutely delish! The sauce is sweet and very homemade tasting, it feels like you’re eating a homemade Italian dish! Currently trying to resist eating thirds as we speak!

My only complaint is the Italian donuts tasted exactly like a cut up breadstick tossed in cinnamon sugar. I was expecting like a soft doughy donut. Prepackaged icing, nothing to write home about. I was expecting something more homemade tasting but they were reminiscent of something from Pizza Hut or the like.

We did a pick up order and it was ready very quickly!

Overall, I’m totally coming back for that butter crust style pizza and would love to try their chicken offerings as well!“