6 Best Bakeries near Sugarcreek

“Delicious and fresh sooo good!“

“Hands down the best cinnamon roll I've ever eaten! Don't expect the owner to fawn all over you. There are a lot of reviews here about her being rude, but my Mom and I have been here a couple times over the last 2 years, the cinnamon rolls are amazing and she was perfectly polite to us.“

“My all time favorite place to dine in Amish country! Fried chicken was piping hot out of the fryer as I like it! Deborah was our outstanding waitress. Only thing missing were stewed/creamed tomatos! I visit from Apple Valley Lake Howard Ohio at least once a season! Enjoy the theatres as well when time permits!“

“the custard filled donuts and breakfast sandwiches are so delicious...also all the donuts are always so fresh...I go to Kauffmans Bakery every time I come to the Amish..it's worth it“

“4 of us dined at Der Dutchman on December 27, 2025. We each chose the buffet as our entrees. The food was hot and fresh and the selection exceeded our expectations. Our server was Ruby and she greeted us as soon as we were seated. She was one of the most pleasant servers I have ever had at a restaurant. She kept our drinks refilled and made sure we were happy with our meals. I want to give her a personal thanks for making our meal so delightful.“