6 Best Bakeries near Sugarcreek

“We ate at Dutch Valley restaurant on Sept.30, 2026. The food was very disappointing. Do the Amish prepare any of the food? Doesn't seem like the same quality as I remembered.“

“Delicious and fresh sooo good!“

“an excellent bakery, and the owner makes excellent coffee. stop in when in Sugarcreek Ohio. this is truly a great shop“

“the custard filled donuts and breakfast sandwiches are so delicious...also all the donuts are always so fresh...I go to Kauffmans Bakery every time I come to the Amish..it's worth it“

“After a day of shopping our last stop was dinner at Der Dutchman Restaurant. The food was delicious and Mardella, our server was the best. She was very helpful, kind, and very accommodating. I would give her a 10+“