10 Best Bakeries in Wooster

Miss Amy's Bakery Bakery • $
1494 E Smithville Western Rd suite c, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Macaron Peanut Butter Chocolate Macaron
Chocolate Salted Caramel Pretzel Cupcake
Assorted Holiday Cake Pop Box
Dozen Triple Berry Scones
Dozen Assorted Cupcakes
Gluten Free Cupcakes
Creme Brulee Macaron
Carrot Cake Blondie
Cinnamon Rolls
Birthday Cake

“We recently used them for our wedding cake and cupcakes. They had so many flavors to choose from and were very easy to work with. The cupcakes and cake were beautiful and my guests were very impressed by the presentation of the cupcakes! The flavors were good and the cakes were moist. Thank you!“

4.9 Superb77 Reviews
Troyer's Home Pantry II Bakery • $
319 E North St, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Rhubarb Pie

“For the last 20 years I've been buying large orders off and on for the office so I am a little late on this review. The maple roll (I think they call it cinnamon roll), pumpkin bar, apple fritter, and cream sticks are the best on the planet. And I believe everyone in the office agrees. I've seen their products at convenience stores and it is awesome however, there's nothing like fresh direct from the Apple Creek or Wooster store at 6-7am. I spent $40 which will easily satisfy 20 of us. The Wooster store is tiny. I only ever get carry out and the service is outstanding.“

4.9 Superb18 Reviews
Cookie Snob Bakery •
Suit101, Freeman Building, 201 E Liberty St, Wooster

“They are always delicious! Also the Wayne county saddle club super appreciates your donation! Thanks for supporting the club!“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Broken Rocks Café & Bakery Bakery • $
123 E Liberty St, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Chocolate Custard
Raspberry Creme Brulee
Olive Oil and Bread
Wild Mushroom Pasta
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Charcuterie Board
Bananas Foster
Fish Sandwich
Cajun Chicken
Tiramisu Cake

“Everything was really good except the time of food prep. We were one of maybe 4 tables in the whole restaurant and it took nearly 30 min after we put in our order to get an omelette and an egg sandwich. I love this place, but I hope they make some adjustments to that part of the process.“

4.5 Superb104 Reviews
The Faithful Little Cupcake Cupcake shop • $
838 East Milltown Road, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Cut Out Cookies
Wedding Cake
Cupcake

“I am in trouble!! Lol This is right around the corner from Baylobster! Gonna go broke from both being so close! I will be back... Yum!!!“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Auntie Anne's Pretzel Store • $
3883 Burbank Rd Suite 1, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pretzel Nuggets Bucket
Pretzel Nugget Bucket Snack Pack
Original Pretzel Nuggets Bucket
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Nuggets
Jalapeño & Cheese Pretzel Dog
Sweet Almond Pretzel
Honey Mustard Dip
Cheese Dip

“I love going to this one because it's local and I usually don't have an issue at this location. However, the last trip I made earlier tonight was not so good. They refused to make the pretzel I wanted even though there was still about a half hour until closing, and then when I asked for one they already made, they gave me the wrong one. Next time I think I'll go during the day time when the supervisor is still working.“

4.5 Superb45 Reviews
Cheesecakery Wooster Bakery • $$
715 Callowhill St, Wooster

“the ordering was easy the excellent customer service. delivery. very good and the cheesecake so creamy and delicious u have to try it thank you again“

4.6 Superb9 Reviews
Butter & Fire Bakery Bakery •
1218 S Honeytown Rd, Wooster

“I stopped at Local Roots and happened to pick up a blueberry lemon coffee cake today. Let me tell you, it was absolutely DELICIOUS! I will definitely have to stop back and try something else sometime soon!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Undergrounds Café & Coffee House Cafe • $
146 E Liberty St, Wooster

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich

“This is a very nice coffee shop with a variety of brunch sandwiches. They have gluten free bread too, which is great. They have a design your own breakfast sandwich, which includes, eggs, a meat, a cheese, and spreads, such as avocado, pesto, mayo ect. The prices are comparable to most restaurants. I highly recommend this cafe.“

4.7 Superb30 Reviews
10

Meijer

Meijer Bakery •
4845 Burbank Road, Wooster

“Started preferring this store to GE because the produce is almost always fresh, and GE has been more miss than hit. They also tend to carry what I need when I'm feeling adventurous in the kitchen, but even with the unique items they do have in stock, I still occasionally have to go to other stores to find everything I need.“

4.2 Good165 Reviews